top of page

Discuss Carlen's findings on women, crime, and poverty.

cambridge

Crime and Deviance

 A Level/AS Level/O Level

Free Essay Outline

Carlen's Findings on Women, Crime, and Poverty
This essay will discuss the findings of Pat Carlen's research into women, crime, and poverty. It will focus on her key ideas, including:

⭐The concept of "the class deal" and how it relates to women's crime.
⭐The "gender deal" and its role in shaping women's choices.
⭐The limitations of Carlen's research, such as its focus on working-class women and its potential to reinforce stereotypes.

The essay will argue that Carlen's work is valuable as it sheds light on the complex interplay between gender, class, and crime. However, it is important to recognize the limitations of her approach and to consider other perspectives on women's criminality.

Free Essay 

The Tangled Web: Carlen's Exploration of Women, Crime, and Poverty

Pat Carlen's groundbreaking work, "Women, Crime, and Poverty", challenges the traditional understanding of female criminality, arguing that women's involvement in crime is intricately linked to their social and economic circumstances. Carlen, a feminist criminologist, moves beyond simplistic explanations of female crime, delving into the complex interplay of gender, class, and power dynamics that shape women's lives and their choices, including criminal ones.

⭐⭐Challenging Existing Theories:⭐⭐ Carlen critiques the prevailing theories of female crime, particularly the "chivalry thesis" that posits lenient treatment of women by the criminal justice system. She argues that this theory falsely presents a monolithic picture of women's experiences and ignores the unique challenges faced by marginalized women, particularly those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds.

⭐⭐The "Control Theory" of Female Crime:⭐⭐ Carlen refines the control theory, suggesting that women's involvement in crime stems from the unequal distribution of power and resources in society. She posits that women, particularly working-class women, are controlled in diverse ways, including through their economic dependence on men, social expectations around motherhood and domesticity, and limited educational and employment opportunities.

⭐⭐The "Gendered Contract":⭐⭐ Central to Carlen's argument is the concept of the "gendered contract," which encompasses the societal expectations placed upon women based on their gender. This contract dictates that women should be "good wives, good mothers, and good daughters," fulfilling their roles within the domestic sphere. Failure to uphold this contract, often fueled by socioeconomic hardship, leads to social censure and can push women towards criminal activities.

⭐⭐Carlen's Study:⭐⭐ Carlen's work is based on empirical research on a group of working-class women in the UK, who were convicted of theft and shoplifting. Her findings highlight the intersectionality of factors that contribute to their involvement in crime. These include:

⭐Economic Vulnerability:⭐⭐ These women face significant economic hardship, often struggling with poverty, unemployment, and precarious work. The pressure to provide for their families, coupled with the limited resources available to them, can drive them towards illegal activities.
⭐Controlling Relationships:⭐⭐ Many women are trapped in abusive or controlling relationships, often with partners who control their finances and restrict their choices. This lack of autonomy forces them into situations where crime becomes a means of survival or escape.
⭐Limited Opportunities:⭐⭐ Educational and employment opportunities are often restricted for working-class women, leading to a cycle of poverty and dependence. The lack of access to resources and opportunities further fuels their vulnerability and can push them towards criminal activities.

⭐⭐The Impact of Carlen's Research:⭐⭐ Carlen's work has significantly impacted the field of criminology, prompting a more nuanced understanding of female criminality. Her insights shed light on the social and economic conditions that contribute to women's involvement in crime, challenging the simplistic explanations prevalent in previous theories.

⭐⭐Implications for Policy:⭐⭐ Carlen's research argues for a shift in policy approaches towards female offenders. Instead of focusing on individual failings, a focus on social and economic factors is needed. Policies that address poverty, provide access to education and employment opportunities, and offer support to women facing domestic violence can effectively address the root causes of female crime.

⭐⭐Conclusion:⭐⭐ Carlen's "Women, Crime, and Poverty" provides a powerful and insightful look into the complex reality of female crime. By framing women's involvement in crime within the context of social and economic structures, her work challenges traditional criminological explanations and calls for a more holistic and compassionate understanding of female offenders. It underlines the need for transformative policy changes that address the systemic inequalities that drive women towards criminal activities, ultimately aiming to create a more just and equitable society.

bottom of page