Which of the following had the more serious consequences for the Kingdom of Italy? (i) The decision to stay out of World War One in 1914 (ii) The decision to enter World War One in 1915 Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
Level
A Level
Year Examined
2022
Topic
Non-British period study: Italy 1896-1943
👑Complete Model Essay
Which of the following had the more serious consequences for the Kingdom of Italy? (i) The decision to stay out of World War One in 1914 (ii) The decision to enter World War One in 1915 Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
Which of the following had the more serious consequences for the Kingdom of Italy?
(i) The decision to stay out of World War One in 1914
(ii) The decision to enter World War One in 1915
While both options had significant impacts on Italy, the decision to enter World War One in 1915 had more serious consequences for the Kingdom. This essay will argue that Italy’s decision to enter the war had the more serious consequences due to its contribution to the undermining of the Liberal Kingdom’s authority, the destruction of the Liberal consensus, and the rise of Fascism.
The Impact of Neutrality
Arguably, the decision to remain neutral in 1914 allowed Italy to avoid the immediate devastation experienced by other European nations. Remaining neutral also afforded Italy the opportunity to negotiate a more favorable position, which ultimately led to the Treaty of London in 1915. This agreement promised Italy territorial gains in return for joining the Allied Powers. However, this initial advantage would quickly be overshadowed by the consequences of Italy’s participation in the war.
The Consequences of Entering the War
Italy’s entry into World War One had disastrous consequences for the Liberal Kingdom. The war effort strained the Italian economy, leading to social unrest and economic hardship. The war also exposed the weaknesses of the Italian military, which suffered heavy casualties and ultimately failed to achieve the promised territorial gains. This further undermined the public’s trust in the Liberal government and its ability to fulfill its promises.
Furthermore, the war significantly damaged the Liberal consensus that had been a defining feature of Italian politics since unification. The war polarized Italian society, highlighting deep divisions between those who supported the war and those who opposed it. The war also resulted in the rise of nationalist and expansionist movements, which challenged the traditional Liberal values of peace and compromise.
The Rise of Fascism
The war’s consequences created a fertile ground for the rise of fascism. Benito Mussolini, a charismatic former socialist, capitalized on the public’s disillusionment with the Liberal government and the perceived failure of the war. He promised to restore Italy’s national pride and strength, appealing to a sense of injured national identity. Mussolini’s message resonated with those who felt betrayed by the war’s outcome and the weakness of the Liberal government. He exploited the deep divisions in Italian society and was able to gain political power through a mixture of violence and propaganda.
Conclusion
While Italy’s neutrality in 1914 had its own set of challenges, the decision to enter the war in 1915 had far more serious consequences. The war’s impact on Italy’s economy, military, and social fabric contributed to the undermining of the Liberal Kingdom, the destruction of the Liberal consensus, and ultimately the rise of fascism under Benito Mussolini. The war’s legacy continues to shape Italian history, reminding us of the devastating consequences of political and military decisions.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Essay Outline: Consequences of Italy's World War One Decisions
Introduction
Briefly introduce the Kingdom of Italy's predicament in 1914-1915 – torn between neutrality and potential gains from joining the war. Clearly state your argument: Entering World War One in 1915 had more serious consequences for the Kingdom of Italy.Briefly outline the key arguments supporting this stance (destruction of liberal consensus, undermining of the Liberal Kingdom's capacity, and the split within the Liberal elite, all paving the way for Mussolini).
Body Paragraph 1: Consequences of Neutrality (1914)
Explain Italy's initial decision to remain neutral. Highlight potential benefits Italy hoped to gain (e.g., territorial concessions from Austria-Hungary).
Analyze the limited consequences of neutrality. While some economic and social tensions arose, they were manageable and did not fundamentally threaten the existing political order.
Transition: However, the decision to enter the war in 1915 had far more profound and lasting consequences.
Body Paragraph 2: Catastrophic Consequences of Entering the War (1915)
Explain the factors leading to Italy's entry into World War One. Discuss the Treaty of London and the promises of territorial gain, as well as the influence of nationalist sentiment.
Detail the devastating impact of the war on Italy.
Military and Civilian Losses:Emphasize the heavy casualties, economic ruin, and social unrest caused by the war.
Political Instability:Explain how the war exacerbated existing political divisions and undermined the credibility of the Liberal government.
Connect to Mussolini's Rise:Show how the war created a climate of disillusionment and resentment that Mussolini exploited to gain power.
Body Paragraph 3: The War's Role in Undermining the Liberal Kingdom
Examine the war's impact on Italian society. Explain how it led to:
Rise of Nationalism and Discontent: Veterans felt betrayed by the "mutilated victory," contributing to social unrest.
Economic Crisis: Focus on inflation, unemployment, and the inability of the Liberal government to address these issues effectively.
Link this directly to the erosion of public trust in the Liberal elite. Highlight how their perceived incompetence during and after the war paved the way for alternative political forces.
Body Paragraph 4: The Split Within the Liberal Elite
Analyze how the war intensified divisions within the Liberal party. Explain how disagreements over war aims and strategies created lasting rifts.
Focus on key figures: Contrast the approaches of pro-war nationalists like D'Annunzio with more moderate Liberals.
Explain how this division weakened the Liberals and made them vulnerable to challenges from both the left and the right, creating an opening for Mussolini's rise.
Conclusion
Reaffirm the argument: While staying neutral in 1914 might have led to missed opportunities, entering World War One in 1915 had far more severe and enduring consequences for the Kingdom of Italy.
Summarize the key points: Briefly reiterate how the war destroyed the liberal consensus, undermined the Liberal Kingdom's capacity to govern effectively, and led to a split within the Liberal élite, ultimately facilitating Mussolini's rise to power.
Offer a final thought:Perhaps consider the long-term implications of Italy's wartime experience for its political development in the 20th century.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Entering World War One in 1915
Entering World War One in 1915 had more serious consequences for the Kingdom of Italy.
⭐It destroyed Italy’s liberal consensus and paved the way for the rise of Mussolini.
⭐It led to Italy’s experience in the war, which further undermined the capacity of the Liberal Kingdom.
⭐It led to the split of the Liberal élite, which prepared the ground for the rise of Mussolini.