top of page

07. Write an account of the ways in which the Normans changed monastic life in England.

Level

GCSE

Year Examined

2020

Topic

Norman England, c1066–c1100

👑Complete Model Essay

07. Write an account of the ways in which the Normans changed monastic life in England.

Account of the Ways the Normans Changed Monastic Life in England

Introduction
The Norman Conquest of 1066 CE marked a turning point in English history, ushering in profound changes to all aspects of society, including the Church. William the Conqueror arrived to find an English Church influenced by Anglo-Saxon traditions and facing internal challenges. This essay will argue that the Normans significantly changed monastic life in England by introducing reforms aimed at improving standards and reinforcing Church authority.

Lanfranc's Reforms and the Drive for Reform
Before 1066, the English Church, while spiritually vibrant, displayed laxity in some areas. Anglo-Saxon monasticism, though influenced by the Benedictine Rule, had developed its own customs, and issues like simony (buying Church offices) and pluralism (holding multiple positions) were present. William sought a reformed Church aligned with continental Europe and appointed Lanfranc, a respected scholar and abbot, as Archbishop of Canterbury. Lanfranc tackled corruption head-on, enforcing celibacy among the clergy and curbing simony and pluralism. He emphasized stricter adherence to the Benedictine Rule, promoting piety and discipline within monasteries. Monasteries like Glastonbury and Winchester underwent significant reform under his guidance.

Introduction of New Monastic Orders
The Normans also brought with them the influence of the Cluniac Order, a powerful monastic movement originating in France. Cluniac monasteries were known for their strict adherence to the Benedictine Rule, their emphasis on liturgical prayer, and their direct accountability to the Pope. William and his nobles favored the Cluniacs, establishing priories like Lewes Priory in Sussex. These Cluniac houses served as models of monastic reform, influencing existing English monasteries and contributing to a more standardized and disciplined monastic culture.

Centralization and Standardization
Centralization was a hallmark of Norman rule, and the Church was no exception. The Normans sought to bring the English Church more closely under their control and to standardize religious practices. They promoted a stricter and more uniform application of the Benedictine Rule across English monasteries, replacing local variations with a more unified approach. This move towards standardization aimed to enhance discipline and ensure consistency in monastic life, but it also sometimes generated resistance from monks accustomed to older customs.

Resistance and Continuity
While Norman reforms brought significant changes, they were not always welcomed wholeheartedly. Some monks resisted the new regulations and mourned the loss of local traditions. The imposition of Norman abbots over English monks also sometimes led to tensions and resentment. It’s crucial to remember that change was not absolute. While embracing reform, English monasticism retained elements of its Anglo-Saxon heritage. The Normans' own piety and their respect for monasticism ensured a degree of continuity, even as they sought to reshape it according to their ideals.

Conclusion
The Norman Conquest brought about profound changes to English monastic life. Through Lanfranc's reforms, the introduction of new orders like the Cluniacs, and their drive for centralization, the Normans tackled corruption, raised monastic standards, and brought English monasticism more in line with continental practices. While facing some resistance, these changes ultimately contributed to a more disciplined and standardized Church, enhancing its authority and shaping its role in English society for centuries to come.

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

Account of the Ways the Normans Changed Monastic Life in England

Introduction
- Briefly introduce the Norman Conquest and its impact on English society, including the Church.
- State the essay's argument: The Normans significantly changed monastic life in England by introducing reforms aimed at improving standards and reinforcing Church authority.

Lanfranc's Reforms and the Drive for Reform
- Explain the state of the English Church before the Norman Conquest (e.g., Anglo-Saxon practices, issues of corruption).
- Detail Lanfranc's appointment and his role in implementing reforms (e.g., combating simony, pluralism, and nepotism).
- Discuss the impact of these reforms on monastic life, emphasizing stricter rules, piety, and alignment with Cluniac ideals.
- Provide examples of monastic houses affected by Lanfranc's reforms.

Introduction of New Monastic Orders
- Explain the Cluniac Order and its significance in the context of monastic reform.
- Provide examples of Cluniac houses established in England with Norman patronage (e.g., Lewes Priory).
- Analyze the influence of these new orders on existing English monasteries, including the spread of stricter practices and ideas.

Centralization and Standardization
- Discuss the Norman tendency towards centralization and its impact on the Church.
- Explain how the Normans standardized monastic practices, promoting greater adherence to the Benedictine Rule.
- Analyze the consequences of this standardization, both positive (e.g., increased discipline) and negative (e.g., potential resistance from monks accustomed to older practices).

Resistance and Continuity
- Acknowledge that Norman reforms were not always welcomed and that resistance existed within monastic communities.
- Provide examples of resistance or challenges faced by the Normans in implementing their reforms.
- Briefly discuss elements of continuity between Anglo-Saxon and Norman monasticism, recognizing that the changes were not absolute.

Conclusion
- Summarize the key ways in which the Normans changed monastic life in England (reforms, new orders, centralization).
- Reiterate the argument: These changes reflect the Normans' commitment to religious reform and their desire for a more disciplined and standardized Church.
- Briefly discuss the long-term consequences of these changes on English monasticism and the Church's role in society.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

The Impact of the Normans on Monastic Life in England

The Normans significantly impacted monastic life in England, introducing reforms aimed at improving standards and reinforcing the authority of the Church. Archbishop Lanfranc, appointed to the See of Canterbury in 1070, led a major reform movement, seeking to eradicate practices like pluralism, simony, and nepotism, which had weakened the Church. He instituted stricter rules for monks, emphasizing piety, regular services, and a stricter lifestyle. While some monks resisted these changes, Lanfranc's reforms ultimately led to a more disciplined and austere monastic life, aligning with the ideals of the Cluniac Order.

The Normans also encouraged the introduction of new monastic orders, such as the Cluniacs, who were known for their strict observance of the Benedictine Rule. William de Warenne, for example, persuaded the Cluniacs to establish a priory near his castle at Lewes between 1078 and 1082.

The influence of the Normans led to a more centralized and standardized monastic system, with greater emphasis on religious discipline, obedience, and adherence to the rules of the Benedictine Order. The reforms, though sometimes met with resistance, brought about a significant shift in monastic life, contributing to the greater authority and influence of the Church in England. These changes, driven by the desire for a more organized and devout monastic system, reflect the Normans' commitment to religious reform and their influence on the cultural landscape of England.

bottom of page