top of page

‘The most effective way for a loss-making retail clothing business to survive is to change the price element of its marketing mix.

CAMBRIDGE

A level and AS level

Year Examined

February/March 2022

Topic

Marketing

👑Complete Model Essay

The Price of Survival: Can Changing Prices Save a Loss-Making Clothing Retailer?

The assertion that changing prices is the most effective way for a struggling clothing retailer to survive is a complex one. While price adjustments can offer a quick fix, a more holistic approach considering all elements of the marketing mix and the competitive landscape is often necessary for long-term sustainability. This essay will explore the validity of this statement, analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of various survival strategies for a loss-making retail clothing business.

Understanding the Challenges: Loss-Making in a Competitive Market

A loss-making business, by definition, spends more than it earns. For a retail clothing business, this could be due to a multitude of factors, including high operating costs, declining sales, inefficient inventory management, or strong competition. The retail clothing market is notoriously cutthroat, with established players like Zara, H&M, and ASOS constantly vying for market share. (Cambridge International AS & A Level – Mark Scheme 2022) This fierce competition often leads to price wars, squeezing profit margins and making it challenging for smaller or struggling businesses to compete.

The Lure of Price Adjustments: A Double-Edged Sword

Altering the price element of the marketing mix can seem like a straightforward solution. Lowering prices might attract price-sensitive customers and boost sales volume. However, this strategy can also erode profit margins and potentially devalue the brand image, especially for businesses positioning themselves as high-quality. Conversely, increasing prices could improve profitability but risk alienating existing customers, particularly in a competitive market where alternatives are readily available.

Beyond Price: Exploring Other Avenues for Survival

While price is a critical element, focusing solely on it ignores the broader picture. A struggling retailer might find more sustainable solutions by revisiting other elements of the marketing mix:

  • Product: Re-evaluating the product line, focusing on current trends, improving quality, or introducing unique selling points can attract new customers and improve brand perception.
  • Place: Optimizing distribution channels, exploring online platforms, or partnering with other retailers can increase reach and accessibility.
  • Promotion: Effective marketing campaigns targeting specific customer segments, utilizing social media, or collaborating with influencers can boost brand awareness and drive sales.

Beyond the Marketing Mix: Internal Factors Matter

Survival often hinges on more than just marketing strategies. Internal factors such as streamlining operations, reducing overhead costs, improving inventory management, and investing in employee training can significantly contribute to a business's turnaround.

The Verdict: A Holistic Approach is Key

While adjusting pricing can play a role in a survival strategy, it is rarely the most effective solution in isolation. A loss-making retail clothing business needs a comprehensive approach, addressing both internal weaknesses and external market forces. This involves carefully analyzing the competitive landscape, understanding customer needs, and strategically leveraging all elements of the marketing mix in conjunction with internal improvements. By adopting a holistic approach, a struggling retailer can position itself for a sustainable recovery and achieve long-term success in a challenging market.

‘The most effective way for a loss-making retail clothing business to survive is to change the price element of its marketing mix.

Score Big with Perfectly Structured Business Studies Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

Business Studies Pack.

✅ Model Essays for past papers questions

 

✅Covers Cambridge Exam Boards

✅ Suitable for A Level

​​

✅A Library of over 400 Essays

 

✅ Download all Essays in PDF format

...and much more!

​​​

Free Essay Plan 🍃

Introduction

This essay will discuss whether the most effective way for a loss-making retail clothing business to survive is to change the price element of its marketing mix. It will explore the advantages and disadvantages of this strategy and consider alternative approaches to business survival.

Understanding the Problem

A loss-making business is one that is spending more money than it is earning, resulting in a negative profit margin. In the context of retail clothing, this could be due to factors such as high costs of production, low sales volumes, or fierce competition. Understanding the specific reasons for the business's losses is crucial for identifying the most effective survival strategy.

The Marketing Mix

The marketing mix, also known as the 4Ps, consists of:

  • Product: The goods or services offered by the business.
  • Price: The cost of the product to the customer.
  • Promotion: How the business communicates with its customers.
  • Place: Where and how the product reaches the customer.

Each element of the marketing mix plays a crucial role in attracting and retaining customers.

The Case for Price as a Solution

Changing the price element of the marketing mix is a common strategy for businesses facing financial difficulties. Lowering prices can potentially attract price-sensitive customers and increase sales volume. This could lead to improved cash flow and a return to profitability. However, it's important to understand the implications:

  • Price Sensitivity: Not all customers are drawn to lower prices. Some might associate lower prices with lower quality and be reluctant to purchase.
  • Profit Margins: Lowering prices often reduces profit margins. This can be detrimental to long-term profitability and sustainability.
  • Competition: Price-based competition can be intensely cutthroat. A downward spiral of price cuts can be difficult to escape, potentially leading to unsustainable profit margins for all players.

Alternatives to Price Changes

While changing the price element can seem immediate, it's not the only solution for a struggling retail clothing business. Here are some alternative strategies:

  • Product Differentiation: Focus on creating unique products that offer value beyond price, such as superior quality, design, or brand identity.
  • Improved Promotion: Invest in strategic marketing campaigns that target the right audience and communicate the brand's unique value proposition effectively.
  • Streamlined Operations: Reduce costs by optimizing supply chain management, inventory control, and operational processes.
  • Market Expansion: Explore new markets or demographics with a higher demand for the products offered.

Evaluation

The effectiveness of any survival strategy depends on the specific context of the business. For a loss-making retail clothing business, changing the price element may be a viable short-term solution but should be carefully considered. It might be more beneficial to focus on alternative strategies that build long-term value and sustainability. Factors such as:

  • Competitive Landscape: The level of competition within the retail clothing market is intense, making price-based competition difficult.
  • Customer Preferences: Understanding customer preferences and their willingness to pay for quality and brand value is crucial.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while changing the price element of the marketing mix can seem like an immediate solution for a struggling retail clothing business, it is not necessarily the most effective. A comprehensive approach that combines price, product, promotion, and place strategies tailored to the specific business scenario is often more successful for long-term survival. Ultimately, the most effective strategy for a loss-making business is one that addresses the root causes of its financial difficulties and builds a sustainable future.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

The most effective way for a loss-making retail clothing business to survive is to change the price element of its marketing mix. Discuss whether you agree with this statement. [20]

Knowledge and Understanding 4 marks

  • Clear understanding of a loss-making business.
  • Clear understanding of a retail business.
  • Clear understanding of a business survival.
  • Clear understanding of a marketing mix.

Application 4 marks

  • Reference to ways that a loss-making / retail / clothing business.
  • Reference to ways that a business can change its marketing mix.

Analysis 6 marks

  • Analysis of advantages / disadvantages of changing elements of the marketing mix including pricing.
  • Analysis of advantages / disadvantages of ways that a (loss-making) business can survive.
  • Analysis of why it might be difficult to survive in a retail (clothing) market.
  • Analysis of the marketing mix that is used in the retail (clothing) market.

Evaluation 6 marks

  • A candidate may make a judgement/conclusion as to whether ‘The most effective way for a loss-making retail clothing business to survive is to change the price element its marketing mix.’
  • These judgements/conclusions may be made at any point in the essay as well as in a concluding section
  • The context is a loss-making retail clothing business.
  • Reference to retail clothing businesses e.g. GAP, H&M, Next, ASOS.
  • Evaluation of reasons why it might be difficult to survive in the retail clothing market.
  • Evaluation of the marketing mix that is used in the retail clothing market.
  • Consideration of the level of competition within the retail clothing market and the market share of the top retailers, which will affect survival of different businesses.
  • Consideration of how important different elements of the marketing mix are to the consumers in this market and therefore which elements may be the most effective to change.
  • Consideration of the ease and ability of the loss-making business to change its marketing mix.
  • Whether there are short / long term effects of changing the marketing mix which need to be considered by the loss-making business.
bottom of page