Discuss how the actions of competitors could affect the operational management decisions of a car manufacturer.
CAMBRIDGE
A level and AS level
Year Examined
October/November 2018
Topic
Competition
👑Complete Model Essay
How Competitor Actions Can Affect Operational Management Decisions of a Car Manufacturer
In the fiercely competitive automotive industry, car manufacturers are constantly challenged to adapt their operational management decisions in response to the actions of their competitors. These decisions, often made in conjunction with other departments like marketing, revolve around the key questions of what to produce, how to produce, and where to produce, aiming to satisfy evolving customer needs. This essay will discuss how competitor actions, such as improvements in design and quality, cost reduction, introduction of new models, price reductions, and enhanced customer service, can significantly impact these operational decisions of a car manufacturer.
Impact on Product Design and Production Processes
When competitors introduce vehicles with superior design, innovative features, or improved quality, car manufacturers are compelled to respond in order to maintain their market share. This might involve adopting new computer-aided design (CAD) processes to enhance the aesthetics and functionality of their vehicles. For instance, the emergence of sleek and aerodynamic designs by competitors might force a manufacturer to invest in advanced CAD software and hire skilled designers to develop equally appealing models.
Similarly, advancements in production technology adopted by competitors can necessitate a manufacturer to upgrade their own manufacturing processes. If a competitor successfully implements a cost-effective Computer-Aided Manufacturing (CAM) system, others might need to follow suit to remain competitive in terms of production efficiency and cost. Failure to do so could result in higher production costs and a decline in profitability.
Influence on Production Platforms and Innovation
The introduction of new models by competitors can have a profound impact on a car manufacturer's decision-making process. If a competitor launches a successful SUV in a market trending towards larger vehicles, the manufacturer might need to consider developing their own SUV model or expanding their existing product line to include similar vehicles. This might necessitate creating new production platforms or adapting existing ones to accommodate the production of the new model.
Furthermore, competitor actions can spur innovation and the development of unique selling points (USPs). For example, if a competitor introduces a hybrid or electric vehicle with impressive fuel efficiency, other manufacturers might be compelled to invest in research and development to produce their own fuel-efficient or alternative fuel vehicles. This drive for innovation is essential for staying relevant in a market increasingly focused on sustainability and environmental consciousness.
Effects on Pricing, Distribution, and Customer Service
Price wars within the automotive industry can significantly impact a manufacturer's operational decisions. If a competitor slashes prices to gain market share, other manufacturers might be forced to respond by optimizing their production processes to reduce costs and maintain profitability. This could involve streamlining operations, negotiating better deals with suppliers, or even relocating production to countries with lower labor costs.
Competitors' efforts to enhance customer service can also influence a car manufacturer's operations. For instance, if a competitor introduces a highly efficient distribution network that reduces delivery times, other manufacturers might need to optimize their own distribution channels to remain competitive. This could involve establishing new dealerships, improving logistics, or even collaborating with third-party logistics providers to ensure timely delivery to customers.
The Importance of Strategic Response and Proactive Measures
While reacting to competitor actions is crucial, car manufacturers should avoid knee-jerk reactions. A price reduction by a competitor might be a temporary tactic, and a company with a strong brand and loyal customer base might not need to engage in a price war. Instead, they can focus on highlighting the value and quality of their products through effective marketing and branding.
Instead of solely reacting, car manufacturers should strive to be proactive. An innovative operations management department can anticipate market trends, invest in research and development, and implement cutting-edge technologies to stay ahead of the competition. By continuously monitoring competitor activities and analyzing market trends, manufacturers can anticipate potential threats and opportunities, enabling them to make informed and proactive decisions that strengthen their market position.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the actions of competitors have a significant and multifaceted impact on the operational management decisions of car manufacturers. From influencing product design and production processes to driving innovation and shaping pricing strategies, competitor actions create a dynamic environment that requires manufacturers to be agile, adaptable, and proactive. By carefully analyzing competitor moves, understanding market trends, and fostering a culture of innovation within their operations, car manufacturers can effectively respond to competitive pressures and thrive in the ever-evolving automotive landscape.
Discuss how the actions of competitors could affect the operational management decisions of a car manufacturer.
Note: Business Studies Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured Business Studies Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
Business Studies Pack.
✅ Model Essays for past papers questions
✅Covers Cambridge Exam Boards
✅ Suitable for A Level
✅A Library of over 400 Essays
✅ Download all Essays in PDF format
...and much more!
Free Essay Plan 🍃
A-Level Business Studies Essay Guide: Competitor Actions and Operational Management
This essay explores how competitor actions can influence the operational management decisions of a car manufacturer. It analyzes the impact of competitor strategies on key operational decisions like what to produce, how to produce, and where to produce. By understanding this dynamic, you can demonstrate your knowledge of strategic business management and its application within the competitive automotive industry.
Understanding the Scope
The essay focuses on the relationship between competitor actions and operational decisions. Key areas to consider include:
- Competitor Actions:
- Improvements in design and quality
- Cost reduction
- New models
- Price reductions
- Improved customer service activities
- Operational Management Responses:
- Adopting new computer-aided design (CAD) and computer-aided manufacturing (CAM) processes
- Creating new production platforms
- Innovation in models and development of new models
- More efficient distribution channels
- Developing unique selling propositions (USPs)
Essay Structure
A clear and logical structure is essential for a successful essay. Consider the following:
Introduction
- Define operational management and its role within a car manufacturer.
- Highlight the competitive nature of the automotive industry.
- Introduce the key competitor actions and operational responses that will be discussed.
- State your main argument: how do competitor actions affect operational decisions?
Main Body
- Section 1: Impact of Competitor Actions
- Analyze each competitor action mentioned in the prompt (design & quality, cost reduction, new models, price reductions, customer service) and explain how it could threaten the car manufacturer's market position.
- Provide specific examples from the automotive industry to illustrate your points.
- Section 2: Operational Management Responses
- Discuss how each operational response can counter the competitor actions. For example, how can adopting CAD/CAM improve design and quality, or how can new production platforms contribute to cost reduction?
- Link each response to the specific operational decisions (what to produce, how to produce, where to produce).
- Address the potential benefits and drawbacks of each response, considering factors like cost, time, and resource availability.
Conclusion
- Summarize the main points and reiterate your argument.
- Discuss the importance of continuous monitoring and adaptation in operational management, highlighting the need to proactively anticipate competitor actions.
- Conclude with a thought-provoking statement about the dynamic interplay between competitor actions and operational decisions in the automotive industry.
Tips for Success
- Research: Conduct thorough research on the automotive industry and examples of competitor actions and operational responses. Look for real-world case studies to support your points.
- Analysis: Provide in-depth analysis of the relationship between competitive actions and operational decisions. Explain the rationale behind operational responses and their potential impact.
- Evaluation: Go beyond simple descriptions and evaluate the effectiveness of different operational management strategies. Discuss the pros and cons of each response and their implications for the car manufacturer.
- Critical Thinking: Demonstrate critical thinking by considering the complex factors that influence operational decisions, such as market conditions, consumer trends, and corporate strategy.
- Clarity and Structure: Ensure your essay is well-organized, with clear headings, subheadings, and transitions between paragraphs. Use concise and precise language.
- Proofread: Carefully proofread your work for grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors.
Remember
By applying these tips, you can write a compelling essay that demonstrates your understanding of operational management, competitive dynamics, and the strategic decision-making process within the automotive industry.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Discuss how the actions of competitors could affect the operational management decisions of a car manufacturer.
Operational management decisions of a car manufacturer (in conjunction with other departments, e.g. marketing) include producing cars that satisfy customer needs – the key decisions include what to produce, how to produce, where to produce. Competitor actions can include:–
- improvements in design and quality
- cost reduction
- new models
- price reductions
- improved customer service activities.
An operations management department can respond by taking such action as:–
- Adopting a new computer-aided design process.
- Adopting a new CAM process.
- Creating new production platforms.
- Innovation in models, new models.
- More efficient distribution channels.
- Developing new unique ‘bells and whistles’ – USP.
Evaluative comments may include:
- It may not be appropriate to take knee jerk action in response to competitor actions.
- A reduction in competitor price may be temporary and the brand strength of the car manufacturer may be strong enough to resist the price reduction.
- It may well depend on the strength and agility of the company and its operational management department.
- An operations management department does not have to wait for threatening competitor activities or actions.
- An innovative operations management department might well be ahead of competitors having taken decisions for new investment/new quality models that put competitors on the back foot and /or it continually and effectively monitors competitors so preventing any surprising or threatening competitor actions.