Describe one example of the US government's response to the Great Depression.
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2021
Topic
Great Depression
👑Complete Model Essay
Describe one example of the US government's response to the Great Depression.
Introduction
The Great Depression, a period of unprecedented economic hardship that gripped the globe in the 1930s, originated with the Wall Street Crash of 1929 and swiftly permeated the US economy. Overproduction, agricultural struggles, and stock market speculation coalesced to create a perfect storm, resulting in mass unemployment, bank failures, and widespread poverty. Faced with this unprecedented crisis, the US government, under President Herbert Hoover, grappled to formulate an effective response.
Thesis Statement: This essay will argue that while President Hoover's response to the Great Depression, particularly through initiatives like the Reconstruction Finance Corporation and the Federal Farm Board, aimed to stabilize the economy, his approach ultimately proved insufficient to address the crisis's scale and severity.
Body Paragraph 1: The Reconstruction Finance Corporation
Created in 1932, the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) represented a significant step by the Hoover administration towards direct government intervention in the economy. The RFC's primary purpose was to provide financial assistance to struggling banks, railroads, and other large businesses. By offering loans, the government aimed to prevent further collapses and stimulate lending to businesses, thus encouraging economic growth. For example, the RFC provided substantial loans to major institutions like the Central Pacific Railroad and General Motors, hoping to avert their failures and the ripple effects that would follow.
However, the RFC's impact remained limited and failed to generate a robust recovery. Criticized for its "trickle-down" approach, the RFC prioritized aid to large institutions with the expectation that benefits would eventually reach ordinary citizens. This strategy neglected the plight of small businesses and individuals who lacked access to these loans, exacerbating the Depression's effects on the broader population.
Body Paragraph 2: Encouraging Business Stability and the Federal Farm Board
Hoover's response to the Depression was deeply rooted in his philosophy of "rugged individualism." He believed in the inherent strength of the American spirit and advocated for limited government intervention in the free market. Consequently, he initially relied on encouraging businesses to maintain wages and production levels through voluntary cooperation, believing this would prevent further economic decline.
The agricultural sector, already struggling in the 1920s, faced a particularly devastating blow during the Depression. To address this, Hoover established the Federal Farm Board in 1929. The board aimed to stabilize crop prices by purchasing surplus agricultural products and providing loans to farmers' cooperatives. However, the program struggled to keep pace with the scale of overproduction and plummeting prices. The agricultural sector continued to suffer, highlighting the limitations of Hoover's approach that relied heavily on voluntary cooperation and market forces to correct the crisis.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while President Hoover's response to the Great Depression, embodied by initiatives like the RFC and the Federal Farm Board, demonstrated a willingness to expand the federal government's role in economic affairs, it ultimately proved inadequate. His approach, largely shaped by his belief in "rugged individualism" and cautious government intervention, struggled to address the sheer magnitude and severity of the crisis.
The limited success of these programs underscored the need for a more direct and comprehensive approach to combat the Depression's devastating impact. Public dissatisfaction with Hoover's policies grew, setting the stage for the election of Franklin Delano Roosevelt and his New Deal programs, which advocated for a more active role for the government in economic recovery and social welfare.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Context: Briefly outline the Great Depression's causes and impact, setting the stage for the US government's response.
Thesis Statement: This essay will argue that while President Hoover's response to the Great Depression, particularly through initiatives like the Reconstruction Finance Corporation and the Federal Farm Board, aimed to stabilize the economy, his approach ultimately proved insufficient to address the crisis's scale and severity.
Body Paragraph 1: The Reconstruction Finance Corporation
Explain the RFC: Detail its purpose, structure, and how it aimed to help banks and businesses.
Provide examples: Mention specific industries or companies that received loans.
Analyze effectiveness: Discuss the RFC's limited success – it helped some institutions survive but didn't stimulate widespread economic recovery. Highlight its focus on "trickle-down" economics and its limitations in reaching individuals and small businesses directly.
Body Paragraph 2: Encouraging Business Stability and the Federal Farm Board
Explain Hoover's philosophy: Describe his belief in "rugged individualism" and limited government intervention. Explain his attempts to encourage businesses to maintain wages and production to avoid further economic downturn.
Focus on the Federal Farm Board: Explain its role in aiding farmers, particularly in dealing with agricultural surpluses and price drops.
Analyze effectiveness: Discuss the limited impact of voluntary measures and the struggles farmers faced despite government assistance. The agricultural sector continued to suffer, highlighting the shortcomings of Hoover's approach.
Body Paragraph 3: (Optional - Depending on Essay Length and Focus)
This paragraph could explore:
Other aspects of Hoover's response (e.g., public works projects).
The growing criticism of Hoover's policies and the public's demand for more direct government action.
How Hoover's response set the stage for FDR's New Deal programs.
Conclusion
Summarize: Briefly restate the main arguments – the RFC and the Federal Farm Board were attempts to address the Depression but proved inadequate.
Broader significance: Explain that Hoover's response, while well-intentioned, demonstrated the limitations of his economic philosophy in the face of a crisis of this magnitude. His policies ultimately failed to stem the Depression's tide, leading to a shift in public opinion and paving the way for a new approach under President Roosevelt.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Government Response to the Great Depression
The government responded to the Great Depression by setting up organisations to help the country deal with the economic downturn [1]. Hoover created the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, which loaned money to banks and businesses [2].
Hoover responded to the Great Depression by encouraging businesses to stabilise prices [1]. For example, he gave government-funded loans to farm cooperatives through the Federal Farm Board to help keep farm prices up and deal with surpluses [2].