top of page

How far do you agree that Deng Xiaoping allowed greater freedoms in China between 1976 and 1981 than under Mao’s earlier leadership?

Level

GCSE

Year Examined

2020

Topic

China

👑Complete Model Essay

How far do you agree that Deng Xiaoping allowed greater freedoms in China between 1976 and 1981 than under Mao’s earlier leadership?

Introduction
Following the tumultuous years of Mao Zedong's leadership and his death in 1976, Deng Xiaoping emerged as the paramount leader of China. His rule from 1978 to 1989 ushered in an era of significant change, particularly in the economic realm. While Deng's reforms introduced greater economic freedoms compared to Mao's era, it is important to acknowledge that political control remained firmly in the hands of the Communist Party. This essay will argue that while Deng Xiaoping allowed some freedoms in China between 1976 and 1981, these were primarily focused on economic activity, while political freedoms remained heavily restricted.

Paragraph 1: Economic Freedoms under Deng
One of the most significant changes under Deng was the introduction of economic reforms aimed at modernizing China and improving living standards. These reforms provided a level of economic freedom previously unseen under Mao. The dismantling of the inefficient commune system in agriculture and the implementation of the "responsibility system" gave farmers greater autonomy over their production and allowed them to profit from their own labor. Similarly, the establishment of Special Economic Zones attracted foreign investment and encouraged private enterprise, fostering a more market-oriented economy. These changes represented a significant departure from the strict state control that characterized Mao's economic policies and gave individuals and families more control over their economic destinies.

Paragraph 2: Educational and Cultural Openness
Beyond the economic sphere, the Deng era witnessed a degree of relaxation in the cultural and educational realms. The government expanded access to higher education, reopening universities and allowing students to pursue opportunities to study abroad. This marked a clear break from the restrictions imposed during the Cultural Revolution, where intellectual pursuits were often suppressed. Culturally, there was a limited loosening of restrictions, with greater tolerance for artistic expression and some access to foreign films and literature. While these changes were significant in moving away from the strict ideological control of the Mao era, they remained carefully managed by the state.

Paragraph 3: Continued Political Repression
Despite these areas of liberalization, it is crucial to recognize that the Communist Party, under Deng's leadership, maintained an iron grip on political power and showed little tolerance for dissent. The early years of Deng's rule saw the arrest and trial of the Gang of Four, holding them responsible for the excesses of the Cultural Revolution. While this move was popular, it also served to consolidate Deng's grip on power. Furthermore, the Democracy Wall Movement, where citizens openly expressed their desire for political reform, was swiftly crushed. Activists like Wei Jingsheng, who called for democracy and human rights, were imprisoned. These events clearly demonstrate that Deng’s government was not willing to tolerate any challenge to the Party's authority.

Paragraph 4: Control and Censorship
Underpinning the Communist Party's hold on power was its continued control over information and media. Censorship remained a powerful tool used to suppress any criticism of the government or the Communist Party. The press and media were tightly controlled, and any attempts to disseminate views that challenged the official narrative were swiftly silenced. This tight grip on information ensured that while people had more freedom in their economic and daily lives, they were not truly free to express political opinions that differed from the Party line.

Conclusion
In conclusion, while Deng Xiaoping’s rule brought about undeniable change, it was a change that primarily manifested in economic and, to a lesser extent, social spheres. While he allowed greater freedoms in these areas compared to the oppressive era of Mao Zedong, political freedoms remained severely limited. Deng’s reforms were ultimately about strengthening China economically and maintaining the firm grip of the Communist Party on power. The crushing of dissent and continued control of information demonstrate that true liberalization was a long way off. Deng’s era can be seen as one of cautious and controlled opening up, where some freedoms were granted, but only within the confines of a one-party state determined to maintain its authority. The legacy of this approach continues to shape China's political landscape today.

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

Introduction
Briefly introduce the context of Deng Xiaoping's rule following Mao Zedong's death. State your line of argument. You might agree to a certain extent, arguing that while some freedoms were granted, political control remained tight.

Paragraph 1: Economic Freedoms under Deng
Point: Deng Xiaoping introduced significant economic reforms that granted more freedom to certain groups. Evidence:

⭐Dismantling of communes and introduction of the "responsibility system" in agriculture.
⭐Allowing private enterprise and foreign investment in Special Economic Zones.

Explanation: Explain how these reforms gave peasants and entrepreneurs more autonomy and control over their economic activities compared to Mao's era.

Paragraph 2: Educational and Cultural Openness
Point: Deng's regime saw an increase in educational and cultural freedoms. Evidence:

⭐Expansion of universities and opportunities for studying abroad.
⭐Relaxation of some cultural restrictions, allowing for greater artistic expression.

Explanation: Explain how these changes represent a shift from the strict ideological control and isolationism of the Cultural Revolution period.

Paragraph 3: Continued Political Repression
Point: Despite some liberalization, Deng's government maintained a firm grip on political power and suppressed dissent. Evidence:

⭐Arrest and trial of the Gang of Four.
⭐Crackdown on the Democracy Wall movement and imprisonment of activists like Wei Jingsheng.

Explanation: Explain how these events demonstrate the limitations of freedom under Deng and the ongoing suppression of political opposition.

Paragraph 4: Control and Censorship
Point: The Communist Party, under Deng, retained tight control over information and media. Evidence:

⭐Continued censorship of the press and media.
⭐Suppression of any challenges to the Party's authority or socialist ideology.

Explanation: Explain how this control over information and limitations on free speech restricted true political freedom.

Conclusion
Summarize your main points. Reiterate your overall judgment on the extent to which Deng allowed greater freedoms. Offer a nuanced perspective: While acknowledging the economic and social freedoms granted, emphasize the continued limitations on political freedom and dissent. Perhaps compare Deng's reforms to the later loosening of restrictions in China, or contrast them with the political openness in other nations.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

Deng Xiaoping: Greater Freedom?

Level 5 answers will typically construct a balanced answer which uses a range of explained supporting evidence explicitly to support the argument being made.

In some ways I agree with this statement, because Deng brought more freedom to Chinese peasants, who made up most of China’s population. After the death of Mao the large communes were broken up and peasants were allowed to rent land and choose how to farm it, keeping any profits that they made. This gave the peasants more freedom as their lives were less controlled by the government. Deng also allowed greater freedom in education, because he introduced policies that expanded Chinese universities and students were encouraged to travel abroad to learn in Western universities. Before 1976 it was almost impossible for people to leave China and so this brought greater freedom.

On the other hand, I don’t fully agree because there was still a great deal of repression in China. After Mao’s death the ‘Gang of Four’ – senior Communists including Mao’s wife – were arrested and in 1980 they were given long prison sentences for opposing the ideas of the government. This shows that there was no greater freedom, as opposition was not tolerated, even within the Communist Party itself. Repression was also used against the Chinese people. In 1979, Deng launched a crackdown on democracy campaigners who had set up a ‘democracy wall’ in Beijing the year before. There were many arrests and several campaigners including Wei Jingsheng were imprisoned. There was no greater freedom in China under Deng as free speech was not permitted.

On balance I believe that whilst some parts of Chinese society saw greater freedoms, the political system did not change from an oppressive one Party state and so these freedoms were very limited indeed.

bottom of page