06 Which of the following saw more change as a result of Lenin’s policies: the way Russia was ruled and controlled the economy of Russia?
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2022
Topic
World History
👑Complete Model Essay
06 Which of the following saw more change as a result of Lenin’s policies: the way Russia was ruled and controlled the economy of Russia?
Which of the following saw more change as a result of Lenin's policies: the way Russia was ruled and controlled or the economy of Russia?
Introduction
Following the Bolshevik seizure of power in 1917, Vladimir Lenin, the first leader of Soviet Russia, implemented a series of radical policies that profoundly transformed the nation's political and economic landscape. This essay will argue that while Lenin's policies instigated significant change in both spheres, the economy of Russia underwent a more drastic transformation. This argument will be supported by examining the extent of change in both governance and the economy.
Body Paragraph 1: Political Control and the Consolidation of Power
Lenin's policies undoubtedly revolutionized the way Russia was ruled. He swiftly dismantled the provisional government and established a one-party state under the Bolsheviks. The dissolution of the democratically elected Constituent Assembly in January 1918 demonstrated Lenin's unwavering commitment to Bolshevik dominance, even at the expense of democratic principles. Furthermore, the signing of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, while deeply unpopular, allowed Lenin to secure peace with Germany and consolidate his power amidst the ongoing civil war. The creation of the Cheka, a secret police force, and the subsequent Red Terror, a period of brutal repression against perceived enemies of the revolution, further solidified Bolshevik control by effectively silencing dissent and eliminating opposition.
Body Paragraph 2: Economic Upheaval and the New Economic Policy
While Lenin's political changes were significant, his economic policies arguably produced even more radical transformations. War Communism, implemented during the Russian Civil War (1918-1922), represented a dramatic attempt to establish a fully socialist economy. This policy entailed the nationalization of industries, forced grain requisitioning from the peasantry, and the abolishment of private trade. However, these measures had disastrous consequences, leading to economic collapse, hyperinflation, and widespread famine.
Recognizing the devastating impact of War Communism, Lenin introduced the New Economic Policy (NEP) in 1921. The NEP marked a significant departure from communist ideals by allowing for a mixed economy. Peasants were permitted to sell their surplus produce for profit, private trade and small businesses were reintroduced, and foreign investment was encouraged. Despite opposition from some within the Bolshevik party, the NEP proved remarkably successful. It revitalized the economy, alleviated food shortages, and provided a much-needed period of stability and recovery following years of turmoil.
Body Paragraph 3: Comparing the Extent of Change
Comparing the two spheres, the shift in the economy appears more dramatic. Politically, Russia transitioned from a Tsarist autocracy to a Bolshevik dictatorship - a significant change, but one that primarily involved a shift in leadership and ideology, while retaining existing power structures. The economic changes under Lenin, however, were far more profound. War Communism completely overturned centuries-old economic practices and traditions in Russia. Even the subsequent introduction of the NEP, while pragmatic, represented a significant ideological compromise and a recognition that a purely socialist economy was not immediately achievable. This willingness to adapt and change course, even if it meant temporarily abandoning core communist principles, demonstrates the profound impact the economic realities had on shaping Lenin’s policies.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while Lenin's policies undeniably revolutionized both governance and the economy of Russia, the scale and depth of change in the economic sphere were more profound. The implementation and subsequent reversal of War Communism, followed by the introduction of the NEP, represented a period of unprecedented upheaval and transformation in the economic fabric of Russian society. While the shift from Tsarist autocracy to Bolshevik rule was significant, it was the economic turmoil and subsequent pragmatic adjustments that arguably had the most dramatic and far-reaching impact on the lives of ordinary Russians.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Which of the following saw more change as a result of Lenin's policies: the way Russia was ruled and controlled or the economy of Russia?
Introduction
This essay will argue that while Lenin's policies drastically altered both the political and economic landscape of Russia, the economy underwent more substantial change. While Lenin's political changes primarily focused on consolidating Bolshevik power, his economic policies transformed the very fabric of Russian society, transitioning it from a struggling wartime economy to a mixed system with capitalist elements.
Body Paragraph 1: Political Control and the Consolidation of Power
Lenin's policies undoubtedly revolutionized the way Russia was ruled, establishing a one-party state under the Bolsheviks. The dissolution of the Constituent Assembly, the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, and the subsequent civil war dramatically reshaped the political landscape. The creation of the Cheka and the Red Terror further tightened Bolshevik control, suppressing dissent and solidifying Lenin's grip on power.
Example 1: The forced closure of the Constituent Assembly demonstrated Lenin's disregard for democratic processes and his commitment to maintaining Bolshevik dominance.
Example 2: Banning opposition parties and censoring non-Bolshevik newspapers effectively eliminated political competition and dissent.
Body Paragraph 2: Economic Upheaval and the New Economic Policy
While Lenin's political changes were significant, his economic policies arguably produced more radical transformations. War Communism, implemented during the civil war, brought about widespread economic upheaval. Nationalization of industries, forced grain requisitioning, and the abolishment of private trade led to economic collapse and widespread famine.
Example 1: The dire economic situation forced Lenin to introduce the New Economic Policy (NEP) in 1921. This marked a significant departure from communist ideals by reintroducing private enterprise and allowing peasants to sell their surplus produce for profit.
Example 2: The NEP's success in revitalizing the economy and alleviating food shortages illustrates the profound impact Lenin's economic policies had on everyday life in Russia.
Body Paragraph 3: Comparing the Extent of Change
Comparing the two spheres, the shift in the economy appears more dramatic. While politically, Russia transitioned from a Tsarist autocracy to a Bolshevik dictatorship, the economic changes under Lenin were more profound. The NEP represented a temporary abandonment of core communist principles to address the desperate economic reality. This pragmatic approach demonstrated a willingness to adapt and change course, even if it meant compromising ideological purity.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Lenin's policies undeniably revolutionized both the governance and economy of Russia. However, the scale and impact of the economic changes, particularly the introduction and success of the NEP, suggest that the economy experienced a more drastic transformation. While consolidating power and establishing a one-party state under the Bolsheviks were significant political shifts, the economic upheaval and subsequent pragmatic adjustments through the NEP represented a more substantial departure from the pre-revolutionary era and had a more direct impact on the lives of ordinary Russians.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Lenin's Rule: Political Control and Economic Change
For example, during Lenin’s rule, the economy saw more change because there was a complete change in direction in 1921 when the NEP reintroduced capitalism in some sections of society instead of communism. This was only possible because the way Russia was ruled and controlled remained consistent. To ensure he stayed in control Lenin forcibly closed down the Constituent Assembly and ruled by issuing decrees that were passed by the Congress of Soviets. The decrees banned opposition parties and non Bolshevik newspapers and this created a political dictatorship controlled by Lenin.
For example, Lenin’s policies created a communist dictatorship and banned opposition. However, the economic system saw more change once the Civil War was over. War Communism was replaced with the New Economic Policy in 1921 as a way of increasing food production. There had been widespread famine and food shortages during the Civil War so Lenin announced that instead of handing their crops over to the government, peasants could begin to sell any surplus grain for profit. Private trade for profit was also allowed. This was intended to be a temporary measure and the state retained control of heavy industry.