Which of the following was a more significant reason for Hitler’s appointment as Chancellor in 1933? i. The popular appeal of Nazism ii. ‘Backstairs Intrigue’ Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
Level
A Level
Year Examined
2021
Topic
Democracy and dictatorships in Germany 1919-1963
👑Complete Model Essay
Which of the following was a more significant reason for Hitler’s appointment as Chancellor in 1933? i. The popular appeal of Nazism ii. ‘Backstairs Intrigue’ Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
Which of the following was a more significant reason for Hitler’s appointment as Chancellor in 1933? i. The popular appeal of Nazism ii. ‘Backstairs Intrigue’ Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
The appointment of Adolf Hitler as Chancellor of Germany in January 1933 was a pivotal moment in the country’s history, marking the beginning of the Nazi regime. While the Nazi Party had gained considerable popularity in the years leading up to Hitler’s appointment, it is crucial to analyze the complex interplay of factors that contributed to his rise to power. This essay argues that while the popular appeal of Nazism played a significant role, it was ultimately ‘backstairs intrigue’ that secured Hitler’s appointment as Chancellor.
The Popular Appeal of Nazism was undeniably a significant factor in Hitler’s rise. The economic depression of the 1930s had left Germany in a state of despair, with high unemployment, social unrest, and a sense of humiliation following defeat in World War I. Nazi propaganda effectively exploited these anxieties, offering a scapegoat in the form of Jewish people and communists, who were blamed for Germany’s woes.
Nazi policies resonated with many Germans who sought radical change. The promise of economic recovery, national pride, and a strong, authoritarian leader resonated deeply with a population disillusioned with the Weimar Republic. The party's extremist ideology appealed to those seeking a sense of belonging and purpose, particularly among the youth.
Nazi electoral successes were further evidence of the party’s growing popularity. The Nazis secured a significant number of seats in the Reichstag in the 1930 and 1932 elections, demonstrating their ability to mobilize a large segment of the electorate. However, it is crucial to note that the Nazis never achieved an outright majority in the Reichstag, suggesting that their support, while significant, was not sufficient to secure power alone.
While the Nazis demonstrated significant popular appeal, their rise to power was ultimately facilitated by ‘Backstairs Intrigue’. Hitler was not elected Chancellor but rather appointed by President Paul von Hindenburg, who was persuaded by a combination of factors.
One key aspect was the conservative politicians’ underestimation of the Nazi threat. They mistakenly saw Hitler as a tool they could use to control the far-right and prevent a communist revolution.
The second election of 1932, in which the Nazi Party actually lost seats, further cemented this belief. Conservative politicians were willing to accept Hitler’s leadership as Chancellor as they believed they could control him.
However, Hitler was a cunning and opportunistic politician who was able to skillfully exploit the internal divisions within the conservative camp. He managed to form alliances with influential figures such as Franz von Papen, who ultimately convinced Hindenburg to appoint him Chancellor. This was despite the fact that Hitler was not the most popular choice amongst the conservative politicians.
In conclusion, while the popular appeal of Nazism undoubtedly played a role in Hitler’s rise, it was ‘backstairs intrigue’ that ultimately tipped the scales in his favor. The conservatives’ underestimation of Hitler and their eagerness to utilize him for their own purposes, combined with his own manipulative skills, enabled him to secure the position of Chancellor. While the Nazi Party had significant public support, it was through political maneuvering and the willingness of conservative politicians to grant him power that Hitler was able to gain control of Germany and usher in the era of the Third Reich.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Which was More Significant for Hitler's Chancellorship: Popular Appeal or Backstairs Intrigue?
This essay will argue that while the popular appeal of Nazism, particularly during the economic depression, played a significant role in Hitler's rise, it was ultimately the "backstairs intrigue" and miscalculations of conservative elites that proved decisive in securing his appointment as Chancellor in 1933. While Nazi support was substantial, it was not yet sufficient to win power democratically. The conservative establishment's maneuvering to use Hitler for their own ends backfired spectacularly, paving the way for his dictatorship.
I. The Role of Popular Appeal
Nazi ideology resonated with segments of the German population disillusioned by the Treaty of Versailles, economic hardship, and political instability.
⭐Economic Depression: The Nazis capitalized on the despair caused by the Great Depression, promising economic recovery and targeting their message to the unemployed, farmers, and small businesses.
⭐Nationalism and Propaganda: Propaganda masterfully exploited nationalist sentiment, blaming the Weimar Republic for Germany's woes and promising national renewal and a return to greatness.
⭐Charisma of Hitler: Hitler's powerful speeches and carefully crafted image as a decisive leader proved alluring to many seeking stability and strong leadership.
⭐Electoral Success: The Nazis became the largest party in the Reichstag by July 1932, demonstrating their growing support base.
However, it's crucial to note that even at their peak, the Nazis never achieved a majority in free and fair elections. This suggests that while their appeal was significant, it was not universally shared by the German people.
II. The Decisive Role of Backstairs Intrigue
Hitler's appointment was the result of political maneuvering by conservative elites, particularly President Hindenburg and his advisors, who underestimated the Nazi threat.
⭐Underestimation of Hitler: Conservatives, including Franz von Papen and Alfred Hugenberg, saw Hitler as a figure they could manipulate and control, aiming to use his popularity to further their own agenda.
⭐Belief in Controllable Force: They believed they could leverage the SA as a paramilitary force to intimidate opponents while keeping Hitler's power in check through a cabinet dominated by conservatives.
⭐Miscalculation and the Enabling Act: This strategy backfired drastically. The Reichstag Fire Decree and the Enabling Act, facilitated by conservative support, effectively handed Hitler dictatorial powers, dismantling the Weimar Republic from within.
The decline of Nazi electoral support in late 1932 further emphasizes that Hitler's path to power was not solely due to popular will. Backstairs intrigue provided him with the opportunity to seize power despite declining votes.
III. Conclusion: A Fatal Confluence
While the popular appeal of Nazism, fueled by economic crisis and nationalist sentiment, laid the groundwork for Hitler's rise, it was the miscalculations and "backstairs intrigue" of conservative elites that ultimately propelled him to the Chancellorship. Their attempts to exploit Hitler for their own ends tragically backfired, enabling him to dismantle democracy and establish a dictatorship that would have devastating consequences.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
In dealing with the popular appeal of Nazism
Answers might consider the appeal of Nazi policies, particularly at a time of economic depression. Answers might consider Nazi electoral successes. Answers might consider the effectiveness of Nazi propaganda and Hitler’s charismatic leadership.
In dealing with ‘backstairs intrigue’
Answers might consider that Hitler was appointed Chancellor, not elected, and required Hindenburg’s support. Answers might consider that Hitler’s conservative rivals underestimated him and provided him with opportunities he was effective in exploiting. Answers might consider that the Nazis actually lost seats in the Reichstag in the second election of 1932, so may have been unlikely to win power electorally.