‘The main reason why many niche cake manufacturing businesses fail is that they grow too quickly.
CAMBRIDGE
A level and AS level
Year Examined
February/March 2023
Topic
Business Growth & Strategy
👑Complete Model Essay
Evaluating the Failure of Niche Cake Manufacturing Businesses
The assertion that rapid growth is the primary driver behind the failure of many niche cake manufacturing businesses holds a degree of truth, but it represents an oversimplification of a complex issue. While unchecked expansion can undoubtedly strain a business's resources and operational capabilities, a myriad of other factors contribute to their downfall. This essay aims to dissect this claim, evaluating the role of swift growth alongside other crucial elements that influence the success or failure of businesses operating within this specific niche.
The Perils of Rapid Growth
Undeniably, expanding too quickly can destabilize a niche cake manufacturing business. As demand surges, the pressure to scale production can lead to compromises on quality, potentially harming the brand's reputation which is paramount in a niche market. For instance, a bakery renowned for its intricately designed cakes might struggle to maintain its artistic standards while ramping up production to meet a sudden influx of orders. This could result in disgruntled customers, negative reviews, and ultimately, a decline in sales.
Furthermore, rapid growth often necessitates significant financial investments in equipment, staff, and larger premises. If not managed prudently, this can result in cash flow issues, particularly if the business experiences seasonal fluctuations in demand. A cake business experiencing a surge in orders during wedding season might invest heavily in expansion, only to face a financial crunch during the off-season.
Beyond Rapid Growth: Other Contributing Factors
However, attributing failure solely to rapid growth would be myopic. Niche cake businesses, by their very nature, cater to specific customer segments and often operate with limited resources. This inherent vulnerability exposes them to a range of challenges:
1. Intense Competition:
The low barriers to entry in the food industry mean that niche cake businesses often encounter fierce competition, both from established players and new entrants. This necessitates constant innovation and marketing efforts to stay ahead of the curve.
2. Fluctuating Ingredient Costs:
The price volatility of ingredients like butter, sugar, and flour can significantly impact profitability, particularly for smaller businesses with limited bargaining power with suppliers.
3. Changing Consumer Preferences:
Food trends are notoriously fickle, and a niche cake business that fails to adapt to evolving consumer tastes risks becoming obsolete. For instance, a bakery specializing in elaborate fondant cakes might find itself struggling to cater to the growing demand for simpler, rustic-style desserts.
4. Lack of Business Acumen:
Many niche cake businesses are started by passionate bakers who lack the necessary business skills to manage finances, marketing, and operations effectively.
Conclusion
While rapid growth can undoubtedly strain a niche cake manufacturing business, it is not the sole determinant of success or failure. A confluence of factors, including competition, cost pressures, changing consumer preferences, and managerial expertise, plays a crucial role. To thrive, these businesses must adopt a holistic approach – balancing controlled growth with a keen understanding of their niche market, a commitment to quality, and robust business practices. Failure to navigate these complex dynamics effectively, regardless of growth rate, significantly increases the likelihood of failure.
‘The main reason why many niche cake manufacturing businesses fail is that they grow too quickly.
Note: Business Studies Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured Business Studies Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
Business Studies Pack.
✅ Model Essays for past papers questions
✅Covers Cambridge Exam Boards
✅ Suitable for A Level
✅A Library of over 400 Essays
✅ Download all Essays in PDF format
...and much more!
Free Essay Plan 🍃
Guide to Writing Your A-Level Business Studies Essay
This guide will help you write a strong essay for your A-Level Business Studies exam on the topic: "The main reason why many niche cake manufacturing businesses fail is that they grow too quickly. Evaluate this view."
Understanding the Question
The statement suggests that rapid growth is the primary cause of failure for niche cake businesses. Your essay needs to evaluate this view by:
- Analyzing the potential benefits and drawbacks of rapid growth for a niche cake manufacturing business.
- Considering alternative reasons for failure, such as poor management, lack of market demand, or intense competition.
- Presenting a balanced conclusion, weighing the evidence and forming your own judgment on the statement's validity.
Essay Structure
A clear and logical structure is crucial for a good essay. Consider the following framework:
Introduction (1 paragraph)
- Briefly define "niche cake manufacturing businesses" and explain what makes them unique.
- Re-state the essay question and introduce your overall argument.
Main Body (3-4 paragraphs)
This section should contain your main arguments and evidence. Here's a possible structure:
Paragraph 1: Advantages of Rapid Growth
- Explain the potential benefits of rapid growth, such as increased market share, economies of scale, and brand recognition.
- Use examples of niche cake businesses that have successfully scaled up.
Paragraph 2: Disadvantages of Rapid Growth
- Detail the potential disadvantages of rapid growth, such as cash flow problems, loss of quality control, and employee burnout.
- Provide specific examples of niche cake businesses that have failed due to rapid growth.
Paragraph 3: Alternative Reasons for Failure
- Explore factors other than rapid growth that can contribute to business failure, such as poor marketing, ineffective management, or intense competition.
- Present evidence to support your claims.
Paragraph 4 (Optional): Balancing the Argument
- Analyze the relationship between rapid growth and other factors that contribute to business failure. For example, how might poor management amplify the negative effects of rapid growth?
- Consider specific examples to illustrate your points.
Conclusion (1 paragraph)
- Restate your main argument and summarize the key points of your essay.
- Provide a balanced and well-supported final judgment on the statement's validity.
Tips for Writing a Strong Essay
- Use relevant business theory: Apply concepts like economies of scale, cash flow management, marketing strategies, and competitive analysis to support your arguments.
- Use real-world examples: Provide concrete examples of niche cake manufacturing businesses that illustrate the points you make.
- Be specific and detailed: Avoid making broad generalizations. Instead, focus on specific aspects of niche cake businesses and their challenges.
- Maintain a balanced perspective: Acknowledge both the potential benefits and drawbacks of rapid growth, and consider the influence of other factors on business failure.
- Proofread carefully: Check for grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors. Ensure your essay is well-written and easy to understand.
Example Content
Here are some examples of content you could use in your essay:
Advantages of Rapid Growth
Rapid growth can lead to economies of scale, allowing the business to produce cakes at a lower cost per unit. This can improve profitability and allow for more competitive pricing. Larger production runs also enable the business to reach a wider market and increase brand awareness.
Disadvantages of Rapid Growth
Rapid growth can strain cash flow, especially if the business needs to invest in new equipment or hire more staff. Without adequate cash reserves, the business may struggle to keep up with production demands and pay its suppliers, leading to financial instability.
Alternative Reasons for Failure
A lack of market demand, due to changing consumer tastes or poor marketing, can lead to a business's demise. Intense competition from established players or new entrants can also make it difficult for a niche cake business to survive.
Remember to provide relevant examples and evidence to support your claims. By using theory, examples, and a balanced approach, you will create a compelling and well-structured essay that effectively assesses the statement.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
The main reason why many niche cake manufacturing businesses fail is that they grow too quickly.
Evaluate this view.
Indicative content
Responses may include:
AO1 Knowledge and understanding
- Knowledge of business failure/growth / niche/manufacturing businesses.
AO2 Application
- Developed application of business failure/growth to a niche cake manufacturing business - ...
- Limited application of business failure/growth to a niche cake manufacturing business - ...
AO3 Analysis
- Fast growth can mean a business loses focus on essential functions and take too many risks – e.g. product diversification
- Fast growth can lead to significantly increased demands on employees and especially managers- stress, fatigue, burn out
- Inferior service may result in lower levels of customer satisfaction as attempt is made to produce more
- Output demands may outpace capability
- A business might accept new clients without resources to meet the demand
- A business might launch a new product with inadequate research and development – not ready for market
- A business might expand into unfamiliar/ fragile markets and territories – suffer significant losses
- A business might fail to account for and control overhead costs – that increase disproportionately in relation to growth
- Too fast growth can result in cash shortages and/or long-term damage to the brand and customer relations of a business
AO4 Evaluation
The following examples illustrate how the levels and marks within levels are applied. The annotations are shown in bold.
Developed evaluative comments (EVAL L2 3 marks)
- Growth that is too quick is likely to undermine the success of any business, particularly if the managers are not skilled enough to see that fast growth places enormous pressure on some aspects of the business, such as cash flow.
- Businesses that grow very quickly may assume that profit-making in the short term means success, but if the quality of the products deteriorates due to unskilled workers the long term viability of the business is not guaranteed and the business might fail as quickly as it grows.
- Without effective marketing and quality control and a recognition of the threat of competitive ‘copy-cats’ a business may be quickly undermined and fail.’
Only developed evaluative comments applied directly to the context of a niche cake manufacturing business can move to EVAL L3 5 marks.