Describe two problems faced by the American Government in settling the West.
Level
GCSE
Year Examined
2021
Topic
America, 1840–1895: Expansion and consolidation
👑Complete Model Essay
Describe two problems faced by the American Government in settling the West.
Describe two problems faced by the American Government in settling the West.
Introduction
<br>
The westward expansion of the United States during the 19th century, driven by the idea of Manifest Destiny, presented the American government with immense opportunities and formidable challenges. As settlers pushed beyond the Mississippi River, the government played a crucial role in encouraging and facilitating their movement. However, this expansion was not without its difficulties. Two primary problems the government faced were encouraging settlement despite geographical challenges and addressing the inevitable conflicts with Native Americans. This essay will explore how these challenges shaped the course of westward expansion and its lasting impact on the nation.
Problem 1: Transportation and Encouraging Settlement
One of the biggest hurdles to settling the West was the sheer distance and harshness of the terrain. The Great Plains, stretching from the Mississippi River to the Rocky Mountains, presented a daunting barrier with its arid climate, limited water sources, and challenging weather conditions. These factors discouraged widespread settlement and made it difficult for the government to incentivize migration.
To overcome these obstacles, the government took significant steps. The passage of the Pacific Railways Act in 1861 marked a turning point. This act provided federal subsidies for the construction of a transcontinental railroad, connecting the East Coast to the West Coast. The completion of the transcontinental railroad in 1869 revolutionized travel and trade. It drastically reduced travel time, allowing for the easier transportation of both people and goods. This development was crucial in stimulating economic growth and connecting the distant regions of the expanding nation.
In addition to the railroad, the government enacted legislation like the Homestead Act of 1862. This act granted 160 acres of free land to individuals willing to cultivate it for a certain period. This policy, along with others, enticed many Americans, including European immigrants, to venture westward in search of new opportunities. However, these policies also had unintended consequences. The rapid influx of settlers put pressure on the environment, leading to overgrazing and deforestation. Moreover, the appropriation of land for settlement further marginalized Native American tribes, foreshadowing the conflicts to come.
Problem 2: Conflicts with Native Americans
The westward expansion of the United States inevitably led to clashes with Native American tribes. Native Americans, with their established cultures and ways of life intrinsically tied to the land, saw their traditional territories encroached upon by settlers seeking land and resources. This clash of cultures lay at the heart of the conflict. For many Native Americans, the concept of private land ownership was alien, as was the settlers' emphasis on agriculture over traditional hunting and gathering practices. The decimation of buffalo herds, a vital resource for many Plains tribes, further exacerbated tensions and threatened Native American ways of life.
The government's approach to dealing with Native Americans was riddled with inconsistencies and broken promises. Initially, treaties were signed with various tribes, often designating specific areas as reservations. However, these agreements were frequently violated as settlers, backed by the government, sought more land and resources. The discovery of gold and other valuable minerals in Native American territories further fueled this drive, leading to increased pressure on the government to seize control of these areas.
When diplomacy failed, the government resorted to military force. Conflicts like the Battle of Little Bighorn in 1876, where the Sioux tribe, led by Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse, famously defeated General Custer, demonstrated Native American resistance. However, these victories were often short-lived. The US Army, with its superior firepower and resources, ultimately suppressed most Native American resistance. The Wounded Knee Massacre in 1890, where hundreds of unarmed Sioux men, women, and children were killed, tragically marked the end of major armed resistance. Beyond military subjugation, the government implemented policies of assimilation, such as the Dawes Act of 1887. This act aimed to break up tribal lands by granting individual plots to Native Americans, forcing them to adopt European-style farming practices and abandon their traditional ways of life.
The consequences for Native Americans were devastating. They faced widespread displacement, loss of land, and the erosion of their cultural identities. The government's actions during this period remain a dark chapter in American history, raising questions about the ethics of westward expansion and its impact on indigenous populations.
Conclusion
The settlement of the American West was a complex and challenging process. While the government succeeded in overcoming geographical barriers and encouraging westward migration, it did so at a significant cost, particularly for Native American populations. The legacy of westward expansion is multifaceted. It led to the development of the American West as we know it, shaping the nation's economy, identity, and landscape. However, this progress was built upon the displacement and cultural disruption of Native Americans, the repercussions of which still resonate today. The story of westward expansion serves as a reminder of the enduring power of the drive for expansion and the importance of understanding its full implications, both positive and negative, on the shaping of a nation.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Describe two problems faced by the American Government in settling the West.
Introduction
br
• Briefly introduce the concept of westward expansion in the US and the government's role in it.
br
• State the two main problems: Encouraging settlement despite geographical challenges and dealing with conflicts with Native Americans.
br
• Thesis statement: While the American government faced significant obstacles in settling the West, their efforts to overcome transportation difficulties and address Native American resistance ultimately shaped the nation's development.
Problem 1: Transportation and Encouraging Settlement
• Challenge: The vastness and harsh conditions of the Great Plains made travel arduous and discouraged widespread settlement.
br
• Government Response:
br • Passage of the Pacific Railways Act (1861) to fund the transcontinental railroad.
br • Explain the significance of the railroad: faster travel, transportation of goods, connection of East and West.
br • Mention other acts like the Homestead Act (1862) that incentivized settlement.
br
• Impact:
br • Increased migration to the West.
br • Economic growth facilitated by the flow of people and resources.
br • However, also acknowledge environmental consequences and the displacement of Native Americans.
Problem 2: Conflicts with Native Americans
• Challenge: Westward expansion encroached upon Native American lands, leading to conflict and resistance.
br
• Explain the clash of cultures:
br • Traditional nomadic lifestyles of Native Americans vs. the settlers' desire for land ownership and agriculture.
br • The decimation of the buffalo herds, which were essential to Native American life.
br
• Government Response:
br • Initially, treaties were signed, but often broken, leading to further conflict.
br • Military force was used to suppress Native American resistance (mention key conflicts like Little Bighorn and Wounded Knee).
br • Policies of assimilation were implemented (e.g., the Dawes Act), aiming to force Native Americans to adopt white culture.
br
• Impact:
br • Devastating consequences for Native American populations: loss of land, forced relocation, cultural destruction.
br • This remains a dark chapter in American history, highlighting the ethical complexities of westward expansion.
Conclusion
• Reiterate that the settlement of the West, while facilitated by government actions, came at a significant cost, particularly for Native Americans.
br
• Briefly connect to the long-term impact: the development of the American West, the ongoing legacy of the treatment of Native Americans, and the shaping of the nation's identity.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
The Thorny Path West: Challenges to American Expansion
The mid-19th century saw a surge in westward expansion in the United States, fueled by the allure of land and opportunity. The American government, eager to consolidate its continental power, played a pivotal role in encouraging and facilitating this movement. However, the path west was not paved with gold, but rather riddled with obstacles. Two key challenges faced by the government were encouraging settlement despite daunting geographical barriers and addressing the inevitable conflicts with Native American populations. While the government's efforts to overcome these challenges ultimately shaped the nation's development, they also left a legacy marked by both progress and tragedy.
A Bridge Across the Plains: Overcoming the Challenge of Distance
The vast expanse of the Great Plains, stretching from the Mississippi River to the Rocky Mountains, presented a formidable barrier to westward migration. The harsh climate, lack of readily available water sources, and sheer distance made the journey arduous and discouraged many from attempting it. Recognizing the need to connect the East Coast with the burgeoning West, the government took decisive action. The passage of the Pacific Railways Act in 1861 provided crucial funding for the construction of the transcontinental railroad. This monumental undertaking revolutionized travel to and within the West. The railroad drastically reduced travel time, facilitated the transportation of goods and resources, and fostered a greater sense of interconnectedness between the two halves of the nation.
Beyond the railroad, the government incentivized settlement through legislation like the Homestead Act of 1862, which granted 160 acres of public land to individuals willing to cultivate it. These measures proved remarkably effective, sparking a surge in westward migration and transforming the demographic landscape of the nation. However, this progress came at a cost. The influx of settlers, coupled with the expansion of railroads, had a devastating impact on the environment, decimating buffalo herds and disrupting delicate ecosystems.
A Clash of Cultures: Confronting the Native American Question
Perhaps the most significant challenge to westward expansion stemmed from the inevitable encounter with Native American tribes who had called these lands home for centuries. The arrival of settlers, driven by the desire for land and resources, directly clashed with the traditional nomadic lifestyles of many Native American tribes. The decimation of the buffalo herds, a vital resource for food, clothing, and spiritual practices, further exacerbated tensions. While the government initially attempted to address these conflicts through treaties, these agreements were often broken or disregarded, leading to further mistrust and hostility.
As tensions escalated, the government increasingly relied on military force to suppress Native American resistance. Conflicts like the Battle of Little Bighorn, a shocking defeat for the US Army, and the Wounded Knee Massacre, a brutal and tragic event that marked the end of armed resistance, became stark reminders of the human cost of expansion. In addition to military campaigns, the government pursued policies of assimilation, aiming to erase Native American culture and force them to adopt white societal norms. The Dawes Act of 1887, which aimed to dismantle tribal land holdings and force assimilation through private land ownership, exemplifies this approach. These policies had devastating and long-lasting consequences, resulting in the loss of land, forced relocation, and cultural suppression for generations of Native Americans.
A Legacy of Progress and Pain
The American government's efforts to settle the West undeniably played a crucial role in shaping the nation into the continental power it is today. The construction of the transcontinental railroad, the passage of legislation like the Homestead Act, and the eventual subjugation of Native American resistance all contributed to the incorporation of the West into the national fabric. However, this chapter in American history remains deeply complex and morally ambiguous. The displacement and suffering inflicted upon Native American populations serve as a stark reminder of the human cost associated with westward expansion. The legacy of this period continues to resonate today, shaping our understanding of the nation's past, its relationship with Native American communities, and its ongoing quest for a more just and equitable future.