How far do you agree that advances in public health since 1900 have mainly been because of actions to improve housing?
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2021
Topic
Public Health
👑Complete Model Essay
How far do you agree that advances in public health since 1900 have mainly been because of actions to improve housing?
Introduction
While improvements in housing have undoubtedly contributed to the betterment of public health since 1900, to claim they are the main reason for such advances would be a misjudgement. This essay will argue that medical breakthroughs, alongside impactful public health campaigns, have played an equally, if not more, significant role in enhancing the well-being of the population.
Arguments Supporting Housing's Impact
Undeniably, improvements in housing have had a positive impact on public health. The overcrowding and unsanitary conditions that were rife at the turn of the 20th century, directly contributing to the spread of diseases like cholera and typhoid, were gradually tackled through a series of housing acts.
⭐The 1909 Housing Act, for instance, banned the construction of back-to-back housing, a notorious breeding ground for disease due to poor ventilation and sanitation.
⭐The 1919 Housing Act further addressed the issue by promoting the building of council houses, introducing minimum standards for space, ventilation, water supply and drainage. This led to a significant improvement in living conditions for many working-class families, directly impacting their health and well-being.
⭐The 1930 Housing Act and subsequent slum clearances, transferring properties to local councils for demolition and rebuilding, further reduced the prevalence of squalid living conditions, although they sometimes resulted in displacement and social disruption.
⭐Post-World War II, large-scale council house building programmes contributed to a rise in living standards, further benefiting public health.
Counter-Arguments: Beyond Housing
However, attributing the significant leap in public health solely to housing improvements would be a simplification, overlooking the colossal impact of medical advancements.
⭐The development and widespread use of vaccines for diseases like measles, polio and rubella have been instrumental in drastically reducing their incidence and mortality rates. Diseases that once ravaged communities and claimed countless lives, particularly among children, are now largely preventable thanks to vaccination programmes.
⭐The discovery and use of antibiotics have revolutionised healthcare. Bacterial infections, once a leading cause of death, can now be treated effectively, saving countless lives and preventing long-term health complications.
In addition to these medical breakthroughs, public health campaigns have played a crucial role in fostering healthier lifestyles and preventing illness.
⭐Campaigns promoting hygiene practices, such as handwashing, food safety and proper waste disposal, have significantly contributed to reducing the spread of infectious diseases.
⭐Public awareness campaigns targeting lifestyle choices, such as smoking cessation, healthier diets and regular exercise, have also been instrumental in decreasing the prevalence of chronic diseases like heart disease and some cancers.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while improvements in housing have undoubtedly played a significant role in enhancing public health since 1900, it is crucial to acknowledge the equally significant contributions of other factors. Medical advancements, such as vaccinations and antibiotics, have been revolutionary in combating and preventing diseases. Simultaneously, public health campaigns have effectively promoted healthier lifestyles and disease prevention. It is the combined impact of all these factors, working in tandem, that has resulted in the substantial improvement in public health witnessed since the beginning of the 20th century.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Briefly state your stance on the question: While improvements in housing have significantly benefited public health since 1900, focusing solely on housing overlooks other crucial factors. This essay will argue that advancements in medicine and public awareness campaigns have been equally, if not more, impactful in enhancing public health.
Arguments Supporting Housing's Impact
Acknowledge the significant role of housing improvements:
⭐1909 Housing Act: Explain how banning back-to-back housing reduced overcrowding and its associated health risks (spread of diseases, respiratory problems).
⭐1919 Housing Act: Discuss the introduction of council housing and its impact on setting minimum standards for space, water supply, and drainage. Link these improvements to reduced disease incidence and improved living conditions.
⭐1930 Housing Act & Slum Clearances: Explain the act's role in transferring slum properties to councils and the subsequent efforts to clear and rebuild. Highlight the positive impacts on public health but also mention potential downsides (displacement, social disruption).
⭐Post-War Council Building: Briefly explain the efforts to address housing shortages after WWII and their contribution to improved living standards.
Counter-Arguments: Beyond Housing
Transition to factors beyond housing that have been equally or more important:
⭐Medical Advancements:
⭐Vaccinations: Discuss the development and widespread use of vaccines for diseases like measles, polio, and rubella, leading to significant declines in their incidence and mortality rates.
⭐Antibiotics: Explain the discovery and use of antibiotics in treating bacterial infections, revolutionizing healthcare and saving countless lives.
⭐Public Health Campaigns:
⭐Hygiene Education: Discuss the role of public awareness campaigns in promoting hygiene practices like handwashing, food safety, and waste disposal, leading to a reduction in infectious diseases.
⭐Lifestyle Campaigns: Mention campaigns targeting smoking, diet, and exercise and their impact on reducing chronic diseases like heart disease and some cancers.
Conclusion
Reiterate your stance: While improvements in housing significantly contributed to public health advancements since 1900, attributing the progress solely to housing would be an oversimplification. Medical breakthroughs like vaccinations and antibiotics, coupled with successful public health campaigns, have played an equally crucial role, if not more so, in creating a healthier society. It's the combined effect of these factors, intertwined and interdependent, that has led to the most significant strides in public health.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Public Health and Housing Improvements
Answers may be awarded some marks at Level 1 if they demonstrate any knowledge of public health. It is possible to reach the highest marks either by agreeing or disagreeing or anywhere between, providing the response matches the level description. BUT, to achieve the two highest levels, answers must consider both sides of the argument before reaching a conclusion. Answers are most likely to show understanding of the second order concepts of similarity and difference and cause and consequence, but reward appropriate understanding of any other second order concept.
Grounds for Agreeing
1909 banning back-to-back building led to an improvement in privately owned housing.
Housing Act of 1919 - council housing/ set standards for space/water supply/drainage etc.
1930 Housing Act forced landlords to sell houses in slums to councils.
Slum clearances.
Streets in the air.
Council building after the war and impact.