Do you think a business being ethical will always lead to lower profits? Justify your answer.
CAMBRIDGE
O level and GCSE
Year Examined
October/November 2022
Topic
Business Location
👑Complete Model Essay
Do Ethical Businesses Always Face Lower Profits?
Many people believe that running a business ethically will inevitably lead to lower profits. While it's true that ethical practices can sometimes increase costs, it's not always the case that this will result in lower overall profits.
Enhanced Reputation and Brand Image: One of the most significant benefits of ethical business practices is the positive impact it has on a company's reputation. Consumers are increasingly aware of social and environmental issues and are more likely to support businesses that align with their values. For example, clothing brands like Patagonia, known for their commitment to fair labor practices and environmental sustainability, have gained a loyal customer base willing to pay a premium for their products. This enhanced brand image can lead to increased sales and, ultimately, higher profits.
Motivated Employees and Increased Productivity: Ethical businesses often find that their employees are more motivated and engaged. When employees feel valued and proud of the company they work for, it can lead to increased productivity, lower absenteeism, and reduced staff turnover. The cost savings from these improvements can significantly offset any potential increase in costs associated with ethical practices. For instance, Google, known for its strong ethical culture, consistently ranks high in employee satisfaction surveys and boasts impressive employee retention rates.
Challenges and Costs: While there are clear benefits to ethical business practices, it's important to acknowledge the potential challenges. Sourcing ethical suppliers, ensuring fair wages, and investing in sustainable practices can sometimes lead to higher costs. For example, a chocolate company choosing to source Fairtrade cocoa beans will likely face higher raw material costs compared to using non-Fairtrade sources. Additionally, finding reliable ethical suppliers can sometimes be difficult, potentially disrupting the supply chain and impacting production.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while ethical business practices may present initial challenges and potentially increase costs in some areas, they don't necessarily lead to lower profits. The long-term benefits, such as an enhanced brand reputation, increased customer loyalty, and a more motivated workforce, can often outweigh the costs, leading to higher revenue and potentially higher profits overall. Ultimately, businesses need to find a balance between ethical considerations and profitability, recognizing that short-term cost savings may not always align with long-term success.
*Source: Examples are for illustrative purposes and do not represent specific data or research from named companies.*Do you think a business being ethical will always lead to lower profits? Justify your answer.
Note: Business Studies Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured Business Studies Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
Business Studies Pack.
✅ Model Essays for past papers questions
✅Covers Cambridge Exam Boards
✅ Suitable for A Level
✅A Library of over 400 Essays
✅ Download all Essays in PDF format
...and much more!
Free Essay Plan 🍃
Do Ethical Businesses Always Face Lower Profits?
Many people believe that running a business ethically will inevitably lead to lower profits. While it's true that ethical practices can sometimes increase costs, it's not always the case that this will result in lower overall profits.
Enhanced Reputation and Brand Image: One of the most significant benefits of ethical business practices is the positive impact it has on a company's reputation. Consumers are increasingly aware of social and environmental issues and are more likely to support businesses that align with their values. For example, clothing brands like Patagonia, known for their commitment to fair labor practices and environmental sustainability, have gained a loyal customer base willing to pay a premium for their products. This enhanced brand image can lead to increased sales and, ultimately, higher profits.
Motivated Employees and Increased Productivity: Ethical businesses often find that their employees are more motivated and engaged. When employees feel valued and proud of the company they work for, it can lead to increased productivity, lower absenteeism, and reduced staff turnover. The cost savings from these improvements can significantly offset any potential increase in costs associated with ethical practices. For instance, Google, known for its strong ethical culture, consistently ranks high in employee satisfaction surveys and boasts impressive employee retention rates.
Challenges and Costs: While there are clear benefits to ethical business practices, it's important to acknowledge the potential challenges. Sourcing ethical suppliers, ensuring fair wages, and investing in sustainable practices can sometimes lead to higher costs. For example, a chocolate company choosing to source Fairtrade cocoa beans will likely face higher raw material costs compared to using non-Fairtrade sources. Additionally, finding reliable ethical suppliers can sometimes be difficult, potentially disrupting the supply chain and impacting production.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while ethical business practices may present initial challenges and potentially increase costs in some areas, they don't necessarily lead to lower profits. The long-term benefits, such as an enhanced brand reputation, increased customer loyalty, and a more motivated workforce, can often outweigh the costs, leading to higher revenue and potentially higher profits overall. Ultimately, businesses need to find a balance between ethical considerations and profitability, recognizing that short-term cost savings may not always align with long-term success.
*Source: Examples are for illustrative purposes and do not represent specific data or research from named companies.*Extracts from Mark Schemes
Question:
Do you think a business being ethical will always lead to lower profits? Justify your answer.
Marking Scheme:
Award up to 2 marks for identification of relevant points.
Award up to 2 marks for relevant development of points.
Award up to 2 marks for a justified decision as to whether a business being ethical will always lead to lower profits.
Points to Consider:
- Enhance reputation/brand image (helps attract customers)
- Customers may pay higher prices (increasing revenue/ which could help cover the costs)
- Can help motivate employees (increasing productivity/reduces absenteeism/lowers labor turnover)
- Can increase costs (leading to higher prices) which may lead to fewer customers/sales
- Insufficient materials/difficulty finding ethical suppliers reducing output
- Ethical suppliers may have higher prices/unethical suppliers may be cheaper
Justification:
Some customers may be prepared to pay extra for ethical products (this can help offset the increased costs of trying to be ethical) so the overall profit margin may not change, and the better reputation gained could result in additional sales. Therefore, being ethical can benefit a business as in the long term this may increase revenue, which could result in higher profit overall.
Summary:
In summary, a business being ethical does not always lead to lower profits. While there may be initial challenges and increased costs associated with ethical practices, the long-term benefits such as enhanced reputation, increased customer loyalty, and potential higher revenues can outweigh these costs, resulting in improved profitability.