Briefly explain causes of diseconomies of scale.
CAMBRIDGE
A level and AS level
Year Examined
February/March 2017
Topic
Business Growth & Strategy
👑Complete Model Essay
Diseconomies of Scale: An In-Depth Analysis
Diseconomies of scale, a concept central to business studies, refer to the point at which a firm's further expansion leads to an increase in average costs. This essay will delve into the causes of diseconomies of scale, focusing on the challenges inherent in managing large organizations.
Management Challenges and Communication Barriers
One of the primary drivers of diseconomies of scale lies in the complexities of managing sprawling organizations. As a firm grows, it often necessitates the establishment of multiple departments, divisions, and geographical locations. This expansion can strain communication channels, leading to a phenomenon known as "communication diseconomies of scale."
Large companies often resort to impersonal communication methods like mass emails and memos, which can lack the clarity and immediacy of face-to-face interaction. Lengthy chains of command further exacerbate the problem, increasing the likelihood of message distortion and delays. For instance, a decision made at the top might undergo multiple interpretations as it trickles down to the operational level. This lack of effective communication can impede decision-making, hinder feedback mechanisms, and ultimately reduce managerial efficiency.
Example: Consider a multinational corporation like General Motors. With operations spanning continents and a vast workforce, ensuring seamless communication becomes a herculean task. A delay in conveying critical information from the headquarters to a manufacturing plant could disrupt production schedules and escalate costs.
Impersonal Operations and Employee Alienation
As firms expand, they often struggle to maintain a personal touch with their employees. The increasing size and bureaucratic structures can create a sense of anonymity, leading to employee demotivation and alienation. This is particularly true in industries heavily reliant on flow line manufacturing, where repetitive tasks can exacerbate feelings of detachment.
Example: The classic case of Ford's assembly lines in the early 20th century exemplifies this issue. While the scale of production was unprecedented, the monotonous work led to high worker dissatisfaction and turnover.
To mitigate these issues, businesses can adopt strategies like team-based work structures and job enrichment programs. These approaches foster a sense of ownership and belonging among employees, even within large organizations.
Coordination Challenges and Bureaucracy
Maintaining effective coordination becomes increasingly difficult as a firm grows. With multiple departments, divisions, and potentially conflicting goals, aligning efforts towards a shared vision can be challenging. The lack of coordination often results in duplication of effort, bureaucratic bottlenecks, and a disconnect between different parts of the organization.
Example: A large technology company might have different development teams working on similar projects without sufficient communication, leading to redundancy and wasted resources.
Furthermore, bureaucracy tends to increase with size. Complex approval processes, rigid hierarchies, and excessive paperwork can stifle innovation and slow down decision-making, ultimately increasing operational costs.
Top-Heavy Structures and Corporate Politics
As organizations become larger, they often become more hierarchical and "top-heavy." This can lead to a concentration of power at the top, potentially creating a disconnect between senior management and the realities of the operational levels. Decisions made in isolation from frontline experience can be misaligned with market needs and operational efficiency.
Additionally, large organizations can become breeding grounds for corporate politics. Internal power struggles, empire-building, and a focus on internal promotion over company goals can all contribute to inefficiencies and increased costs.
Conclusion
Diseconomies of scale represent a significant challenge for growing businesses. While achieving scale can offer numerous advantages, understanding and managing the potential downsides is crucial for sustained success. By recognizing the communication and coordination challenges, addressing employee morale concerns, and mitigating the risks of excessive bureaucracy and internal politics, companies can strive to maintain efficiency and cost-effectiveness even at large scales.
Briefly explain causes of diseconomies of scale.
Note: Business Studies Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured Business Studies Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
Business Studies Pack.
✅ Model Essays for past papers questions
✅Covers Cambridge Exam Boards
✅ Suitable for A Level
✅A Library of over 400 Essays
✅ Download all Essays in PDF format
...and much more!
Free Essay Plan 🍃
A-Level Business Studies Essay Guide: Diseconomies of Scale
This guide will help you write a strong A-Level Business Studies essay on the causes of diseconomies of scale. It will provide you with a clear understanding of the concept and equip you with the necessary knowledge and tips to craft a well-structured and insightful essay.
Understanding Diseconomies of Scale
Diseconomies of scale occur when a company experiences a decrease in efficiency and an increase in average production costs as it continues to grow in size. Essentially, the benefits of economies of scale start to diminish, and the company begins to face challenges that hinder its growth and profitability.
Key Causes of Diseconomies of Scale
Here are some key causes of diseconomies of scale, along with tips for addressing them:
1. Communication Breakdowns
Communication problems can become a significant issue in large organisations. As the size of a company grows, it becomes increasingly difficult to maintain effective communication channels. This can lead to:
- Excessive use of non-personal communication: Emails, memos, and other impersonal forms of communication can lead to misunderstandings and a lack of clarity.
- Long chains of command: Information may be distorted or delayed as it travels through multiple layers of management.
- Lack of feedback: Employees may be hesitant to provide feedback due to fear or lack of accessibility to senior management, leading to poor decision-making.
Tips for addressing communication issues:
- Invest in communication training for managers.
- Encourage open communication and feedback mechanisms.
- Utilize technology to improve communication efficiency and transparency.
2. Demotibation and Alienation
As companies grow, they often become more impersonal. This can lead to a sense of de-motivation and alienation among employees. This is particularly true in flow-line production companies where tasks are often repetitive and employees feel disconnected from the overall goals of the organisation.
Tips to address de-motivation and alienation:
- Implement employee engagement initiatives: Focus on building team spirit, recognizing achievements, and providing opportunities for growth.
- Promote job enrichment: Give employees more responsibility and autonomy to enhance job satisfaction.
- Create a positive workplace culture: Foster open communication, encourage feedback, and promote a sense of belonging.
3. Poor Coordination and Control
Large organisations can struggle to maintain control over their disparate parts. This can result in:
- Duplication of effort: Different departments may be working on the same projects without coordination, leading to wasted resources.
- Bureaucracy: Excessive layers of management and complex decision-making processes can slow down operations and increase costs.
- Lack of clarity: As a company grows, it can be difficult to maintain a clear understanding of its mission and purpose across all departments.
Tips to address coordination and control challenges:
- Develop clear lines of responsibility: Define roles and responsibilities for each department and individual.
- Implement effective performance monitoring systems: Track progress, identify bottlenecks, and address issues proactively.
- Invest in training and development: Ensure that managers have the skills and knowledge to effectively coordinate and control their teams.
4. Top-Heavy Management and Company Politics
Large organisations often have a top-heavy management structure. This can lead to:
- Increased administrative costs: Salaries and benefits for senior management can add significant expenses to the company's budget.
- Company politics: Internal power struggles and competition can divert attention from core business activities.
- Slower decision-making: Decisions may be delayed or stalled due to bureaucracy and the need for consensus from multiple levels of management.
Tips to address top-heavy management and company politics:
- Streamline management structure: Reduce unnecessary layers of management and delegate responsibilities to lower levels.
- Promote a culture of collaboration: Encourage teamwork and cooperation amongst employees.
- Implement transparency and accountability: Ensure that all decisions are made openly and that managers are held accountable for their actions.
Conclusion
Understanding the causes of diseconomies of scale is crucial for any business leader. By recognizing these challenges and implementing effective strategies to address them, companies can mitigate the negative effects of growth and continue to operate efficiently and profitably.
Essay Writing Tips
Here are some additional tips to ensure your essay is strong:
- Clearly define diseconomies of scale in your introduction and provide relevant examples.
- Use real-life examples to illustrate the causes of diseconomies of scale.
- Provide evidence and supporting data for your claims.
- Structure your essay logically with clear headings and subheadings, making it easy to follow.
- Use academic language and ensure your writing is clear, concise, and grammatically correct.
- Proofread your essay carefully before submitting it.
By following these tips and using your understanding of the causes of diseconomies of scale, you will be well on your way to writing a successful essay.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Briefly explain causes of diseconomies of scale.
Answers could include:
-
Diseconomies of scale are generally related to management challenges/ problems associated with directing a large organisation, often with many divisions and spread across different locations/ countries.
-
Communication is often a major problem leading to diseconomies - excessive use of non-personal communication – mass of messages – long chains of command – messages distorted – information is delayed – poor decision-making – lack of feedback – management efficiency reduced.
-
Impersonal organisations – lose contact with employees – de-motivation – danger of staff alienation, especially in flow line manufacturing companies (use team work and job enrichment to address these issues).
-
Poor co-ordination – with growth – difficult often to maintain control over the disparate parts of the organisation – purpose and mission not understood – duplication of effort – bureaucracy – this poor co-ordination can lead to higher production costs.
-
Top heavy companies – company politics.