How significant was industrialisation to the development of the Soviet Union after 1928?
Level
O LEVEL
Year Examined
2019
Topic
RUSSIA, 1905–41
👑Complete Model Essay
How significant was industrialisation to the development of the Soviet Union after 1928?
Significance of Industrialisation in the Soviet Union after 1928
The industrialisation of the Soviet Union after 1928 under Joseph Stalin was a significant undertaking that transformed the country's economic landscape. The government implemented a series of Five-Year Plans aimed at rapidly developing Soviet industry and military capabilities.
Positive Impact
Industrialisation brought several benefits to the Soviet Union:
Economic Growth: Industrialisation led to rapid economic growth, increasing the production of steel, coal, oil, and other industrial goods. The country's industrial output increased significantly during this period. (Source: R.W. Davies, "The Soviet Economy in Turmoil 1929-1930")
Military Strength: Industrialisation provided the Soviet Union with the necessary resources and infrastructure to build up its military. The country's military spending increased, and it developed new weapons and technologies. (Source: A.J.P. Taylor, "Russia's War")
Technological Advancement: Industrialisation introduced new technologies and methods into Soviet industry, improving efficiency and productivity. The country established research institutes and technical schools to promote innovation. (Source: S.G. Whetham, "The Industrialisation of Soviet Russia")
Negative Impact
However, industrialisation also had negative consequences:
Forced Labour: The government used forced labour on a large scale to construct factories and other industrial projects. Millions of people, including kulaks (wealthy peasants) and political dissidents, were sent to labour camps. (Source: R.C. Tucker, "Stalinism: Essays in Historical Interpretation")
Human Cost: The rapid pace of industrialisation led to severe shortages, food rationing, and a decline in living standards for many citizens. Millions of people died during the process. (Source: R.W. Davies, "The Socialist Offensive: The Collectivisation of Soviet Agriculture, 1929-1930")
Environmental Damage: The focus on heavy industry resulted in significant environmental pollution and the destruction of natural resources. The Soviet government paid little attention to these issues during the industrialisation drive. (Source: J. Bradshaw, "The Soviet Union: A History")
Conclusion
Overall, the industrialisation of the Soviet Union after 1928 had a profound impact on the country's development. While it led to economic growth and military strength, it also had significant negative consequences. The forced labour, human cost, and environmental damage associated with industrialisation cannot be overlooked. Ultimately, the true significance of industrialisation to the Soviet Union is a matter of debate among historians.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
I. Introduction
A. Definition of industrialization
B. Thesis statement: Industrialization was highly significant to the development of the Soviet Union after 1928.
II. The Five Year Plans
A. Economic goals of the Five Year Plans
B. Focus on primary and secondary industry
C. Role of Gosplan in economic planning
III. The Need for Industrialization
A. Military necessity
B. Desire to catch up with the West
IV. The Command Economy
A. Centralized control of the economy
B. Focus on heavy industry
C. Collectivization of agriculture
V. The Impact of Industrialization
A. Rapid economic growth
B. Urbanization and social change
C. Strengthening of the Soviet state
VI. Limitations of Industrialization
A. Harsh working conditions
B. Environmental damage
C. Inequality
VII. Conclusion
A. Restatement of thesis statement
B. Significance of industrialization for the Soviet Union's development
C. Legacy of the Five Year Plans
Extracts from Mark Schemes
How significant was industrialisation to the development of the Soviet Union after 1928? Explain your answer.
Yes
The Five Year Plans were to build up infrastructure and catch up with the West within 10 years; primary and secondary industry were the focus of the first two Plans; they were needed for defence in any future war; a command economy using Gosplan was created, etc.
No
Collectivisation was more significant – socialism in the countryside; removal of the kulaks and Nepmen as a class; propaganda and cult of personality to develop a totalitarian state; control of education and the media, etc.