How far do you agree that 'Popular policies were the main reason the Communist Party was able to establish control over China in the 1950s.'?
Level
Year Examined
2022
Topic
Chinese Communist Revolution
👑Complete Model Essay
How far do you agree that 'Popular policies were the main reason the Communist Party was able to establish control over China in the 1950s.'?
Introduction
The Chinese Communist Party (CCP)'s rise to power in 1949 marked a turning point in Chinese history. While some argue that their success hinged solely on popular policies that resonated with the masses, this view overlooks the significant role played by violence and repression. This essay will argue that although popular policies like land redistribution and women's rights were instrumental in garnering support for the CCP, it was the strategic use of violence and fear, through campaigns like the Three- and Five-Antis and the Anti-Rightist Movement, that truly solidified their control over China in the 1950s.
Main Paragraphs
Argument 1: Popular Policies were Important
Land Reform:
⭐The CCP's land reform policy, implemented soon after their victory, was a masterstroke in gaining peasant support. Through "struggle sessions," landlords, often vilified as class enemies, were publicly humiliated and their land confiscated. This land was then redistributed among the peasantry.
⭐For a peasantry long subjected to exploitation and poverty under the previous regime, land ownership was a dream come true. This policy resonated deeply, fostering immense goodwill towards the CCP and cementing their image as liberators.
⭐This newfound support translated into increased legitimacy and authority for the CCP. Peasants, now invested in the new regime's success, became a powerful force in consolidating Communist control in the countryside.
Policies towards Women:
⭐Recognizing the need to mobilize women, who constituted nearly half the population, the CCP introduced progressive policies concerning their rights. The 1950 Marriage Law outlawed arranged marriages and granted women equal rights in divorce and inheritance, while women were also granted suffrage.
⭐These policies were revolutionary for Chinese women, granting them unprecedented freedoms and challenging deeply ingrained patriarchal norms. This resonated particularly with women who had long suffered under oppressive traditional practices.
⭐By empowering women, the CCP secured their allegiance, further broadening their base of support and strengthening their grip on power. This also facilitated increased participation of women in the workforce, bolstering the CCP's socialist agenda.
Argument 2: Violence and Repression Were Also Important
Mass Campaigns:
⭐While popular policies won over large segments of society, the CCP simultaneously employed violence and terror to eliminate opposition. The Three- and Five-Antis Campaigns, launched in the early 1950s, targeted capitalists and remnants of the former regime.
⭐These campaigns utilized public denunciations, forced confessions, and arbitrary imprisonment, often culminating in executions or sentences to brutal labor camps known as laogai. This created an atmosphere of pervasive fear and silenced any potential dissent.
⭐Through these brutal tactics, the CCP effectively eradicated opposition from influential groups like businessmen and intellectuals, consolidating their control over urban centers and neutralizing potential threats to their authority.
Anti-Rightist Campaign:
⭐As Mao consolidated his power, he grew increasingly intolerant of criticism, even from within the CCP itself. Launched in 1957, the Anti-Rightist Campaign targeted intellectuals and party members who dared to express dissent or propose alternative visions for China's future.
⭐Those accused of "rightist" tendencies faced public humiliation, dismissal from their positions, and even imprisonment. This campaign effectively silenced any internal opposition, ensuring absolute obedience to Mao and his ideology.
⭐By ruthlessly suppressing dissent within its own ranks and among intellectuals, the CCP eliminated potential challenges to their leadership, creating a climate where open criticism was unthinkable and obedience paramount.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the CCP's popular policies, particularly land reform and women's rights, played a significant role in garnering support and solidifying their rule in the 1950s, it was the simultaneous and strategic implementation of violence and repression that proved crucial in their complete control over China. While popular policies won hearts and minds, it was ultimately fear and the brutal crushing of opposition, through campaigns like the Three- and Five-Antis and the Anti-Rightist Movement, that allowed the CCP to establish an unchallenged grip on power, shaping the course of Chinese history for decades to come.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Briefly introduce the topic of the essay. State your line of argument – that popular policies were important in helping the Communists establish control, but that other factors were also important.
Main Paragraphs
Argument 1: Popular Policies were Important
Land Reform:
⭐Explain how land reform worked, including details like struggle sessions.
⭐Explain why this was popular with the peasantry (majority of the population).
⭐Link this popularity to increased support for the Communists.
Policies towards Women:
⭐Give specific examples of policies like the Marriage Law and gaining the vote.
⭐Explain why this was popular with women.
⭐Link this popularity to increased support and control for the Communists.
Argument 2: Violence and Repression Were Also Important
Mass Campaigns:
⭐Describe the campaigns of the early 1950s (Three- and Five-Antis) and who they targeted (middle classes).
⭐Explain the methods used (executions, laogai) and the impact of fear.
⭐Link this to reducing opposition and strengthening Communist control.
Anti-Rightist Campaign:
⭐Describe the targets of this campaign (intellectuals critical of Mao).
⭐Explain the methods used (humiliation, imprisonment, pressure) and their impact.
⭐Link this to removing opposition and strengthening Communist control.
Conclusion
Reiterate your line of argument: acknowledge the importance of popular policies, but emphasize that violence and repression were also significant in establishing Communist control. You could argue that while popular policies won over large sections of society, violence was used to silence and eliminate opposition, making it a crucial, if brutal, tool in consolidating power.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
On one hand I agree that the Communists established control because of popular policies.
Land reform in the early 1950s was popular because it allowed peasants to take revenge for their mistreatment by landlords at brutal struggle sessions, and redistributed land from the landlords to the peasants. As peasants made up the majority of China’s population at the time, land reform was important in increasing support for the Communists. Many women in China also supported the Communist Party because their policies towards women gave them greater equality and opportunity, such as the 1950 Marriage Law which gave them equal rights to men and in 1953 women also gained equal voting rights. This gave the Party support and therefore control.
On the other hand, the Communists also used violence to establish control, so popular policies were not the only reason.
The ‘mass campaigns’ of the early 1950s, like the Three- and Five-Antis, targeted people like the middle classes who were suspected of disloyalty to Mao. These people faced execution or being sent to the laogai prison camps. Fear of this treatment reduced opposition to the Communists. Later in the decade the Anti-Rightist campaign targeted intellectuals who had spoken out against Mao. They were forced to take part in humiliating self-criticisms and many were imprisoned or even committed suicide under all the pressure. This removed people who had declared opposition to Communism and so strengthened Communist control through violence.
On balance, I think the Communists tried to establish control through policies that were popular with large groups in Chinese society, like peasants and women.
They only used violence against smaller groups who were opposed to them such as the wealthy and landlords, so popular policies were more important.