How far do you agree that the problems of public health were the same in both the Early Modern Period (1500-1750) and in the twentieth century (1900-2000)?
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2020
Topic
Public Health
👑Complete Model Essay
How far do you agree that the problems of public health were the same in both the Early Modern Period (1500-1750) and in the twentieth century (1900-2000)?
Introduction
Public health, encompassing the health and well-being of a population, has been a concern for centuries. This essay will examine the public health challenges of two distinct periods: the Early Modern Period (1500-1750) and the twentieth century (1900-2000). While some problems persisted across both eras, significant differences arose due to advancements in science, technology, and societal structures. This essay argues that while fundamental challenges remained, the twentieth century witnessed substantial progress in understanding and addressing public health issues, differentiating it from the Early Modern Period.
Similarities in Public Health Problems
Epidemics and Lack of Understanding:
⭐The Early Modern period was ravaged by the bubonic plague, known as the Great Plague. Its cause, spread through fleas on rats, remained a mystery, and treatments were ineffective, resulting in widespread death and social disruption.
⭐Similarly, the twentieth century faced its own pandemics. The Spanish Flu of 1918-1920, caused by an influenza virus, killed millions globally. Later, the emergence of AIDS in the 1980s, a new and poorly understood disease, again highlighted humanity's vulnerability to infectious diseases despite advancements in medicine.
Urbanization and its Challenges:
⭐Both periods witnessed increasing urbanization, leading to overcrowded cities with inadequate sanitation.
⭐ In the Early Modern period, cities like London suffered from open sewers and contaminated water supplies, contributing to the spread of diseases like cholera and typhoid.
⭐Similarly, rapid industrialization in the twentieth century led to the growth of slums, where poverty and overcrowding exacerbated health problems.
Substance Abuse:
⭐Substance abuse has been a persistent public health concern across centuries, albeit with different substances.
⭐In the Early Modern period, gin consumption reached epidemic proportions in England, leading to social problems and health issues.
⭐The twentieth century saw the rise of drug addiction, with substances like heroin and cocaine posing significant public health challenges.
Resistance to Public Health Measures:
⭐Resistance to public health measures is not a new phenomenon.
⭐During the plague, quarantines were met with resistance due to religious beliefs, economic concerns, and distrust of authorities.
⭐This skepticism towards public health initiatives persisted in the twentieth century, exemplified by the anti-vaccination movement, illustrating the enduring challenge of overcoming misinformation and fear.
Differences in Public Health Problems
Scientific and Technological Advancements:
⭐The twentieth century witnessed groundbreaking scientific and technological advancements that revolutionized public health.
⭐The discovery of antibiotics, like penicillin, transformed the treatment of bacterial infections, which were often deadly in the Early Modern period.
⭐Vaccines, developed against diseases like polio and measles, drastically reduced their incidence and mortality rates. Improved sanitation systems, water treatment, and food safety regulations further contributed to a decline in infectious diseases.
Communication and Public Awareness:
⭐The twentieth century saw a revolution in communication. Mass media, including newspapers, radio, television, and later the internet, enabled faster and wider dissemination of information about public health threats and preventative measures.
⭐This increased awareness played a crucial role in promoting public health campaigns and encouraging healthy behaviors. In contrast, information spread slowly and often inaccurately in the Early Modern period, hindering effective responses to health crises.
Political and Social Reforms:
⭐The twentieth century witnessed significant political and social reforms that led to increased government involvement in public health.
⭐The rise of democracy and social welfare states led to the establishment of public health institutions, sanitation reforms, and programs addressing poverty and inequality. These interventions contributed to significant improvements in living conditions and overall population health. In contrast, public health in the Early Modern period was largely left to local authorities or charitable organizations, often with limited resources and reach.
Conclusion
While both the Early Modern Period and the twentieth century grappled with public health challenges, the nature and impact of these problems differed significantly. While fundamental issues like epidemics and the impact of urbanization persisted, the twentieth century benefited from groundbreaking scientific discoveries, improved communication, and increased government intervention. These factors dramatically improved living conditions, extended life expectancy, and revolutionized the approach to public health. Therefore, while acknowledging the similarities in the challenges faced, the twentieth century marked a distinct period in public health history, characterized by advancements that dramatically reshaped our understanding and ability to address health threats.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Start by defining "public health" and its importance. Briefly introduce the time periods: Early Modern (1500-1750) and 20th century (1900-2000). State your stance on the essay question - do you agree or disagree that the problems were the same? Mention you will be exploring both sides of the argument.
Similarities in Public Health Problems
Epidemics and Lack of Understanding:
⭐Early Modern: Discuss the Great Plague, its impact, and the limited understanding of its causes and treatments.
⭐20th Century: Discuss the Spanish Flu and AIDS pandemics. While medical knowledge had advanced, these events still caused widespread fear and death, highlighting the continued vulnerability to new diseases.
Urbanization and its Challenges:
⭐Both periods saw increasing urbanization, leading to overcrowding, poor sanitation, and the spread of diseases.
⭐Early Modern: Discuss examples like London's overcrowding and lack of proper sewage systems.
⭐20th Century: Discuss the growth of slums in industrial cities and the associated health problems.
Substance Abuse:
⭐Explain how substance abuse has been a persistent public health issue.
⭐Early Modern: Focus on the widespread consumption of gin and its social consequences.
⭐20th Century: Discuss the rise of drug addiction and its impact on public health.
Resistance to Public Health Measures:
⭐Early Modern: Mention resistance to quarantines during the plague due to religious beliefs or economic concerns.
⭐20th Century: Discuss the anti-vaccination movement and skepticism towards public health initiatives, showing the persistence of distrust in authority and science.
Differences in Public Health Problems
Scientific and Technological Advancements:
⭐Highlight the significant advancements in medicine and technology in the 20th century.
⭐Discuss the development of antibiotics, vaccines, and improved sanitation, which dramatically reduced the impact of many diseases prevalent in the Early Modern period.
Communication and Public Awareness:
⭐Contrast the limited communication channels in the Early Modern period with the advent of mass media (newspapers, radio, TV, internet) in the 20th century.
⭐Explain how this enabled faster spread of information about public health threats and preventative measures.
Political and Social Reforms:
⭐Discuss the rise of democracy and social reform movements in the 20th century, leading to government intervention in public health.
⭐Mention the establishment of public health institutions, sanitation reforms, and welfare programs that addressed poverty and improved living conditions.
Conclusion
Summarize the main arguments presented. Reiterate your stance - were the public health problems more similar or different? Acknowledge that while fundamental challenges like disease outbreaks and the impact of urbanization persisted, the 20th century saw significant advancements in scientific knowledge, communication, and government intervention, resulting in substantial differences in how public health issues were addressed and mitigated.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Public Health in the 17th-19th Centuries vs. the 20th Century: Continuity or Change?
Answers may be awarded some marks at Level 1 if they demonstrate any knowledge of public health in the relevant time periods. It is possible to reach the highest marks either by agreeing or disagreeing or anywhere between, providing the response matches the level description. BUT, to achieve the two highest levels, answers must consider both sides of the argument before reaching a conclusion.
Answers are most likely to show understanding of the second order concepts of continuity and change and diversity but reward appropriate understanding of any other second order concept.
Grounds for Agreeing:
⭐Epidemics and inability to explain them. Both periods experienced devastating epidemics, like the Great Plague and the Spanish Flu/AIDS, highlighting the persistent vulnerability to infectious diseases.
⭐Urbanisation caused more PH issues in both periods. Both the 17th-19th centuries and the 20th century saw increased urbanisation, leading to problems like pollution and poor housing conditions.
⭐Examples of reluctance to regulate. In both periods, there was resistance to public health regulations, often due to economic or ideological reasons.
⭐Substance abuse. Alcohol and drug abuse posed significant public health challenges in both eras.
⭐Religious resistance and distrust of science. Even in the 20th century, some resisted public health measures based on religious beliefs or distrust of science, as seen in the MMR vaccine controversy.
Grounds for Disagreeing:
⭐Scientific and technological advancements. The 20th century witnessed significant breakthroughs in medicine, sanitation, and public health infrastructure, leading to a dramatic reduction in mortality rates and improvements in overall health.
⭐Communication of public health messages. The advent of mass media like newspapers, television, and the internet enabled more effective communication of public health information in the 20th century.
⭐Growth of democracy and pressure for reform. The rise of democracy in the 20th century led to increased public pressure for social and health reforms, resulting in improved public health policies and programs.
⭐Role of increasing wealth. Increased wealth in the 20th century enabled greater investment in research, infrastructure, and public health initiatives.
⭐Move away from laissez-faire towards a welfare state. This shift in the 20th century led to increased government intervention in public health, resulting in the creation of public healthcare systems and social safety nets that mitigated many public health issues.