top of page

Discuss the impact of subcultures on criminal and deviant behaviour. [20 marks]


Crime and Deviance

 A Level/AS Level/O Level

Free Essay Outline

Introduce the concept of subcultures and their relationship to crime and deviance.

Subcultures as a Source of Deviance
Strain Theory
Explain how Merton's strain theory suggests that subcultures arise from blocked opportunities within society.
Status Frustration and Delinquent Subcultures
Discuss Cohen's theory of status frustration and how subcultures offer alternative ways to achieve status.
Subcultural Values and Criminal Behaviour
Examine how subcultural values, such as toughness, excitement, and rebellion, can influence criminal behaviour.

Examples of Subcultures and Deviance
Gang Culture
Explore how gangs operate as subcultures, providing support and opportunities for criminal activity.
Cybercrime and Hacker Subcultures
Analyze the role of online subcultures in facilitating and normalizing cybercrime.

Criticisms of Subcultural Theories
Overemphasis on Working-Class Deviance
Discuss the criticism that subcultural theories overlook the role of white-collar crime and deviance.
Deterministic View of Subcultures
Examine the argument that subcultural theories may present a deterministic view of behaviour, neglecting individual agency.

Summarize the key points and highlight the impact of subcultures on criminal and deviant behaviour.

Free Essay 

The Shadowy Influence: Subcultures and the Dance with Deviance

Subcultures, those distinct groups with shared values, beliefs, and practices that diverge from the mainstream, hold a complex relationship with criminal and deviant behaviour. They can act as both breeding grounds for deviance and protective forces against it, making their influence a nuanced and often paradoxical phenomenon.

⭐⭐The Breeding Ground⭐⭐: Subcultures can provide an environment where deviant behaviours become normalized and even celebrated. This occurs through several mechanisms:

⭐Value Conflict⭐⭐: Subcultures often arise from a perceived clash with mainstream values. This conflict can manifest in a rejection of dominant social norms, leading to the adoption of alternative behaviours, some of which might be considered deviant by the larger society. For example, youth gangs, often rooted in marginalized communities, may adopt violence and theft as survival strategies or expressions of power within their subculture.
⭐Group Identity and Bonding⭐⭐: Subcultures offer a sense of belonging and identity, particularly for individuals who feel alienated from the mainstream. This strong group identification can lead to the acceptance and even glorification of behaviours that are considered deviant by the wider society. Members might conform to the subculture's norms to earn acceptance and maintain their status within the group.
⭐Learning and Socialization⭐⭐: Subcultures act as microcosms with their own socialization processes. Through interaction and observation, members learn and internalize the subculture's values, including those that may normalize criminal or deviant behaviours. This can be observed in the transmission of criminal techniques, justifications for criminal activity, and the development of an anti-establishment ethos.

⭐⭐The Protective Shield⭐⭐: While subcultures can foster deviance, they can also act as a protective force against it. This occurs through:

⭐Alternative Social Control⭐⭐: Subcultures often develop their own informal systems of social control that regulate members' behaviour. This can involve sanctions for deviating from the subculture's norms, preventing individuals from engaging in activities that are deemed unacceptable within the group. For example, a punk subculture may have strong norms against theft within the community, even if theft is viewed differently by the larger society.
⭐Solidarity and Support⭐⭐: Subcultures can offer a sense of belonging and support for their members. This can provide a buffer against the pressures and temptations of the wider society, potentially reducing the likelihood of engaging in criminal or deviant behaviours. For example, a religious subculture may provide strong moral guidance and social support, lessening the likelihood of its members engaging in drug use or other forms of deviance.
⭐Alternative Values⭐⭐: Subcultures may possess values that conflict with dominant societal norms but do not necessarily promote criminal or deviant behaviours. For example, a subculture valuing self-sufficiency and resourcefulness may engage in "deviant" activities like dumpster diving to meet their needs, but they might not consider these actions criminal.

⭐⭐The Complexity of the Relationship⭐⭐: The relationship between subcultures and criminal or deviant behaviour is complex and multifaceted. It is not a simple case of subcultures directly causing deviance. Rather, the influence of subcultures is shaped by a multitude of factors, including:

⭐Individual Factors⭐⭐: The individual's own personality, motivations, and experiences play a significant role in their behaviour, regardless of subcultural influences.
⭐Social Context⭐⭐: The wider social context, including poverty, inequality, and discrimination, can influence both the formation and the activities of subcultures, contributing to the rise of criminal or deviant behaviours.
⭐Subculture Variations⭐⭐: Subcultures themselves are diverse and dynamic, with varying levels of acceptance and tolerance for criminal and deviant activities. Some subcultures, like youth gangs, may actively promote violence and delinquency, while others, like academic subcultures, may emphasize conformity and compliance with societal norms.

⭐⭐Conclusion⭐⭐: The relationship between subcultures and criminal and deviant behaviour is not a simplistic one. While subcultures can provide an environment where deviant behaviours become normalized, they can also act as a protective force against them. Understanding this interplay requires consideration of the individual, the social context, and the dynamic nature of subcultures themselves. By delving into the nuanced relationship between subcultures and deviance, we can gain valuable insights into the complex forces shaping human behaviour within society.

bottom of page