Which of the following had a greater impact on Europe? (i) Silver from the New World (ii) Trade with overseas empires Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
Level
A Level
Year Examined
2022
Topic
Exploration, encounters and empire 1445-1570
👑Complete Model Essay
Which of the following had a greater impact on Europe? (i) Silver from the New World (ii) Trade with overseas empires Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
The Impact of Silver and Overseas Trade on Europe
The arrival of vast quantities of silver from the New World and the burgeoning trade with overseas empires profoundly impacted Europe during the 16th and 17th centuries. While both factors contributed to economic growth, political shifts, and social change, the **impact of silver from the New World was arguably greater**, due to its immediate and widespread effects across Europe. This essay will explore the multifaceted influences of both silver and overseas trade, ultimately arguing that silver's influence was more pervasive and transformative.
Silver from the New World
The influx of silver from the Americas, particularly from the mines of Potosí, dramatically altered the European economy. The **price revolution*of the 16th century, characterized by inflation, is often attributed to the influx of silver. This inflation, while initially beneficial to landowners and merchants, eventually led to hardship for the poor, who saw their wages eroded by rising prices.
Beyond inflation, the silver from the New World **fueled the Spanish Empire's power and ambition**. It allowed Spain to fund its wars, both within Europe and in its overseas colonies. The silver was used to pay for the salaries of Spanish soldiers, the maintenance of its vast fleet, and the purchase of supplies. This financial muscle enabled Spain to become a dominant force in 16th century Europe, but it ultimately contributed to its economic and political decline.
The flow of silver also **allowed the Spanish crown to repay loans from its bankers**, thereby consolidating its financial position. However, the increase in silver supply undermined the business of European silver mines, leading to their decline and associated social consequences.
Trade with Overseas Empires
The burgeoning trade with overseas empires, particularly with the Americas and the East Indies, also had significant effects on Europe. It **stimulated the export of goods from Europe**, including textiles, manufactured goods, and foodstuffs. Spain, for example, exported cloth, oil, and wine.
This trade also **introduced new goods into Europe**, such as rubber, fruits, timbers, and spices. These exotic commodities became highly desired, leading to the growth of new industries and markets.
The expansion of trade **increased customs revenue for European governments**, providing them with additional financial resources. Moreover, the **shipping industry in Europe expanded**, leading to the growth of ports such as Seville and the internal migration of people to these port cities.
Conclusion
While both the influx of silver and the trade with overseas empires played crucial roles in shaping European history, the **impact of silver was more immediate, pervasive, and transformative**. The silver from the New World directly impacted the European economy, fueled Spanish expansion, and ultimately contributed to the price revolution. While trade with overseas empires led to the introduction of new goods and the expansion of European shipping, its effects were arguably less profound than those of silver. The silver revolution, with its dramatic impact on prices, power dynamics, and the lives of ordinary people, had a greater impact on the European landscape.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Which had a greater impact on Europe: Silver from the New World or Trade with Overseas Empires?
Introduction:
Briefly introduce the Age of Exploration and the two key factors: influx of New World silver and burgeoning overseas trade. State your argument – which factor had a greater impact and why (e.g., more transformative, longer-lasting effects).
I. The Impact of New World Silver
A. Economic Upheaval and Inflation:
Discuss the Price Revolution and the debate surrounding it. Was the influx of silver the sole cause of inflation, or were other factors at play? How did this inflation impact different social groups (e.g., wage earners vs. landowners)?
B. Spain's Silver-Lined and Frayed Economy:
Explain how Spain used silver to finance its empire: paying for imports, funding wars, repaying debts. Highlight the negative consequences – did reliance on silver hinder Spain's development of a diverse domestic economy?
C. The Ripple Effect on European Silver Production:
Discuss the impact on European silver mines. Did the influx of New World silver lead to their decline? Were there any shifts in European mining practices or economic focus as a result?
II. The Impact of Trade with Overseas Empires
A. A Catalyst for European Exports:
Discuss how the demand for goods in overseas empires stimulated European production, using examples like Spanish cloth, oil, and wine. Explain the concept of mercantilism and its role in shaping trade policies.
B. The Arrival of New Goods and Consumerism:
Analyze the impact of new goods like rubber, fruits, and timbers on European society. Did these goods change consumption patterns, create new industries, or impact daily life?
C. Economic and Social Transformations:
Discuss the wider economic benefits: increased customs revenue for governments, the growth of the shipping industry, and the rise of port cities like Seville. Analyze the social changes – did internal migration to ports lead to urbanization and new social dynamics?
III. Weighing the Impacts: A Comparative Analysis
Directly compare the impacts of silver and trade. Which factor led to more profound and lasting changes in Europe?
Consider:
Scope:Did silver or trade affect a wider range of aspects of European life (e.g., economic systems, social structures, political power)?
Longevity:Were the effects of silver or trade more long-lasting and influential in shaping Europe's future trajectory?
Transformative Power:Which factor was a more significant driver of change – did it fundamentally alter existing structures or create entirely new dynamics?
Conclusion
Reiterate your argument, summarizing why you believe either silver or trade had a greater impact. Provide a nuanced perspective – acknowledge the interconnectedness of these factors and their combined role in shaping Europe's destiny. End with a thought-provoking statement about the lasting legacy of this period on Europe and the world.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Dealing with Supplies of Silver from the New World
Answers might discuss the debate about inflation in the 16th Century. Answers might explain that silver was used to pay for Spanish imports. Answers might explain that silver funded wars fought by Spain (the pay and provision of Spanish forces). Answers might argue that silver allowed the Crown to repay loans from its bankers. Answers might argue that silver supplies undermined the business of European silver mines.
Dealing with Trade with Overseas Empires
Answers might argue that empire stimulated the export of goods from Europe (for example, from Spain: cloth, oil, wine). Answers might argue that new goods were imported such as rubber, fruits, timbers). Answers might argue that revenue from customs increased, to the benefit of governments. Answers might argue that the shipping industry in Europe gained from increased trade. Answers might discuss the growth of ports, for example, Seville, and the internal migration of people to the ports.