Why did countries lose confidence in the League of Nations in the 1930s?
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2020
Topic
League of Nations
👑Complete Model Essay
Why did countries lose confidence in the League of Nations in the 1930s?
Introduction
The League of Nations, established in 1920 with the noble goal of preventing future wars, found itself facing a crisis of confidence throughout the 1930s. This decline stemmed from a number of factors, but two events, in particular, exposed the League's weaknesses and ultimately contributed to its failure: the Manchurian Crisis (1931-1933) and the Abyssinian Crisis (1935-1936). These crises demonstrated the League's inability to effectively deal with aggression by powerful nations who felt emboldened to defy the organization, undermining international faith in its ability to maintain peace.
Manchurian Crisis (1931-1933)
A Test of Resolve: The Manchurian Crisis provided an early and significant test for the League. In 1931, Japan, seeking to expand its empire, invaded Manchuria, a region in northeastern China. This act of aggression directly challenged the League's core principles of collective security and peaceful resolution of disputes.
Ineffective Response and Appeasement: The League, hampered by its lack of a standing military force and reliant on the cooperation of member states, responded with condemnations and economic sanctions against Japan. However, these measures proved largely ineffective. Japan, unwilling to back down, withdrew from the League in 1933, demonstrating that a determined aggressor could act with impunity.
A Blow to the League's Credibility: The League's failure to protect China and enforce its own Covenant had profound consequences. It exposed the organization's vulnerability to powerful states willing to disregard international law and act in their own self-interest. This emboldened other nations with expansionist ambitions and significantly weakened global confidence in the League's ability to prevent future conflicts.
Abyssinian Crisis (1935-1936)
A Second Critical Failure: If the Manchurian Crisis exposed the League's weaknesses, the Abyssinian Crisis confirmed its impotence. In 1935, Fascist Italy, led by Benito Mussolini, invaded Abyssinia (Ethiopia), a fellow member of the League. This act of aggression was a blatant violation of international law and a direct challenge to the League's authority.
Compromise and Self-Interest: Despite condemning the invasion, the League's response was again characterized by hesitation and ultimately, failure. The Hoare-Laval Pact, a secret agreement between Britain and France to appease Mussolini by offering him part of Abyssinia, revealed the cynical self-interest that trumped collective security. While the pact was never implemented due to public outcry, it further damaged the League's credibility and highlighted the unwillingness of leading powers to take decisive action against aggression.
Consequence of Inaction: The League's failure to protect Abyssinia had devastating consequences. It demonstrated to the world that aggression, even when condemned, could still be successful. This further emboldened dictators like Hitler in Germany, who witnessed the League's weakness and began to openly disregard its authority, ultimately contributing to the outbreak of World War II.
Conclusion
The Manchurian and Abyssinian Crises were critical turning points in the decline of confidence in the League of Nations. They exposed the organization's fatal flaws: a lack of military power, dependence on the cooperation of self-interested member states, and an inability to effectively enforce its own covenant. The failure of the League to address these crises had profound global consequences. It undermined faith in collective security, emboldened aggressors, and ultimately contributed to the outbreak of a second world war, a conflict the League was powerless to prevent.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
The League of Nations, established after World War I to prevent future conflicts, faced growing skepticism throughout the 1930s. This essay will examine two key reasons for this decline in confidence: the Manchurian Crisis and the Abyssinian Crisis, both of which exposed the League's inability to effectively address aggression and uphold its own principles.
Manchurian Crisis (1931-1933)
Japan's Invasion and the League's Response: In 1931, Japan, a member of the League, invaded Manchuria in China. The League, lacking a standing army, responded with diplomatic pressure and sent Lord Lytton to investigate.
Delayed Action and Ineffectual Sanctions: The Lytton Report, completed after a year, condemned Japan's actions but failed to offer a solution before Japan consolidated its control. The League's attempt at economic sanctions was weak and unenforceable.
Loss of Confidence: Japan's successful defiance and the League's impotence demonstrated its limitations in dealing with powerful aggressors, undermining faith in its ability to protect member states.
Abyssinian Crisis (1935-1936)
Italy's Aggression and the League's Response: In 1935, Italy, another League member, invaded Abyssinia (Ethiopia). The League condemned the invasion but again resorted to limited economic sanctions.
Hoare-Laval Pact and Self-Interest: The secret Hoare-Laval Pact, proposing to appease Mussolini by granting him part of Abyssinia, further damaged the League's credibility. This exposed the self-interest of leading members (Britain and France) over upholding collective security.
Failure to Protect and Deter: The League's failure to prevent Italy's conquest of Abyssinia and its willingness to compromise with the aggressor further diminished confidence in its ability to protect weaker nations or deter future aggression.
Conclusion
The Manchurian and Abyssinian Crises were pivotal in eroding confidence in the League of Nations during the 1930s. The League's lack of a military force, its slow and ineffective responses, and the self-serving actions of its leading members ultimately rendered it incapable of fulfilling its primary purpose: preventing another world war. These failures paved the way for the outbreak of World War II, demonstrating the tragic consequences of a powerless and compromised international organization.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Level 5 Answers
Level 5 answers will typically identify at least two reasons why countries lost confidence in the League of Nations in the 1930s and explain them fully.
Countries lost confidence in the League in the 1930s for several reasons. One reason was the Manchurian Crisis. In 1931 Japan, who was a leading member of the League, invaded Manchuria in China. The League lacked an army, and instead of intervening sent Lord Lytton to carry out an investigation. This took almost a year, by which time Japan had taken control of Manchuria and then left the League when asked to return it to China. This made countries lose confidence in the League as they had failed to stop the invasion or control one of their own members.
Another reason was the Abyssinian Crisis. In 1935 Italy – another member of the League – invaded Abyssinia in Africa. Again the League did very little, and in fact Britain and France tried to make a secret deal with Mussolini to give him part of Abyssinia which caused great embarrassment when it became public. Mussolini conquered Abyssinia and left the League. The main members of the League of Nations had failed to protect smaller countries and acted in their own self-interest, which again caused countries to lose confidence in it.