Why did the railroads have such a big impact on the plains?
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2020
Topic
American History
👑Complete Model Essay
Why did the railroads have such a big impact on the plains?
The Transformative Impact of Railroads on the Great Plains
The arrival of the railroads in the mid-19th century marked a turning point in the history of the Great Plains, ushering in an era of profound and lasting change. This essay will argue that the railroads were the single most impactful factor in the transformation of the Plains, facilitating westward expansion, fueling economic development, and irrevocably altering the social and environmental landscape.
Facilitating Westward Expansion and Settlement
Prior to the railroads, the journey westward was arduous and perilous, deterring all but the most determined pioneers. Railroads dramatically reduced travel time and increased safety, making the Plains a far more accessible and appealing destination. This newfound ease of travel led to a surge in westward migration, with homesteaders enticed by the prospect of cheap land offered by railroad companies eager to populate and develop the regions they traversed. The railroads, therefore, acted as a catalyst for the rapid settlement of the West, fundamentally altering the demographic makeup of the region.
Economic Transformation: Cattle, Trade, and Cow Towns
The railroads were instrumental in establishing the cattle industry as a cornerstone of the Plains economy. By providing a swift and efficient means of transporting cattle to eastern markets, railroads made large-scale ranching profitable. This led to the rise of "cow towns" along rail lines, serving as hubs for trade, entertainment, and the burgeoning cattle industry. The railroads also facilitated the transportation of goods and resources, connecting the Plains to national and international markets and stimulating economic growth.
Conflict and Consequence: The Displacement of Native Americans
While the railroads brought prosperity to many, their impact on Native American populations was undeniably devastating. The railroads facilitated the mass slaughter of buffalo, a vital resource for Plains Indians, both for sustenance and as a cornerstone of their cultural identity. This environmental destruction, coupled with the railroads' role in opening up the Plains to white settlement, led to increased competition for land and resources, culminating in violent clashes between ranchers, settlers, and Native Americans. The railroads, though an engine of economic progress, were also instrumental in the displacement and dispossession of indigenous peoples.
Conclusion: A Legacy of Change and Continuity
The railroads were a force of unprecedented change on the Great Plains. They facilitated westward expansion, spurred economic development, and irreversibly altered the relationship between humans and the environment. However, this era of transformation was also marked by conflict and displacement, highlighting the complex and often contradictory consequences of technological advancement. The legacy of the railroads on the Great Plains is, therefore, one of both progress and loss, shaping the region into the landscape we recognize today.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Essay Outline: The Impact of Railroads on the Plains
Introduction:
- Briefly introduce the railroads and their expansion into the Great Plains during the 19th century.
- State your argument: The railroads had a profound impact on the Plains, transforming the region economically, socially, and environmentally.
Body Paragraph 1: Facilitating Migration and Settlement
- Causation:Railroads provided a faster, safer, and more efficient means of transportation compared to wagon trains.
- Consequence:This led to a massive influx of homesteaders, especially after the Homestead Act of 1862 and railroad land grants.
- Evidence: Mention the surge in population in Plains states during the 1870s.
Body Paragraph 2: Transforming the Economy
- Change:Railroads facilitated the rise of the cattle industry by connecting ranches to eastern markets.
- Consequence: Cow towns emerged along rail lines, boosting trade and urbanization.
- Evidence: Provide examples of prominent cow towns like Abilene and Dodge City.
Body Paragraph 3: Impact on Native Americans
- Conflict:Railroad expansion led to the decimation of buffalo herds, a vital resource for Plains Indians.
- Consequence:This disruption of their traditional way of life resulted in conflict and displacement.
- Evidence: Mention key conflicts like the Red River War (1874-1875).
Body Paragraph 4: Environmental Consequences
- Change:Overgrazing by cattle, fueled by railroad access to markets, led to environmental degradation.
- Continuity:The exploitation of natural resources continued, impacting the delicate ecosystem of the Plains.
Conclusion
- Restate the significant impact of railroads on the Plains, highlighting the multifaceted changes they brought.
- Briefly mention the long-term consequences of these changes on the region and its inhabitants.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Explanations
Explanations are most likely to show understanding of the second order concepts of causation and consequence and change and continuity but reward appropriate understanding of any other second order concept.
Explanations could consider:
⭐Much easier and less dangerous method of travel therefore more people would move west.
⭐1870s flood of homesteaders due to railroad companies selling land cheaply.
⭐Divided land where natives hunted buffalo.
⭐Cattle ranches by the 1870s had spread across the Plains – led to scarcity of water and grass for buffalo.
⭐Helped cattle trade develop (e.g. cow towns).
⭐The impact on the buffalo herds and, therefore, the Indians.
⭐Violent clashes between Indians and Ranchers.
⭐Migrant workers to the Plains.