04 Describe two problems faced by people in crossing the Plains before 1865.
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2022
Topic
World History
👑Complete Model Essay
04 Describe two problems faced by people in crossing the Plains before 1865.
Describe two problems faced by people in crossing the Plains before 1865.
Introduction:
The vast expanse of the Great Plains, stretching from the Mississippi River to the Rocky Mountains, presented a formidable challenge to those seeking a new life in the American West before 1865. Fueled by the allure of gold, land, and new beginnings, thousands embarked on this perilous journey. However, the dream of reaching the fertile valleys of Oregon or the goldfields of California was often overshadowed by harrowing obstacles. Two of the most significant problems faced by these pioneers were the harsh and unpredictable weather conditions and the ever-present threat of conflict with Native American tribes.
Problem 1: Harsh Weather Conditions:
The Plains were notorious for their extreme and unpredictable weather patterns. Travelers faced scorching summers with temperatures soaring well over 100 degrees Fahrenheit, often with no natural shade for relief. These conditions led to dehydration and heatstroke, proving fatal for many. Conversely, winters brought bitter cold, with temperatures plummeting below freezing. Blizzards could sweep across the Plains with little warning, blanketing the landscape in feet of snow and making travel impossible. The dangers of these blizzards are tragically illustrated by the fate of the Donner Party in 1846. Trapped by heavy snowfall in the Sierra Nevada mountains, they were forced to camp for the winter. As their food supplies dwindled, the desperate group resorted to cannibalism to survive, a chilling testament to the brutality of the journey. Even when travelers avoided the most extreme conditions, the weather posed constant challenges. Torrential rain could turn trails into muddy bogs, halting progress for days or even weeks. Hailstorms and tornadoes could appear suddenly, threatening livestock and damaging possessions. Sandstorms could blot out the sun for hours, making navigation near impossible. These weather-related hardships resulted in lost time, dwindling supplies, illness, and the deaths of both humans and vital livestock.
Problem 2: Conflicts with Native American Tribes:
While it is essential to acknowledge that interactions between settlers and Native Americans were not always hostile, and some tribes proved helpful and welcoming, increasing tensions led to numerous violent encounters. The westward expansion of settlers encroached upon Native American lands, disrupting their traditional way of life. Competition for resources, such as land for farming and hunting, further fueled these tensions. Moreover, the U.S. government's policies of forced relocation and broken treaties exacerbated the conflict. For Native Americans, defending their homelands and way of life was paramount. The tragic fate of the Gould family in 1862 vividly illustrates the very real dangers faced by travelers. Upon encountering 11 abandoned wagons, they made the horrifying discovery of the deceased families inside, victims of an attack. This grim scene served as a stark reminder of the human cost of westward expansion. Such conflicts, fueled by misunderstandings, prejudices, and the drive for land and resources, cast a long shadow over the journey west.
Conclusion:
The journey across the Great Plains before 1865 was fraught with challenges, with harsh weather conditions and conflicts with Native American tribes presenting significant obstacles. These hardships resulted in countless delays, the loss of life, and constant fear for those seeking a new life in the West. However, despite the dangers, thousands persevered, demonstrating remarkable resilience and determination in the face of adversity. Their experiences paint a complex picture of westward expansion, marked by both the promise of a new beginning and the tragic consequences of cultural clashes and environmental challenges.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Describe two problems faced by people in crossing the Plains before 1865.
Introduction:
- Briefly introduce the Plains and the westward expansion before 1865.
- State the two main problems to be discussed: harsh weather conditions and conflicts with Native American tribes.
Problem 1: Harsh Weather Conditions:
- Explain the unpredictable and extreme weather patterns on the Plains (torrential rain, tornadoes, hailstorms, sandstorms, scorching heat, freezing cold).
- Discuss the dangers of snow blizzards in the mountains, using the Donner Party (1846) as a case study:
- Their decision to camp for the winter due to heavy snowfall.
- Running out of food and resorting to cannibalism for survival.
- Mention other examples of hardships caused by weather, such as delays, loss of livestock, and illness.
Problem 2: Conflicts with Native American Tribes:
- Acknowledge that not all interactions with Native Americans were negative; some tribes were friendly and helpful.
- Explain the reasons behind hostilities:
- encroachment on Native American lands by settlers.
- Competition for resources.
- Broken treaties and government policies.
- Use the Gould family's experience in 1862 as an example of the dangers:
- Finding 11 plundered wagons and the deceased families, highlighting the tragic consequences of conflicts.
- Briefly mention other examples of violent encounters between settlers and Native American tribes.
Conclusion:
- Reiterate the two main problems faced by people crossing the Plains: weather and conflicts with Native Americans.
- Briefly summarize the impact of these problems on westward expansion.
- Offer a concluding thought, such as acknowledging the resilience and determination of those who undertook this perilous journey or the complex relationship between settlers and Native Americans during this period.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
One Problem: The Weather
One problem was the weather because it took many weeks to cross the Plains and travellers could face torrential rain, tornadoes, hail and sandstorms, scorching heat and freezing cold. The snow blizzards in the mountains were a great danger. The Donner party decided to camp for the winter but ran out of food and only survived because they ate those who had died.
Another Problem: Plains Indians
Another problem was that some Plains Indians were friendly and would act as guides or offer to trade but others were hostile. The Gould family who travelled west in 1862 found 11 wagons that had been plundered by Plains Indians and the families killed.