top of page

‘US reaction to the Cuban Revolution was the main cause of the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Level

A Level

Year Examined

2022

Topic

International history, 1945–92

👑Complete Model Essay

‘US reaction to the Cuban Revolution was the main cause of the Cuban Missile Crisis.

US reaction to the Cuban Revolution was the main cause of the Cuban Missile Crisis. Assess this view.

The Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962, a tense standoff between the United States and the Soviet Union over Soviet nuclear missiles deployed in Cuba, was a defining moment of the Cold War. While the crisis had multiple contributing factors, it can be argued that the US reaction to the Cuban Revolution, particularly its unwavering hostility towards Fidel Castro's regime, played a significant role in creating the conditions that led to the confrontation.

The US had long held considerable economic and political influence in Cuba. The 1950s saw the US support the dictatorship of Fulgencio Batista, a regime widely perceived as corrupt and oppressive. The US government prioritised stability and its own economic interests over the welfare of the Cuban people. This approach fuelled resentment towards the US and contributed to the rise of Fidel Castro's revolutionary movement.

Castro's victory in 1959 and his subsequent socialist reforms, including the nationalisation of US-owned businesses, were met with immediate hostility from the US government. The Eisenhower and Kennedy administrations viewed Castro's government as a dangerous precedent, fearing the spread of communism throughout Latin America, a region considered by the US to be within its sphere of influence. This fear, often referred to as the "domino theory," shaped US foreign policy and drove its determination to undermine Castro's regime.

The US response to the Cuban Revolution was multifaceted and aggressive. Economic sanctions were imposed, aiming to cripple the Cuban economy. The US orchestrated the disastrous Bay of Pigs invasion in 1961, a failed attempt to overthrow Castro using Cuban exiles trained and funded by the CIA. The operation's failure was a significant humiliation for the Kennedy administration and served only to further antagonize Castro and push him closer to the Soviet Union. Following the Bay of Pigs, the US continued to engage in covert operations aimed at destabilizing Cuba, including assassination plots against Castro and sabotage missions targeting the island's infrastructure, known as Operation Mongoose. This relentless pressure and hostility from the US left Castro feeling increasingly vulnerable and reliant on Soviet support.

From Khrushchev's perspective, the Cuban Revolution presented an opportunity to bolster his own standing within the Soviet Union and advance Soviet interests on the world stage. Khrushchev, facing internal criticism and challenges to his leadership, saw an opportunity to secure a strategic ally in the Western Hemisphere, directly challenging US dominance. Deploying nuclear missiles to Cuba, a move Khrushchev likely believed the US would not tolerate, offered a chance to appear strong and decisive, potentially enhancing his domestic position and projecting Soviet power globally.

While US hostility towards Castro was a significant factor leading to the crisis, Khrushchev's miscalculation of US resolve cannot be ignored. He underestimated Kennedy's determination to remove the missiles and misjudged the potential for escalation to nuclear war. The US naval blockade of Cuba, combined with Kennedy's firm stance and back-channel diplomacy, ultimately forced Khrushchev to back down, removing the missiles in exchange for a US pledge not to invade Cuba and the secret removal of US missiles from Turkey.

In conclusion, while Khrushchev's decision to place missiles in Cuba was the immediate trigger of the crisis, US actions following the Cuban Revolution significantly contributed to the escalation of tensions. The US's persistent hostility towards Castro's regime, its efforts to isolate Cuba economically and politically, and its involvement in covert operations created an environment of fear and mistrust that made Cuba receptive to Soviet overtures and provided Khrushchev with the pretext he needed to justify his actions. Therefore, while not the sole cause, the US reaction to the Cuban Revolution was a crucial factor in the chain of events that culminated in the Cuban Missile Crisis.

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

Introduction
Briefly introduce the Cuban Revolution and the Cuban Missile Crisis. State the essay's main argument: While US hostility towards Castro's regime significantly contributed to the crisis, Khrushchev's actions and motivations played an equally crucial role.

US Reaction to the Cuban Revolution
US Hostility: Discuss the US's longstanding economic and political interests in Cuba, support for Batista, and refusal to accept Castro's communist government. Explain how these actions pushed Castro towards the Soviet Union.
Bay of Pigs & Operation Mongoose: Analyze the impact of the failed Bay of Pigs invasion and Operation Mongoose on US-Cuban relations. Explain how these events increased tensions and reinforced Castro's reliance on Soviet support.

Khrushchev's Motivations
Domestic & International Pressures: Analyze Khrushchev's domestic and international challenges, including the "Secret Speech," uprisings in Eastern Europe, tensions with China, and the Berlin Wall. Explain how these pressures influenced his decision-making.
Opportunity in Cuba: Explain how Khrushchev saw the Cuban Revolution as an opportunity to advance Soviet interests by establishing a strategic ally in the Western Hemisphere, potentially spreading communism, and challenging US dominance.
Miscalculations and Underestimations: Discuss how Khrushchev misjudged Kennedy's resolve and underestimated the US response to the missile deployment. Explain how his miscalculations contributed to the crisis.

The Missile Deployment and Crisis
Soviet Missiles in Cuba: Explain the significance of the Soviet missile deployment in Cuba and its impact on the regional power balance. Analyze why this action provoked a strong US reaction.
Kennedy's Response: Discuss Kennedy's options and his decision to implement a naval blockade of Cuba. Analyze the role of diplomacy and negotiation in resolving the crisis.

Conclusion
Summarize the key arguments and reiterate that while US hostility towards Castro's regime was a significant factor, Khrushchev's motivations and actions played an equally crucial role in causing the Cuban Missile Crisis. The crisis was a culmination of both countries' actions and miscalculations during a period of heightened Cold War tensions.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

US reaction to the Cuban Revolution was the main cause of the Cuban Missile Crisis. Assess this view.

The Cuban Revolution brought Fidel Castro to power. US refusal to accept his rule and failure to overthrow him drove Castro into an alliance with the Soviets. The United States wanted to retain their influence in Cuba and during the 1950s had supported the corrupt and oppressive rule of Batista. Much of Cuba's industry was owned by US business and its main export, sugar, was controlled by the United States. Batista’s government was very unpopular, and Fidel Castro led a revolution against him in 1958. Havana fell in 1959 and Batista fled from Cuba. Castro formed a government, but he wanted to be free from US influence. He nationalised businesses and geared the economy to help the poorer Cubans. US refusal to accept Castro’s communist government drove Castro to seek Soviet support. However, the United States regarded itself as the protector of South and Central American countries from outside interference and believed that if Cuba remained communist, this would also spread to Latin America affecting US interests. The United States stopped selling arms to Cuba and considered banning the purchase of sugar and Castro asked the Soviet Union to buy it instead.

Some of Batista’s supporters formed part of a US plan to invade Cuba in 1961 and overthrow Castro. The Bay of Pigs landing proved to be a humiliating failure, but Castro was certain that the United States wanted to overthrow him. Kennedy and the CIA then approved Operation Mongoose whereby Cuban exiles and the CIA attacked industry and farmland and assassinated members of Castro’s government. Kennedy was obsessed with defeating Castro and removing any communist threat so close to the United States. The US provided the opportunity for Khrushchev to protect Cuba.

Khrushchev was unpopular in the Soviet Union; it was felt that he would not be able to bring about a worldwide communist revolution. By the late 1950s, he was losing support in Russia. He was disliked for his ‘Secret Speech’ in which he criticised the communist regime and many of its leaders. He also faced rebellions in Poland and Hungary in 1956 and the Berlin Wall, erected in 1961, showed that he had to imprison citizens to prevent them from escaping from East Germany. Relations had also deteriorated with China. The opportunity to assist Cuba made it look as if he was helping a communist state in danger and he might have the chance to spread communism to Latin America. He had also underestimated Kennedy and thought that he could risk putting intermediate-range ballistic missiles on Cuba in 1962. He believed that Kennedy was weak because of the Bay of Pigs invasion. Kennedy had not taken military action after the building of the Berlin Wall and Khrushchev believed he would not be able to deal with Soviet military presence in Cuba. Khrushchev certainly misjudged the situation in 1962. He felt justified in helping to spread communism and protecting Castro. The crisis began with his decision to install intermediate and medium-range nuclear missiles in Cuba. Kennedy saw U2 pictures of the missiles on 16 October 1962; they had been secretly deployed by Khrushchev in April. The Americans had been lied to about the Soviet intentions making a US response inevitable. Such missiles could threaten most US cities. However, he could have defended Cuba with conventional weapons. It seems likely that Khrushchev wanted to appear to have greater military strength than the United States. Appearing to defend the Cuban Revolution gave Khrushchev the opportunity to try to score a nuclear success over the Americans.

bottom of page