To What Extent Did British Policy Towards the USSR Change During the 1930s?

British policy towards the USSR during the 1930s was characterized by a complex interplay of ideological suspicion, geopolitical considerations, and pragmatic adjustments. While it can be argued that the fundamental distrust of Soviet communism remained a consistent element throughout the decade, there were notable shifts and attempts at rapprochement, particularly in response to the growing threat of Nazi Germany. This essay will analyze the extent to which British policy towards the USSR underwent transformation during this pivotal period.

The legacy of the Bolshevik Revolution in 1917 cast a long shadow over Anglo-Soviet relations. Conservative governments, which dominated British politics throughout the 1930s, harbored deep ideological antipathy towards communism. The Soviet Union, with its collectivized economy and one-party state, was viewed as a fundamental challenge to the existing world order. This distrust was exacerbated by Soviet support for international communist movements, which were perceived as a threat to British imperial interests. The Comintern (Communist International), established in 1919, actively sought to promote global revolution, further fueling British anxieties.

The Spanish Civil War (1936-1939) served as a litmus test for Anglo-Soviet relations. Despite officially adhering to the Non-Intervention Agreement, the Soviet Union provided material support to the Republican government, which was fighting against a fascist uprising led by General Francisco Franco. Britain, on the other hand, remained largely neutral, fearing that intervention would escalate the conflict into a wider European war. The Soviet Union's actions in Spain reinforced British perceptions of Moscow as an unreliable and ideologically driven actor.

The Munich Conference of 1938 marked a low point in Anglo-Soviet relations. Despite having a defense pact with both France and Czechoslovakia, the Soviet Union was excluded from the negotiations, which ultimately resulted in the cession of the Sudetenland to Nazi Germany. This exclusion highlighted the deep mistrust between the West and the Soviet Union, as well as the British government's willingness to appease Hitler in the hope of avoiding another devastating war.

However, it would be an oversimplification to argue that British policy towards the USSR remained static throughout the 1930s. There were periods of tentative cooperation and even attempts at forging a united front against Nazi aggression. In 1930, a Labour government under Ramsay MacDonald restored diplomatic relations with the Soviet Union and renewed trade agreements. This brief period of rapprochement, however, was driven more by economic pragmatism than any fundamental shift in ideological outlook.

In 1934, the Soviet Union was admitted to the League of Nations, with no objections from Britain. This move was seen as a way to integrate the Soviet Union into the existing international order and encourage responsible behavior on the world stage. However, the League's ineffectiveness in addressing the challenges posed by Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy ultimately rendered its significance limited.

The Nazi-Soviet Pact of August 1939 sent shockwaves through Europe and shattered any remaining illusions of a united front against Hitler. From the British perspective, the pact confirmed their worst fears about Soviet intentions, portraying Stalin as an opportunistic and untrustworthy leader. The pact also had the effect of further poisoning Anglo-Soviet relations, making any form of meaningful cooperation virtually impossible.

In conclusion, British policy towards the USSR during the 1930s was characterized by a combination of continuity and change. While the underlying distrust of Soviet communism remained a constant, there were notable attempts at rapprochement, driven by geopolitical considerations and a shared concern over the rise of Nazi Germany. However, these attempts were ultimately unsuccessful, hampered by ideological differences, mutual suspicion, and a series of events that deepened the mistrust between the two countries. The Nazi-Soviet Pact of 1939 marked the culmination of this process, leaving Anglo-Soviet relations in a state of profound hostility on the eve of World War II.

Bibliography

Andrew, C. (2000). The Penguin History of Modern Britain: 1914 to the present. London: Penguin Books.
<br>
Roberts, J. (1999). Twentieth Century Britain. London: Longman.
<br>
Weinberg, G. L. (1995). A World at Arms: A Global History of World War II. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.