top of page

How far did the Locarno Treaties improve European international relations in the 1920s?

Level

AS Level

Year Examined

2023

Topic

The League of Nations and international relations in the 1930s

👑Complete Model Essay

How far did the Locarno Treaties improve European international relations in the 1920s?

How Far Did the Locarno Treaties Improve European International Relations in the 1920s?
The Locarno Treaties, signed in 1925, were a series of agreements between the major European powers that aimed to secure peace and stability after the devastation of World War I. While the treaties fostered a period of optimism and cooperation, often referred to as the "Spirit of Locarno," their impact on European international relations was ultimately limited. This essay will argue that while the Locarno Treaties brought about some improvements in the short term, they failed to address underlying tensions and ultimately proved insufficient in preventing the outbreak of World War II.

Improvements in International Relations
The Locarno Treaties brought about several notable improvements in European international relations. Firstly, the main treaty formally recognized Germany's western borders as established by the Treaty of Versailles. This recognition was significant as it put to rest, at least temporarily, the territorial disputes that had plagued Europe since the end of the war. By accepting these borders, Germany demonstrated a willingness to abide by the terms of the Treaty of Versailles, which in turn, reduced tensions with France and Belgium.

Secondly, the treaties included a mutual non-aggression pact between Germany, France, and Belgium. This pact, guaranteed by Great Britain and Italy, committed these countries to resolving any future disputes peacefully. The fact that Britain and Italy agreed to act as guarantors added weight to the agreement and provided a sense of security to the signatories. This commitment to peaceful conflict resolution marked a significant departure from the pre-war era, which had been characterized by militarism and alliances that often escalated disputes.

Finally, the signing of the Locarno Treaties paved the way for Germany's admission to the League of Nations in 1926. This was a significant development, as it signaled Germany's reintegration into the international community after years of isolation following World War I. Germany's membership in the League of Nations was seen by many as a sign of reconciliation and a step towards lasting peace in Europe.

The "Spirit of Locarno" fostered a period of international cooperation and goodwill, exemplified by the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to German Foreign Minister Gustav Stresemann and his French counterpart, Aristide Briand, in 1926. The signing of the Kellogg-Briand Pact in 1928, which outlawed war as an instrument of national policy, further demonstrated the optimistic mood of the time. However, this apparent success was built on shaky foundations.

Underlying Tensions and Limitations
Despite the positive developments associated with the Locarno Treaties, they failed to address several underlying tensions and limitations that would ultimately contribute to their undoing. One major flaw was the treaties' failure to address Germany's eastern borders. While Germany's western borders were guaranteed, no such guarantees were extended to its eastern borders with Poland and Czechoslovakia. This omission fueled resentment in Germany, where many felt that the Treaty of Versailles had treated them unfairly by awarding territory to Poland that they believed rightfully belonged to Germany. This resentment would later be exploited by the Nazi Party, who used the issue of German territory in the east to gain popular support.

Furthermore, the guarantees provided by the Locarno Treaties were not as strong as they appeared. The treaties lacked clear mechanisms for enforcement, and it remained unclear how far Britain and Italy were willing to go to uphold their guarantees in the event of German aggression. This ambiguity meant that the deterrent effect of the treaties was limited. As the economic depression took hold in the late 1920s and early 1930s, the commitment of the guarantor powers to upholding the Locarno agreements weakened. The rise of fascism in Italy under Benito Mussolini also cast doubt on the country's commitment to the principles of collective security enshrined in the League of Nations and the Locarno Treaties.

Moreover, the Locarno Treaties did little to address the fundamental economic imbalances that plagued Europe in the 1920s. The Treaty of Versailles had imposed heavy reparations payments on Germany, crippling its economy and breeding resentment among the German population. The economic depression exacerbated these issues, leading to political instability and the rise of extremist movements across Europe. As economic conditions worsened, countries became increasingly focused on their own internal problems and less willing to cooperate internationally. This inward turn undermined the fragile consensus that had been built at Locarno.

Conclusion
While the Locarno Treaties did improve European international relations in the short term by fostering a spirit of cooperation and temporarily easing tensions, they ultimately failed to prevent the outbreak of World War II. The treaties' failure to address Germany's eastern borders, the weakness of their guarantees, and their inability to solve Europe's underlying economic problems ultimately undermined their effectiveness. The "Spirit of Locarno" proved to be fleeting, and the outbreak of World War II just over a decade later demonstrated the fragility of the peace that had been achieved.

**Bibliography**

⭐Keynes, John Maynard. *The Economic Consequences of the Peace*. Harcourt, Brace and Howe, 1920.
⭐Mazower, Mark. *Governing the World: The History of an Idea*. Penguin Books, 2012.
⭐Trachtenberg, Marc. *Reparation in World Politics: France and European Economic Diplomacy, 1916-1923*. Columbia University Press, 1980.

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

Introduction
The Locarno Treaties, signed in 1925, were a significant attempt to improve European international relations after the devastation of World War I. This essay will analyze the extent to which the Locarno Treaties successfully improved relations, considering both the positive developments and the underlying tensions that remained.

Improved International Relations
Formal Recognition of German Borders
The main treaty between Germany, France, Belgium, Great Britain, and Italy formally recognized Germany's revised western borders established by the Treaty of Versailles, which had been a major source of resentment for Germany.

Non-Aggression Pacts and Guarantees
Germany, France, and Belgium undertook not to attack each other, with Britain and Italy acting as guarantors. This agreement provided a sense of security and stability in Western Europe.

Arbitration and the League of Nations
Germany agreed to sign arbitration conventions with France and Belgium and arbitration treaties with Poland and Czechoslovakia. This commitment to peaceful resolution of disputes helped to create a more cooperative atmosphere.

The "Spirit of Locarno"
The Locarno Treaties fostered a spirit of international cooperation, symbolized by the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to Stresemann and Briand. Germany's entry into the League of Nations as a permanent member of the Council further strengthened this spirit.


Failures and Underlying Tensions
Continuing Franco-German Tensions
Despite the agreements, underlying tensions between Germany and France remained. These tensions re-emerged following the death of Stresemann and the economic collapse of 1929. The economic difficulties of the Weimar Republic further fueled German dissatisfaction.

Eastern European Exclusion
The Locarno Treaties did not provide the same guarantees of security to eastern European states, particularly Poland. This led to resentment and a deterioration in Franco-Polish relations.

Ambiguous Guarantees
The guarantees attached to the Treaty were not absolute, as they did not necessarily commit the guarantor nations to military intervention. This ambiguity left room for interpretation and potential for conflict.

Conclusion
The Locarno Treaties had a significant impact on European international relations in the 1920s, fostering a period of cooperation and stability. However, the treaties did not fully address underlying tensions, especially between Germany and France. Ultimately, the Locarno Treaties achieved only a temporary improvement in relations, and the seeds of future conflict were still present.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

How far did the Locarno Treaties improve European international relations in the 1920s?
Discussion of improved international relations may consider how the main treaty between Germany, France, Belgium, Great Britain, and Italy formally recognised Germany’s revised western borders established by the Treaty of Versailles. Also, Germany, France and Belgium undertook not to attack each other with Britain and Italy acting as guarantors. In the event of aggression by any of the first three states against another, all other parties were to assist the country under attack. Germany also agreed to sign arbitration conventions with France and Belgium and arbitration treaties with Poland and Czechoslovakia, undertaking to refer future disputes to an arbitration tribunal or to the Permanent Court of International Justice. France signed further treaties with Poland and Czechoslovakia, pledging mutual assistance in the event of conflict with Germany. These essentially reaffirmed existing treaties of alliance concluded by France with Poland on 19 February 1921 and with Czechoslovakia on 25 January 1924. This agreement created the so called ‘Spirit of Locarno’ a spell of international co-operation and Germany was able to join the League of Nations as a permanent member of the Council. Stresemann and Briand were awarded the Noble Peace Prize and in 1928 the Kellogg-Briand Pact was signed.
Discussion of the failure to resolve issue may include exploration of the underlying tension between Germany and France remained and re-emerged following the death of Stresemann and the economic collapse in 1929. There was still dissatisfaction in Germany which was masked by the success of the Weimar Republic in the late 1920s but re-emerged once economic difficulties returned. Eastern European states were not given the same guarantee against future aggression as the western states. Poles in particular were furious with the outcome as they felt their need for security against future German aggression had been ignored in the Treaty. This led to a deterioration in Franco-Polish relations. The guarantees attached to the Treaty did not necessarily commit the guarantor nations to military intervention.
Accept any other valid responses.

bottom of page