top of page

‘The main impact of foreign affairs on Britain during the period from 1848 to 1866 was the emergence of the Liberal party.’ How far do you agree?

Level

A Level

Year Examined

2022

Topic

British period study and enquiry: Liberals, Conservatives and the rise of Labour 1846-1918

👑Complete Model Essay

‘The main impact of foreign affairs on Britain during the period from 1848 to 1866 was the emergence of the Liberal party.’ How far do you agree?

The main impact of foreign affairs on Britain during the period from 1848 to 1866 was the emergence of the Liberal party. How far do you agree?
The period from 1848 to 1866 witnessed significant shifts in British politics, culminating in the emergence of the Liberal Party. While foreign affairs undoubtedly played a role in this transformation, arguing it was the primary driver oversimplifies the complex interplay of factors. This essay will explore the extent to which foreign affairs shaped the Liberal Party, acknowledging other contributing influences.

Foreign Affairs and the Rise of Palmerston
Lord Palmerston, a Whig, rose to prominence during this era due to his assertive foreign policy. His response to foreign affairs, characterized by a strong defense of British interests, resonated with a large segment of the population. His handling of the Crimean War (1853-56), where he successfully defended Turkish sovereignty against Russia, cemented his public image as a resolute leader. This popularity, coupled with his willingness to embrace liberal principles in domestic policy, contributed to the formation of the Liberal Party.

Constitutional Issues and the Liberal Consensus
Many foreign affairs issues of the period, such as the Crimean War and the Italian question, were framed as "constitutional" issues. This meant they appealed to a broad coalition of Whigs, Radicals, and Peelites, all of whom shared a commitment to constitutionalism and liberal principles. This shared outlook on foreign affairs facilitated an environment conducive to the rise of a new political party.

Free Trade and Liberal Economic Policies
The period also witnessed the completion of free trade agreements with countries like Piedmont and France. This push for liberalization of trade, spearheaded by figures like Richard Cobden, resonated with a segment of the electorate who favored free trade and economic reform. These policies, often championed by Whig and Peelite leaders, further contributed to the coalescence of the Liberal Party.

The Second Opium War and the "Liberals"
The Second Opium War (1858-60), fought to uphold British trading rights in China, demonstrated the growing influence of liberal thinking in foreign affairs. Figures like William Ewart Gladstone, who later became a prominent Liberal leader, were willing to support the war, highlighting the shifting attitudes towards foreign intervention within the emerging liberal camp.

The Italian Question and the Liberal Cause
The Italian Wars of Unification (1859-61) further solidified the Liberal Party. Many Britons, including prominent figures like Gladstone, supported Giuseppe Garibaldi and the Italian unification movement. This support for Italian independence, based on principles of self-determination and national unity, resonated with the Liberal cause and solidified the party's commitment to internationalist ideals.

Other Impacts of Foreign Affairs
While foreign affairs significantly contributed to the emergence of the Liberal Party, it is crucial to understand that other factors were also at play. The influx of European migrants to Britain, particularly to London, seeking refuge from persecution, impacted social and economic structures, contributing to tensions and societal shifts. The American Civil War and the subsequent "cotton famine" in Lancashire created hardship and economic distress, challenging existing political structures and potentially fostering calls for change.

Defense and Empire
Fears of French aggression in the wake of the Crimean War led to the creation of a significant military force and the construction of defensive fortifications, impacting the British economy and shaping the political landscape. Furthermore, events like the Indian Mutiny of 1857, while driven by internal factors, strengthened the argument for maintaining the British Empire. This focus on imperial expansion and national defense further shaped the political discourse of the era.

Conclusion
In conclusion, foreign affairs played a pivotal role in shaping the British political landscape during the period from 1848 to 1866. Palmerston's assertive foreign policy, the prominence of "constitutional" issues, and the growing acceptance of liberal principles in international affairs all contributed to the rise of the Liberal Party. However, attributing the party's emergence solely to foreign affairs would be an oversimplification. The complex interplay of domestic factors, including social and economic upheavals, the cotton famine, and the strengthening of imperial ambitions, also shaped the political discourse and laid the groundwork for the Liberal Party's ascendancy.

Note: History Study Pack Required

 

Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!

Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...

 

History Study Pack.

1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.

Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.

🍃 Free Essay Plan

Essay Outline: The Impact of Foreign Affairs on Britain (1848-1866)

Introduction:
- Briefly contextualize the period (1848-1866) and its significance in British history.
- Introduce the argument: While the emergence of the Liberal Party was a significant impact of foreign affairs, other factors were equally, if not more, impactful.
- Briefly outline the key arguments that will be discussed in the essay.

Body Paragraph 1: Foreign Affairs and the Formation of the Liberal Party

Argument: The dominant figure of Palmerston and his approach to foreign affairs heavily influenced the formation and ideology of the Liberal Party.
- Discuss Palmerston's political background (Whig) and his rise to prominence.
- Explain how his foreign policy (e.g., support for liberal movements abroad) aligned with emerging Liberal ideals.
- Highlight the coalescing of Whigs, Radicals, and Peelites around issues like free trade and constitutionalism, further solidifying the Liberal Party.
- Use examples like the Crimean War and support for Italian unification to illustrate these points.

Body Paragraph 2: Economic and Social Impacts of Foreign Affairs

Argument: Foreign affairs had profound effects on British society and economy, extending beyond purely political changes.
- Discuss the influx of European immigrants (particularly in London) fleeing political turmoil, and its impact on British society.
- Explain the "cotton famine" caused by the American Civil War and its devastating effect on Lancashire's textile industry.
- Analyze how the fear of French aggression led to increased military spending and the construction of defensive fortifications.

Body Paragraph 3: The Impact on British Imperialism

Argument: Foreign events, particularly the Indian Mutiny, had a substantial impact on British imperial policy and public opinion.
- Provide a concise overview of the Indian Mutiny and its causes.
- Analyze how the uprising led to a shift in British policy, from Company rule to direct Crown control.
- Discuss the impact of the Mutiny on public perception of the Empire and the debate surrounding its governance.

Body Paragraph 4: Countering the Central Claim

Argument: The emergence of the Liberal Party, while significant, shouldn't overshadow the broader impacts of foreign affairs.
- Acknowledge the important role of Palmerston and foreign policy in shaping the Liberal Party.
- However, emphasize that other factors, like the economic and social consequences discussed earlier, were equally transformative.
- Argue that focusing solely on the Liberal Party provides an incomplete picture of the period's complexities.

Conclusion:

- Briefly summarize the main arguments discussed in the essay.
- Reiterate that while the emergence of the Liberal Party was a significant consequence of foreign affairs, it was not the mainimpact.
- Offer a nuanced concluding statement that recognizes the multifaceted and far-reaching impact of foreign affairs on British society, economy, and imperial policy during the period 1848-1866.

Extracts from Mark Schemes

In arguing that the main impact of foreign affairs was the emergence of the Liberal Party
Answers might explain how Palmerston (a Whig) became a dominant figure whose response to foreign affairs helped shape the Liberal Party. Answers might argue that many of the affairs abroad were ‘constitutional’ issues on which Whigs, radical and Peelites agreed. Answers might discuss the completion of free trade agreements (e.g. with Piedmont and France) which united men who favoured the liberalisation of trade. Answers might assess the effects of the wars in China (1858-60) to uphold British trading rights which ‘liberals’ including Gladstone were prepared to support. Answers might argue that events in Italy, including support for Garibaldi, helped unite ‘liberals’

In arguing that there were other impacts,
Answers might discuss how people from Europe settled in Britain (especially London) to escape persecution at home. Answers might explain how the Civil War in the USA created the ‘cotton famine’ and hardship in Lancashire. Answers might explain how fears of France led to the creation of a force of 150,000 men and the building of a system of forts for defence. Answers might argue that foreign affairs, for example, the Indian Mutiny, strengthened support for empire. Answers might discuss the economic effects on industry of British involvement in foreign affairs.

bottom of page