‘The creation of the state of Israel was the most important turning point in the development of the Palestinian issue in the period from 1908 to 2011.’ How far do you agree?
Level
A Level
Year Examined
2022
Topic
The Middle East 1908-2011: Ottomans to Arab Spring
👑Complete Model Essay
‘The creation of the state of Israel was the most important turning point in the development of the Palestinian issue in the period from 1908 to 2011.’ How far do you agree?
The Creation of the State of Israel: A Turning Point in the Palestinian Issue?
The creation of the state of Israel in 1948 was undoubtedly a pivotal moment in the history of the Palestinian issue. While the roots of the conflict can be traced back to earlier periods, the establishment of Israel undeniably marked a decisive turning point, shaping the political landscape and the lives of Palestinians for generations. This essay argues that the creation of Israel was indeed the most important turning point in the development of the Palestinian issue, with significant consequences that continue to reverberate today.
The Definitive Shift: Rejection and Displacement
The 1947 UN Partition Plan proposed dividing Palestine into two states, one Jewish and one Arab. The Palestinian leadership rejected this plan, which they saw as inherently unfair and a betrayal of their aspirations for an independent state. The creation of Israel, on land claimed by Palestinians, led to the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians, an event known as the "Nakba" (the catastrophe), forever altering the demographic landscape of the region. This displacement fueled resentment and anger, creating a deep sense of injustice and loss among Palestinians.
The terms of the partition plan were themselves deeply problematic for Palestinians. While the proposed Jewish state was to be larger than the Arab state, the Jewish state was also granted control over Jerusalem, a city of immense religious and cultural significance for both Muslims and Christians. This decision further solidified the perception that the international community had unfairly favored the Zionist movement. The inclusion of cities with large Arab populations within the borders of the Jewish state, such as Jaffa and Haifa, further solidified this perception and fueled Palestinian grievances.
The violence that erupted following the UN declaration and the subsequent war further exacerbated the situation. Massacres of Palestinian civilians by Zionist militias further stoked the flames of animosity and contributed to a deep sense of mistrust between Palestinians and Israelis. This cycle of violence became a defining feature of the conflict, with each act of violence serving to further entrench the opposing positions.
A Turning Point or a Continual Evolution?
While the creation of Israel is widely recognized as a significant turning point, it is crucial to acknowledge the contributions of earlier events that shaped the Palestinian issue. The Zionist Congress decisions of 1905, advocating for Jewish immigration and land purchase in Palestine, laid the groundwork for the conflict. The Balfour Declaration of 1917, expressing support for a Jewish national home in Palestine, further escalated the tensions between Jewish and Arab aspirations. However, while these developments established the historical context for the conflict, it was the establishment of Israel that crystallized the Palestinian issue, creating a new reality with insurmountable consequences.
The subsequent decades saw a series of wars, the emergence of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), and the rise of Palestinian nationalism. The First Intifada (1987-1993) and the Second Intifada (2000-2005) further highlighted the Palestinian struggle for self-determination and challenged the status quo. The Palestinian Authority, established in 1994, represented a significant shift in the Palestinian movement, seeking a negotiated solution through peaceful means.
Conclusion: The Legacy of 1948
The creation of Israel remains a defining event in the Palestinian issue, shaping the lives of Palestinians and Israelis to this day. While the conflict had earlier roots, the establishment of Israel marked a turning point, leading to the displacement of Palestinians, the emergence of a distinct Palestinian national identity, and the perpetuation of violence. The unresolved issues of refugee return, Jerusalem, and land ownership continue to be major obstacles to peace. While other developments, such as the Balfour Declaration and the Palestinian Authority, have contributed to the evolving narrative of the conflict, the creation of Israel stands as the central event that irrevocably altered the course of the Palestinian issue.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
The Creation of the State of Israel: A Turning Point in the Palestinian Issue?
The question of whether the creation of the state of Israel in 1948 was the most important turning point in the development of the Palestinian issue from 1908 to 2011 is a complex and multifaceted one. While there are strong arguments to be made on both sides, this essay will argue that, while significant, the creation of Israel was not the most important turning point in the ongoing conflict.
Arguments Supporting the Creation of Israel as a Turning Point
The Rejection of Partition: A key argument for the creation of Israel as a turning point is the immediate rejection of the 1947 UN Partition Plan by Palestinian Arabs. This rejection led to the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, resulting in the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians and the establishment of Israel on a larger area than originally proposed. This event can be seen as the catalyst for the ongoing conflict, setting the stage for future wars, ongoing displacement, and the emergence of the Palestinian refugee crisis.
The Issue of Jerusalem: The status of Jerusalem, considered holy by both Jews and Muslims, has been a major point of contention throughout the conflict. The 1948 war led to Jerusalem being divided, with Israel controlling the western part and Jordan controlling the eastern part. This division, exacerbated by Israel’s annexation of East Jerusalem in 1967, has fueled tensions and contributed to the ongoing deadlock in peace negotiations.
The Impact of the 1948 War: The war itself, which resulted in the displacement of Palestinians, created a deep sense of grievance and resentment. The Palestinian narrative of dispossession and loss has been a driving force in the subsequent struggle for self-determination. The massacres that followed the UN declaration in 1948, such as the Deir Yassin massacre, further fueled Palestinian anger and contributed to the ongoing tension.
The Seeds of Future Conflict: The creation of Israel and the subsequent war can be seen as the beginning of a new era in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. The unresolved issues of land, refugees, and Jerusalem have become major obstacles to peace, shaping future political negotiations and exacerbating the violence that has defined the conflict.
Arguments Against the Creation of Israel as the Most Important Turning Point
Prior Zionist Congress Decisions: It can be argued that decisions made at the Zionist Congress in 1905, which advocated for the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine, were more significant in shaping the conflict. These decisions laid the groundwork for the later Zionist movement and influenced the development of the British Mandate for Palestine, setting the stage for the conflict.
The Balfour Declaration (1917): The Balfour Declaration, which promised a Jewish homeland in Palestine, can be seen as a crucial turning point. It provided legitimacy to the Zionist movement and fueled tensions with the Arab population, leading to increased Jewish immigration and land purchases. This set the stage for future conflict and ultimately contributed to the creation of Israel.
The Status of Palestine (1920s-1940s): The period between World War I and the UN Partition Plan witnessed increasing tensions and violence. The British Mandate for Palestine, characterized by ambiguous promises and conflicting interests, created a volatile environment. The rapid growth of the Jewish population and the restricted rights of Palestinian Arabs fueled resentment and contributed to the eventual outbreak of war.
The Palestinian Refugee Crisis: While the creation of Israel was a significant factor in the Palestinian refugee crisis, it is important to note that the displacement of Palestinians began before 1948. Palestinian refugees began fleeing to neighboring countries during the 1920s and 1930s as a result of economic hardship and political instability. This ongoing process was exacerbated by the 1948 war, but it was not solely a consequence of Israel's creation.
The Rise of the PLO and the Intifadas: The rise of the PLO, led by Yasser Arafat, emerged as a significant force in the conflict in the 1960s and 1970s. It sought to represent the Palestinian people and fight for their rights through armed struggle. The First Intifada (1987-1993) and the Second Intifada (2000-2005) demonstrated the Palestinian people’s resolve and ability to resist Israeli occupation. These events, stemming from the ongoing Palestinian struggle against Israeli occupation, had a significant impact on the conflict, shaping its trajectory and highlighting the lasting consequences of the unresolved issues.
The Palestinian Authority: The establishment of the Palestinian Authority in 1994, following the Oslo Accords, marked a new phase in the conflict. It established a limited autonomous government in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, aimed at achieving a negotiated peace. While the Palestinian Authority has been plagued by internal divisions and limitations imposed by Israel, it has become a significant entity in the Palestinian struggle and a potential actor in future peace negotiations.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the creation of the state of Israel in 1948 was undoubtedly a pivotal event in the development of the Palestinian issue, it was not the most important turning point. The conflict had already been simmering for decades, fueled by pre-existing tensions, colonial policies, and unresolved claims. The decisions of the Zionist Congress, the Balfour Declaration, and the realities of the British Mandate played significant roles in shaping the conflict, setting the stage for the creation of Israel. However, the creation of Israel did act as a catalyst for the ongoing conflict, exacerbating existing tensions and leading to new challenges, including the Palestinian refugee crisis and the continued dispute over Jerusalem. This enduring struggle, driven by historical grievances, competing narratives, and unresolved issues, continues to shape the Palestinian issue today.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Supporting the Hypothesis
It might be argued that the UN Partition Plan of 1947 was a turning point in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as Palestinian Arabs rejected partition.
Answers might consider the following:
⭐The issue of Jerusalem: The plan divided the city, which was unacceptable to both sides.
⭐The Jews were given a larger area than the Arabs: This was seen as unfair by the Palestinian Arabs.
⭐Cities with large Arab majorities were designated as part of the Jewish state: This was also seen as unfair by the Palestinian Arabs.
⭐The impact of the massacres that followed the UN declaration: These massacres further inflamed tensions and made the conflict more difficult to resolve.
⭐The creation led to war and this would become a way to try and solve the problem in the future: The 1948 war was a direct result of the partition plan and set the stage for future conflicts.
Challenging the Hypothesis
It might be argued that the UN Partition Plan of 1947 was not the most important turning point in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Answers might consider the following:
⭐Zionist Congress decisions on 1905: These decisions laid the groundwork for the Zionist movement and its eventual goal of establishing a Jewish state in Palestine.
⭐The Balfour Declaration of 1917: This declaration promised the establishment of a "national home for the Jewish people" in Palestine, which was seen as a major turning point by the Zionist movement.
⭐The status of Palestine: The status of Palestine as a British mandate after World War I was a major factor in the development of the conflict.
⭐The issue of refugees: The displacement of Palestinian Arabs during the 1948 war has been a major issue in the conflict ever since.
⭐Arafat and the PLO: The rise of Yasser Arafat and the PLO in the 1960s and 1970s was a major turning point in the conflict, as it brought the Palestinian struggle to the forefront of international attention.
⭐The issue of Intifadas: The Palestinian uprisings of the 1980s and 1990s were major turning points in the conflict, as they helped to galvanize international support for the Palestinian cause.
⭐The impact of the Palestinian Authority: The establishment of the Palestinian Authority in the 1990s was a significant development, but it has also been plagued by internal divisions and corruption.