top of page

Explain the impact of migrants in Britain during the First World War.

Level

GCSE

Year Examined

2021

Topic

World War I

👑Complete Model Essay

Explain the impact of migrants in Britain during the First World War.

Explain the impact of migrants in Britain during the First World War

Introduction:
The outbreak of the First World War in 1914 had a profound impact on migration to Britain. Men and women from across the British Empire and beyond arrived in Britain, seeking refuge or opportunity. This influx of migrants from diverse backgrounds, including Ireland, the Caribbean, and parts of Europe, brought about significant social and economic changes. While the war amplified existing social tensions leading to hostility towards some migrant groups, others made vital contributions to the war effort, highlighting the complex impact of migration on British society.

Body Paragraph 1: Hostility and Intolerance
Topic Sentence: The First World War exacerbated pre-existing prejudices, leading to increased hostility towards certain migrant groups, particularly those perceived as "enemy aliens."
The outbreak of war heightened suspicion and fear towards those of enemy nationality. Germans and Austrians living in Britain, many of whom were long-term residents, were classified as "aliens" under the Aliens Restriction Act of 1914. They faced restrictions on their movement, with curfews imposed and travel limited. Their businesses and homes were often targeted, and many faced internment. Anti-German sentiment escalated into violence in some areas. The anti-German riots in South Shields in 1915 exemplify this hostility. Fueled by rumors of German spies and resentment over job competition, mobs attacked German-owned shops and homes. This event highlighted the deep-seated prejudice and fear that gripped parts of British society, demonstrating how wartime anxieties could boil over into violence and social unrest.
Analysis: The wartime experience intensified existing anti-immigrant sentiments, particularly against those perceived as a threat to national security. The government's response, driven by public pressure and wartime anxieties, often served to further marginalize and alienate these communities. The legacy of this distrust would continue to impact relations long after the war ended.

Body Paragraph 2: Contributions to the War Effort
Topic Sentence: Despite facing prejudice, many migrants made significant contributions to the British war effort, serving in various capacities and challenging stereotypes.
Despite the prejudice they often faced, many migrants contributed significantly to the British war effort. Black migrants from the Caribbean, answering Britain's call for support, volunteered for military service, eager to demonstrate their loyalty and patriotism. Walter Tull, a professional footballer of Afro-Caribbean descent, rose through the ranks to become an officer in the British Army, a testament to his courage and resilience in the face of discrimination. Many others served with distinction, challenging racial stereotypes and demonstrating their commitment to Britain's cause. Beyond military service, migrants filled vital roles in factories, shipyards, and on farms, keeping the British economy afloat during the war years.
Analysis:The contributions of migrants to the war effort challenged existing prejudices, highlighting their loyalty and commitment to their adopted country. However, despite their service and sacrifice, the social and political landscape for many migrant groups remained largely unchanged after the war, demonstrating the entrenched nature of racial and social divisions within British society.

Conclusion
The First World War had a complex and multifaceted impact on migrants in Britain. While the war fueled existing prejudices and led to increased hostility towards groups perceived as "enemy aliens," it also witnessed the vital contributions of many migrants to the war effort, challenging stereotypes and demonstrating their commitment to Britain. The experience of migrants during this period, marked by both discrimination and heroism, serves as a reminder of the enduring tensions between nativism and the contributions of immigrant communities, a theme that continues to resonate in contemporary society.

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

Essay Plan: Explain the impact of migrants in Britain during the First World War

Introduction:
- Briefly introduce the topic of migration to Britain during WWI.
- Mention the diverse origins of these migrants and their varied roles.
- Provide a clear thesis statement outlining the main impacts you will discuss (e.g., "While the war amplified existing social tensions leading to hostility towards some migrant groups, others made vital contributions to the war effort, highlighting the complex impact of migration on British society.").

Body Paragraph 1: Hostility and Intolerance
- Topic Sentence: The First World War exacerbated pre-existing prejudices, leading to increased hostility towards certain migrant groups, particularly those perceived as "enemy aliens."
- Example 1: Explain the classification of Germans and Austrians as “aliens.” Detail the restrictions imposed on them, such as curfews, travel limits, and property confiscation.
- Example 2: Discuss the anti-German riots in South Shields and other areas. Explain the motivations behind these attacks and their impact on community relations.
- Analysis: Connect these examples to the broader impact on British society. Did this experience challenge or reinforce existing prejudices? How did the government respond to this hostility?

Body Paragraph 2: Contributions to the War Effort
- Topic Sentence: Despite facing prejudice, many migrants made significant contributions to the British war effort, serving in various capacities and challenging stereotypes.
- Example 1: Focus on the contributions of Black migrants from the Caribbean. Highlight Walter Tull's story as a symbol of their service and the obstacles they overcame.
- Example 2: (Optional - Include if you have more information) Briefly mention other migrant groups and their contributions, such as laborers, nurses, or factory workers.
- Analysis: How did these contributions challenge existing perceptions of migrants? Did their service lead to any social or political changes regarding their status in British society?

Conclusion
- Briefly summarize the two contrasting impacts of migrants during WWI: the rise of hostility and the vital contributions to the war effort.
- Offer a nuanced concluding statement: Acknowledge the complexity of the situation. Perhaps argue that the war exposed and intensified existing social divisions while also highlighting the contributions and resilience of migrant communities.
- Do not introduce new information in the conclusion.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

- One impact of migrants during the First and Second World Wars was the increased hostility to some foreigners that took place in Britain. For example, during the First World War, German and Austrian migrants were classed as ‘aliens’ and were subject to restrictions, and there were protests and sometimes attacks on these people, for example in South Shields. Their impact was to increase intolerance in British society, as they were seen as the enemy. [1 impact] - Some migrant groups played important roles in the British armed forces during the First World War. A good example would be Black migrants from the Caribbean, who served in the British army, such as Walter Tull, the first Black officer to command White soldiers. The impact of migrants like these was to help Britain win the First World War.

bottom of page