top of page

How significant have the Palestinians been in the development of the Arab-Israeli dispute?

Level

O LEVEL

Year Examined

2022

Topic

ISRAELIS AND PALESTINIANS SINCE 1945

👑Complete Model Essay

How significant have the Palestinians been in the development of the Arab-Israeli dispute?

The Significance of Palestinians in the Arab-Israeli Dispute

The Arab-Israeli dispute is a complex and multifaceted issue with a long and bloody history. While numerous actors have played significant roles, the Palestinians have undoubtedly been central to the conflict's development. This essay argues that their actions and experiences have been crucial in shaping the conflict's trajectory and remain key to any lasting resolution.

The Palestinian Exodus and the Rise of Nationalism

The 1948-49 war, culminating in the establishment of Israel, witnessed a mass exodus of Palestinians. While the exact circumstances remain contested, actions by Zionist groups like Irgun and Lehi instilled fear and panic among Arab villagers. This resulted in approximately 700,000 Palestinians fleeing their homes, becoming refugees in neighboring Arab countries. This displacement, coupled with the loss of their homeland, fueled Palestinian nationalism and a deep-seated resentment towards Israel.

The displacement also had a profound impact on the broader Arab world, solidifying Arab nationalism and antagonism towards Israel. This shared sense of injustice provided fertile ground for the emergence of groups like Fatah and later the PLO, led by Yasser Arafat. These organizations engaged in armed struggle against Israel, further escalating the conflict. Border raids, hijackings, and attacks on Israeli civilians, while condemned by many, were seen by some Palestinians as legitimate resistance against occupation.

Palestinian Resistance and the International Stage

The Palestinian struggle gained international attention, with the PLO recognized by the UN as the representative of the Palestinian people. This platform allowed them to voice their grievances and demand self-determination. The Palestinian Authority (PA) was established following the Oslo Accords, a landmark event representing a significant step towards Palestinian autonomy, albeit limited. However, the continued expansion of Israeli settlements in the West Bank and the failure to reach a final status agreement exacerbated tensions.

The rise of Hamas in Gaza and its control over the territory further complicated the situation. Hamas, designated a terrorist organization by many countries, engaged in rocket attacks against Israel, leading to devastating retaliatory strikes. While these actions have been condemned internationally, they underline the desperation and frustration felt by a significant portion of Palestinians.

Counterarguments: The Role of Other Actors

It's crucial to acknowledge that focusing solely on the Palestinians' role risks oversimplifying the conflict. Israel's policies, including territorial expansion and settlement building, have fueled Palestinian resentment and hindered peace efforts. The actions of Arab neighbors like Egypt, Jordan, and Syria, as well as the involvement of superpowers like the US and USSR, have also significantly shaped the conflict's trajectory.

Conclusion

While numerous actors have contributed to the Arab-Israeli conflict, the Palestinians' role has been undeniably significant. The trauma of displacement, the struggle for self-determination, and the ongoing occupation have shaped their actions and fueled the conflict's persistence. While other parties bear responsibility for their actions, any lasting solution necessitates addressing Palestinian grievances and aspirations. Acknowledging their centrality is not to diminish the roles of others but to recognize that peace requires a just and equitable resolution for all involved.

**Source:**

Fawaz, L. (2015). *A History of the Arab-Israeli Conflict*. Saqi Books.

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

I. Significance of the Palestinians in the Development of the Arab-Israeli Dispute

A. Contributions to the Outbreak of the Conflict

Yes: The actions of Irgun and Lehi created terror and precipitated the displacement of 300,000 Arab villagers, enlarging Israel's territory.
No: Israeli expansionism, Arab nationalism, and the role of Egypt under Nasser were more influential.

B. Palestinian Nationalism and the Growth of the Conflict

Yes: The refugee crisis fueled Palestinian nationalism and the formation of militant groups like Al Fatah and the PLO.
No: The broader Arab nationalist movements, such as those led by Egypt and Syria, played a more significant role.

C. Escalating Violence and Border Raids

Yes: Palestinian cross-border raids from Lebanon led to Israeli invasions and intensified the conflict.
No: The pre-emptive attacks by Egypt and Syria in the Six Day War and Israel's subsequent occupation were more impactful.

D. Diplomacy and Peace Efforts

Yes: The PLO's involvement in the Oslo Accords and the establishment of the Palestinian Authority were important developments.
No: The Camp David Accords between Israel and Egypt under Carter were more substantial in shaping the conflict's trajectory.

E. Ongoing Tensions and the Role of Hamas

Yes: Hamas's resistance in Gaza and the West Bank has perpetuated the conflict.
No: The actions of Israeli settlers and the ongoing occupation have been more influential factors.

II. Conclusion

Yes: The actions of the Palestinians have been significant in the development of the conflict, contributing to displacement, violence, and the rise of militant groups.
No: While the Palestinians have played a role, the broader regional dynamics involving Israel, Arab states, and international powers have been the primary driving forces behind the Arab-Israeli dispute.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

How significant have the Palestinians been in the development of the Arab-Israeli dispute? Explain your answer.

YES

Actions of Irgun and Lehi during the 1948–49 war created terror in the minds of Arab villagers in Palestine; 300 000 fled their homes to other parts of Palestine and neighbouring Arab countries; Israel increased its territory by 21% by 1949 and pushed many refugees to Transjordan, Egypt, Syria and Lebanon; 1967, Israel tripled its size and increased the number of refugees to over 700 000; led to increased Palestinian nationalism and Arab nationalism – opposition to state of Israel; formation of Al Fatah and later PLO led by Arafat; border raids into Israel; raids from Lebanon led to Israeli invasion in 1978 and 1982; PLO involvement in Oslo Agreement; Palestinian Authority; role of Hamas in Gaza and West Bank, etc.


NO

More important: role of Israel – expansion of territory and settlers in Palestinian Arab areas; role of Nasser and nationalisation of Suez Canal; pre-emptive attack of Egypt and Syria in Six Day War; role of Begin and Sadat and Camp David Talks with Carter; roles of Palestinian neighbours such as Jordan, Egypt, Syria; roles played by the superpowers – USA and financial and military support for Israel; Soviet military aid to Syria and Egypt; role of Britain and France; actions by the UN in peace talks and dealing with refugee crisis, etc

bottom of page