top of page

How significant have Gaza and the West Bank been as factors in the Arab-Israeli conflict?

Level

O LEVEL

Year Examined

2019

Topic

ISRAELIS AND PALESTINIANS SINCE 1945

👑Complete Model Essay

How significant have Gaza and the West Bank been as factors in the Arab-Israeli conflict?

The Significance of Gaza and the West Bank in the Arab-Israeli Conflict

The Gaza Strip and the West Bank are two territories at the heart of the Arab-Israeli conflict. While other factors undoubtedly play a role, the significance of these territories cannot be understated. This essay will argue that Gaza and the West Bank are highly significant factors in the conflict due to their disputed status, the impact of Israeli policies, and their role in fueling Palestinian nationalism and resistance.

Disputed Territory and Israeli Expansion

The very existence of Israel, founded in 1948, displaced hundreds of thousands of Palestinians. The 1967 Six-Day War led to Israel's capture of the West Bank (from Jordan) and Gaza (from Egypt), further displacing Palestinians and exacerbating tensions. Israel's subsequent control over these territories, including the expansion of settlements deemed illegal under international law, has been a major point of contention. The presence of Israeli settlements, often viewed by Palestinians as land grabs, fuels resentment and undermines trust. This is further exemplified by the construction of the separation barrier, which Palestinians argue restricts their movement and isolates them within their own land.

Palestinian Nationalism and Resistance

Gaza and the West Bank are also significant as focal points for Palestinian nationalism and resistance. The presence of Israeli control has fostered a sense of Palestinian identity rooted in the struggle for self-determination. This is evident in the rise of groups like Hamas in Gaza, which gained support partly due to their resistance against Israeli occupation. The First Intifada (1987-1993), characterized by Palestinian uprisings originating in the West Bank and Gaza, exemplifies the role of these territories in channeling Palestinian frustration and desires for independence.

Terrorism and the Cycle of Violence

Sadly, Gaza, particularly under Hamas rule, has become synonymous with rocket attacks against Israel. Israel, in turn, has responded with significant military force. This cycle of violence, with its tragic cost in civilian lives on both sides, reinforces the perception of the territories as battlegrounds and hampers peace efforts. The Oslo Accords of the 1990s, which aimed to establish a framework for Palestinian self-governance in the West Bank and Gaza, ultimately failed to deliver lasting peace. This failure can be partly attributed to continued settlement expansion and the lack of trust between the two sides, issues deeply intertwined with the status of these territories.

Conclusion

While factors like the actions of the PLO, the role of neighboring Arab states, and international diplomacy certainly contribute to the complexity of the Arab-Israeli conflict, the significance of Gaza and the West Bank remains undeniable. Their disputed status, the impact of Israeli policies, and their role in shaping Palestinian resistance demonstrate their centrality to the conflict. Until a just and lasting solution is found for the future of Gaza and the West Bank, the root causes of the conflict will persist.

**Sources:**

Fawaz A. Gerges, _The Rise and Fall of the Arab World_ (Saqi Books, 2018)
Rashid Khalidi, _The Iron Cage: The Story of the Palestinian Struggle for Statehood_ (Beacon Press, 2007)

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

Essay Outline: The Significance of Gaza and the West Bank in the Arab-Israeli Conflict

I. Introduction:

⭐Briefly introduce the Arab-Israeli conflict and its complexities.
⭐State the central question: How significant have Gaza and the West Bank been as factors in this conflict?
⭐Briefly outline the arguments for and against their significance.

II. Arguments for the Significance of Gaza and the West Bank:

⭐Disputed Territory:Explain how the contested nature of Gaza and the West Bank has fueled the conflict from its inception.
⭐Israeli Settlement and Palestinian Displacement:Discuss the impact of Israeli settlements on Palestinian livelihoods and national identity.
⭐Humanitarian Crisis and International Condemnation: Highlight the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza and its impact on global perceptions of the conflict.
⭐Rise of Hamas and the Cycle of Violence:Analyze the emergence of Hamas in Gaza and its role in perpetuating the cycle of violence.

III. Arguments Against the Sole Significance of Gaza and the West Bank:

⭐Broader Regional Dynamics:Emphasize that the conflict encompasses a wider struggle over land, resources, and recognition across the entire region.
⭐Role of External Actors:Analyze the involvement of international actors like the UN, US, and neighboring Arab states.
⭐Ideological and Historical Roots:Explore the historical grievances and ideological differences that underpin the conflict beyond specific territorial disputes.
⭐PLO and Palestinian Resistance Beyond Gaza and the West Bank: Acknowledge the role of the PLO and Palestinian resistance movements operating outside these territories.

IV. Comparative Analysis and Nuance:

⭐Acknowledge the interconnectedness of all factors involved in the conflict.
⭐Avoid presenting a simplistic "yes" or "no" answer to the essay question.
⭐Instead, emphasize the complex interplay between local dynamics in Gaza and the West Bank and broader regional and international factors.

V. Conclusion:

⭐Briefly summarize the main arguments presented in the essay.
⭐Offer a nuanced conclusion about the significance of Gaza and the West Bank in the Arab-Israeli conflict, acknowledging their undeniable role while situating it within the broader context.
⭐End with a thought-provoking statement about the future of the conflict and the potential for peace.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

How significant have Gaza and the West Bank been as factors in the Arab-Israeli conflict? Explain your answer.

Yes: The disputed area between Israel and neighbouring states; attempts at Israeli expansion after the 1967 War; areas of terrorist activity; the West Bank was annexed by Israel in the Six-Day War – continued settlement in both the West Bank and Gaza, leading to Palestinian nationalism and terrorism – the growth of Hamas, etc.

No: More significant – actions of the PLO; Israeli aggression; raids into Israel from neighbouring Arab states – Jordan, Syria; the role of the UN and US in diplomacy and peacekeeping, etc.

bottom of page