In the years 1936 to 1946, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) changed radically. Assess the validity of this view.
Level
A Level
Year Examined
2019
Topic
The Transformation of China, 1936-1997
👑Complete Model Essay
In the years 1936 to 1946, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) changed radically. Assess the validity of this view.
In the years 1936 to 1946, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) changed radically. Assess the validity of this view.
The CCP in 1936, reeling from the Long March and facing an existential threat from the Guomindang (GMD), was a far cry from the party that emerged triumphant in 1949. The decade between 1936 and 1946 was undeniably transformative, marked by war, ideological shifts, and internal power struggles. This essay will argue that while the CCP underwent significant changes during this period, particularly in terms of its support base and organization, it is crucial to acknowledge elements of continuity, especially regarding its leadership and core ideology. Therefore, the view that the CCP changed "radically" requires a nuanced assessment.
Arguments for Radical Change
One of the most significant changes was the dramatic expansion of the CCP's support base and territorial control. The brutality of the GMD and the Japanese occupation drove many Chinese, particularly peasants, towards the CCP's promise of land reform and national salvation. By 1946, the CCP controlled areas with a population of around 90 million, a stark contrast to its precarious position in 1936. This growth was accompanied by a shift in the party's image, transforming from a group of radical revolutionaries to a more inclusive force fighting for national liberation.
This period also witnessed a radical shift in the CCP's leadership. The discrediting of the Young Bolsheviks, the desertion of leaders like Zhang Guotao, and the Rectification Campaign (1942-1944) consolidated Mao Zedong's authority. By 1946, Mao emerged as the unchallenged leader, his ideology shaping the party's future direction. The Rectification Campaign, in particular, purged the party of Soviet-influenced ideologies, paving the way for Maoism to take root.
Furthermore, the Second United Front with the GMD, necessitated by the Japanese invasion, forced the CCP to adapt its organizational structure. It transitioned from open warfare with the GMD to a more complex relationship of uneasy alliance and strategic maneuvering. This period provided the CCP with valuable experience in governance and military organization, which proved crucial in the subsequent civil war.
Arguments Against Radical Change
However, characterizing the changes as "radical" overlooks critical elements of continuity. The CCP's support base, while larger, remained predominantly peasant-based. Its policies, like land redistribution, continued to target the peasantry, and its new cadres were largely drawn from rural areas. While its control expanded, it remained confined to the countryside, as the GMD and Japanese controlled major cities.
Despite the Second United Front, the CCP's relationship with the GMD remained adversarial. The GMD never fully ceased its attempts to contain the CCP, as evidenced by the renewed blockade of Yan'an in 1939 and the New Fourth Army Incident in 1941. This underlying tension suggests that the CCP's organizational adaptation was less a radical shift and more a pragmatic response to a complex situation.
Moreover, while Mao's authority grew, his influence on the CCP predates 1936. He played a critical role in establishing the Jiangxi Soviet and the Yan'an base, and his focus on peasant mobilization shaped the party's strategies even before this period. His rise to preeminence was less a radical departure and more a culmination of his growing influence within the party.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the CCP underwent significant changes between 1936 and 1946, portraying them as "radical" risks oversimplification. The party's growth in size and strength, the consolidation of Mao's leadership, and its organizational adaptations were undoubtedly crucial developments. However, these changes occurred within the context of pre-existing ideological leanings, a consistent focus on peasant mobilization, and a persistent rivalry with the GMD.
Ultimately, the CCP's transformation was a complex process, blending elements of change and continuity. By 1946, the party was undoubtedly stronger, more experienced, and better positioned to challenge the GMD. However, the seeds of this success were sown in the preceding years, demonstrating that the changes, while significant, were part of a longer evolutionary trajectory rather than a complete ideological and organizational overhaul.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
In the years 1936 to 1946, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) changed radically. Assess the validity of this view.
This essay will assess the validity of the view that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) underwent radical transformation between 1936 and 1946. It will argue that while the CCP did experience significant changes, the fundamental aspects of its support base, ideology, and organizational structure remained largely consistent. The essay will explore both the arguments supporting and challenging this view.
Arguments supporting radical change:
Expansion of power and support: The CCP's territory and popular support grew dramatically during this period. The GMD's brutality and Japanese oppression pushed many towards the CCP. By 1946, the CCP controlled areas with a population of around 90 million, a stark contrast to its smaller, struggling presence in 1936.
Leadership changes: The CCP witnessed significant shifts in its leadership during this period. The discrediting of the Young Bolsheviks, the desertion of leaders like Zhang Guotao, and the Rectification Campaign in Yan'an led to Mao Zedong's emergence as the unchallenged leader by 1946.
Ideological shifts: The CCP's ideology underwent changes to increase class participation. The adoption of the "mass line," the emphasis on learning from the people, and the incorporation of the "national bourgeoisie" as a revolutionary class created a more inclusive Party by 1946.
Organizational changes: The Second United Front altered the CCP's organization. The shift from fighting against the GMD to fighting alongside it against the Japanese offered a respite from the GMD's suppression campaigns.
Arguments challenging radical change:
Consistent support base: The CCP's support base remained primarily peasant-based throughout this period. Its policies and cadres largely stemmed from rural areas, reflecting a focus on agrarian issues.
Continuous GMD hostility: Despite the Second United Front, the GMD maintained hostility towards the CCP. The GMD renewed its blockade of Yan'an in 1939, and the New Fourth Army Incident in 1941 demonstrated ongoing tensions.
Soviet influence: Soviet attempts to influence the CCP continued throughout this period. Stalin's recognition of the GMD as China's official government and his pressure on Jiang Jieshi during the X'ian Incident suggest a consistent Soviet influence.
Mao Zedong's consistent influence: While Mao Zedong's power increased during this period, his influence was already significant in the CCP. His peasant-driven policies remained central to the Party's ideology.
Conclusion:
While the CCP underwent significant changes in terms of expansion, leadership, and ideology during the period under examination, there is evidence to suggest that its fundamental characteristics remained relatively constant. The CCP's support base remained predominantly peasant-based, its organization was continuously challenged by GMD hostility, and Mao's influence remained prominent. While the changes were significant, the CCP's core identity remained consistent. By 1946, the CCP had become a stronger, more organized force, but it was still essentially the same peasant-based, Maoist-led party that had emerged during the Long March.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Arguments Supporting Radical Change in the CCP (1936-1946)
Arguments supporting the view that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) underwent radical change between 1936 and 1946 include:
⭐Expansion of Support Base and Control: The CCP witnessed significant growth in its support base and control over territory by 1946. GMD cruelty and Japanese oppression during this period pushed many towards the CCP, leading to the Party controlling areas with a population of around 90 million by 1946. This marked a dramatic change from the struggling, small Party of 1936.
⭐Leadership Transformation: The CCP leadership underwent significant changes during this period. The discrediting of the Young Bolsheviks, desertion of leaders like Zhang Guotao, and the Rectification Campaign in Yan’an (1942-1944) resulted in Mao Zedong emerging as the unchallenged leader of the CCP by 1946.
⭐Ideological Shifts: The CCP's ideology underwent radical changes to increase class participation. Developments like the implementation of the 'mass line' policy and the incorporation of the 'national bourgeoisie' as a revolutionary class created a more inclusive Party by 1946 compared to 1936.
⭐Organizational Changes: The CCP underwent a significant transformation as a result of the Second United Front. The Party transitioned from fighting against the GMD to fighting alongside it against the Japanese, providing a crucial period of respite from the GMD's fierce extermination campaigns.
Arguments Challenging Radical Change in the CCP (1936-1946)
Arguments challenging the view that the CCP underwent radical change between 1936 and 1946 include:
⭐Consistent Peasant Support: The CCP's support base remained primarily rooted in the peasantry throughout the period. Their policies like land reform targeted peasants, and most new CCP cadres were drawn from rural areas. While the CCP expanded, it did so primarily in agricultural areas due to the GMD and Japanese control over Chinese cities.
⭐Continued GMD Hostility: Despite the Second United Front, the CCP faced ongoing hostility from the GMD. The GMD renewed their blockade of Yan'an in 1939, and the New Fourth Army Incident of 1941 exemplifies the continued tensions. While the Civil War officially resumed in 1946, hostilities never truly ceased.
⭐Soviet Influence: Soviet attempts to influence the CCP continued throughout the period, and relations with the USSR were often strained. Soviet pressure prevented Jiang Jieshi's execution during the X'ian Incident and resulted in Stalin recognizing the GMD as the official government of China.
⭐Mao’s Consistent Influence: Although his power grew during this period, Mao consistently influenced the CCP between 1936 and 1946. He was largely credited with establishing the CCP base at Yan'an. The Party's policies were driven by his peasant-centric approach.
Conclusion
The CCP did undergo significant changes between 1936 and 1946. Although some elements remained consistent, these changes transformed the Party into a much more credible force by 1946. By 1946, the CCP was a genuine contender for political power in China, a stark contrast to its struggling beginnings in 1936. The changes the Party underwent were demonstrably impactful.