top of page

Compare structural and subcultural theories of crime.


Crime and Deviance

 A Level/AS Level/O Level

Free Essay Outline

Briefly define crime and deviance.
State the aim of the essay, which is to compare structural and subcultural theories of crime.

Structural Theories
Explain Durkheim's concept of anomie.
Briefly describe Merton's Strain Theory and its five adaptations to strain.
Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of Merton's theory.
Explain the Marxist concept of crime as a product of capitalism.
Briefly describe how crime is a result of the inequalities and power structures within capitalism.
Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the Marxist theory.

Subcultural Theories
Cohen's Status Frustration Theory
Explain Cohen's theory about how working-class boys experience status frustration and delinquency.
Describe the alternative status hierarchy and delinquent subculture.
Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of Cohen's theory.

Comparing Structural and Subcultural Theories
Summarize the key differences between structural and subcultural theories of crime.
Discuss the strengths and limitations of each perspective.
Consider why one perspective might be more valuable than the other.

Restate the main points of the essay.
Briefly discuss the implications of the comparison for understanding crime and deviance.

Free Essay 

The Roots of Deviance: Exploring Structural and Subcultural Theories of Crime

Understanding why people commit crimes has been a central focus of sociology for decades. Two prominent theoretical frameworks, structural and subcultural theories, offer distinct perspectives on the root causes of deviance. These frameworks, while often contrasted, can also be seen as complementary, offering a multifaceted understanding of criminal behavior.

⭐⭐Structural Theories: A Macro Level Perspective⭐⭐

Structural theories emphasize the societal structures and inequalities that drive criminal behavior. They focus on how power dynamics, social stratification, and resource allocation within a society influence individual actions. These theories highlight the broader societal context that shapes individual choices and opportunities:

⭐Strain Theory (Robert Merton):⭐⭐ This theory posits that crime arises from a mismatch between culturally defined goals (e.g., material success) and the legitimate means to achieve them. When individuals lack access to legitimate means, they experience strain, leading them to engage in deviant behavior, including crime, to attain those goals.
⭐Social Disorganization Theory (Shaw & McKay):⭐⭐ This theory focuses on the breakdown of social structures in disadvantaged neighborhoods, characterized by poverty, high population turnover, and weak social institutions. These factors lead to a lack of informal social control, facilitating the development of criminal subcultures and increasing crime rates.
⭐Conflict Theory (Marxist Perspective):⭐⭐ This theory highlights the inherent conflict between different social groups due to unequal power and resources. Crime, in this view, is a result of the exploitation and marginalization of the working class by the ruling class.

⭐⭐Subcultural Theories: Exploring Group Dynamics and Identity⭐⭐

Subcultural theories, on the other hand, delve into the specific subcultures and group dynamics that foster criminal behavior. These theories focus on how individuals develop deviant identities and values within specific social groups, often as a response to social pressures and marginalization:

⭐Differential Association Theory (Sutherland):⭐⭐ This theory proposes that criminal behavior is learned through interactions with others. Individuals are more likely to engage in crime if they associate with people who hold criminal values and attitudes. This association shapes their perceptions of right and wrong, making deviant behavior more acceptable.
⭐Subcultural Theory (Cohen):⭐⭐ This theory argues that certain subcultures develop their own value systems and norms that oppose mainstream society. These subcultures, often arising from social exclusion and status frustration, provide alternative routes to achieving status and recognition. Criminal behavior within these subcultures becomes a way to gain respect and belonging.
⭐Labeling Theory (Becker):⭐⭐ This theory emphasizes the role of social labels and societal reactions in shaping criminal behavior. It suggests that once an individual is labeled as deviant, they are more likely to internalize this label and engage in criminal behavior. The self-fulfilling prophecy, where individuals act according to expectations, becomes a key factor in reinforcing deviant behavior.

⭐⭐Interplay and Intersectionality: A Holistic Approach⭐⭐

Structural and subcultural theories, while distinct, aren’t mutually exclusive. They can be seen as complementary, offering a more comprehensive understanding of crime:

⭐Structural conditions can create the social context that fosters subcultures.⭐⭐ For example, social disorganization within disadvantaged neighborhoods can lead to the development of criminal subcultures, as young people seek alternative means of achieving social status and recognition.
⭐Subcultural norms can influence individuals' interpretations of structural inequalities.⭐⭐ Individuals might perceive their limited opportunities and societal injustices through the lens of their subcultural values, leading them to engage in criminal behavior as a form of resistance or rebellion.

⭐⭐Conclusion: A Broader Understanding of Crime⭐⭐

By recognizing the interplay between structural and subcultural factors, we gain a more nuanced understanding of crime. Examining the broader social context, including power dynamics, social inequalities, and subcultural influences, allows us to understand the underlying causes of criminal behavior. Ultimately, this holistic approach can inform more effective crime prevention strategies and interventions that address both the structural and social factors contributing to deviance.

bottom of page