Describe two ways in which Parliament challenged the monarchy in the Tudor period, 1485 to 1603.
Level
Year Examined
2022
Topic
Tudor England
👑Complete Model Essay
Describe two ways in which Parliament challenged the monarchy in the Tudor period, 1485 to 1603.
Introduction
The Tudor period (1485-1603) was a time of significant change in England, marked by religious upheaval, foreign wars, and the rise of a powerful monarchy. However, despite the autocratic tendencies of some Tudor monarchs, Parliament was not a passive bystander. It challenged royal authority in various ways, shaping the political landscape of the era.
Challenge 1: Religion
Subheading: Parliamentary Resistance to Religious Change
Point 1: The English Reformation, initiated by Henry VIII, brought about a profound shift in religious authority from the Pope to the Crown. However, Parliament did not always comply with Henry's wishes. For instance, during the dissolution of the monasteries, there was considerable resistance in Parliament, demonstrating an unwillingness to simply rubber-stamp royal policy, even on such a key issue.
Point 2: Furthermore, Parliament played a key role in the religious see-sawing that characterized the Tudor period. After Henry VIII's death, Parliament under Edward VI pushed for further Protestant reforms, while Mary I's reign saw Parliament reinstate Catholicism. This highlights Parliament's capacity to act as a vehicle for the religious sentiments of the nation, even if ultimately reflecting the monarch's faith.
Challenge 2: Succession and Marriage
Subheading: Parliament's Role in National Stability
Point 1: The issue of succession was a constant source of anxiety during the Tudor period, and Parliament often took an active role in attempting to sikre the lineage. Evidence: For example, Henry VIII's multiple marriages and his desire for a male heir led to parliamentary acts of succession that validated his chosen heir while also highlighting the monarch's need for parliamentary approval in such crucial matters.
Point 2: Parliament's concern for stability extended to urging monarchs, particularly Elizabeth I, to marry. This pressure, while stemming from anxieties about a female ruler, underscores Parliament's perceived role in safeguarding the future of the nation, even if it meant intruding on the monarch's personal life.
Challenge 3: Taxation and Financial Control
Subheading: Limiting Monarchial Power Through the Purse Strings
Point 1: One of Parliament's most powerful tools was its control over taxation. Monarchs, especially when engaged in costly wars or ventures, required parliamentary approval for new taxes. Evidence: This gave Parliament leverage to negotiate with the monarch and influence royal policies. For example, Elizabeth I's need for funds to fight Spain led to increased parliamentary scrutiny of her financial decisions.
Point 2: Parliament also used its financial power to hold the monarchy accountable for its spending. This often involved demanding audits and investigations into royal finances, further demonstrating Parliament's growing assertiveness in curtailing any perceived financial mismanagement.
Conclusion
While the Tudor monarchs remain imposing figures in English history, the role of Parliament in challenging their authority should not be underestimated. Whether in matters of religion, succession, or finance, Parliament demonstrated a growing awareness of its own power and its responsibility in shaping the destiny of the nation. This complex and evolving relationship between the Crown and Parliament would continue to shape English politics in the centuries to come, ultimately laying the foundation for the constitutional monarchy that exists today.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Brief overview of the Tudor period and the relationship between the monarchy and Parliament. The Tudor period (1485-1603) witnessed a complex and evolving dynamic between the monarchy and Parliament. While monarchs like Henry VIII and Elizabeth I wielded considerable power, Parliament played a crucial role in shaping legislation, granting taxation, and voicing concerns on matters of national importance.
Challenge 1: Religion
Subheading: Elizabethan Religious Settlements and Parliamentary Opposition
Point 1: Elizabeth I's attempts to establish a middle way in religion through the Elizabethan Religious Settlements faced opposition from Puritan members of Parliament who desired further Protestant reforms. Evidence: Walter Strickland's efforts to introduce stricter Protestant measures exemplify this challenge.
Point 2: Parliament's role in passing the Act of Supremacy and the Act of Uniformity, which established the Church of England, demonstrated their influence on religious matters, even if not always aligned with the monarch's preferences.
Challenge 2: Succession and Marriage
Subheading: Parliamentary Pressure on Elizabeth I
Point 1: Parliament persistently pressured Elizabeth I to marry and secure the Tudor line of succession, highlighting their concern for national stability and their role in ensuring a smooth transition of power. Evidence: William Cecil and other prominent MPs actively sought a suitable husband for Elizabeth.
Point 2: The issue of Mary, Queen of Scots also fueled tensions, with Parliament urging Elizabeth to eliminate the threat posed by her Catholic cousin. Evidence: Parliamentary pressure intensified following plots and rebellions linked to Mary, culminating in their demands for her execution.
Challenge 3: Taxation and Financial Control
Subheading: Limiting Monarchial Power Through the Purse Strings
Point 1: Parliament's power of the purse gave them leverage over the monarchy. Monarchs required parliamentary approval for taxation, especially for expensive endeavors like wars. Evidence: Parliament's refusal to fully finance Wolsey's planned war in France demonstrates this leverage.
Point 2: By controlling finances, Parliament could influence royal policy and limit the monarch's ability to act unilaterally, shaping the balance of power.
Conclusion
Summarize how Parliament challenged the monarchy during the Tudor period. While the Tudor monarchs were powerful, Parliament played a significant role in challenging their authority on key issues like religion, succession, and finances. These challenges demonstrate the evolving relationship between the Crown and Parliament, laying the groundwork for future conflicts in the seventeenth century.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
One way in which Parliament challenged Elizabeth I was over religion[1].
For example, Walter Strickland, an MP, wanted Elizabeth to introduce much stricter control over religion in England [2].
Another way in which Parliament challenged Elizabeth was over the succession [3].
For example, William Cecil and other MPs put pressure on Elizabeth to marry and to secure an heir to the throne [4].
One way Parliament challenged Elizabeth I was over the fate of Mary, Queen of Scots [1].
Following the numerous plots involving Mary, MPs put pressure on Elizabeth to execute her cousin [2].
Parliament challenged Tudor monarchs by refusing to grant taxes [1]
for example when they rejected Wolsey’s request for money to fight a war in France [2].