Which of the following caused the greater difficulty for early explorers? (i) Problems of navigation (ii) Conditions at sea Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
Level
A Level
Year Examined
2022
Topic
Exploration, encounters and empire 1445-1570
👑Complete Model Essay
Which of the following caused the greater difficulty for early explorers? (i) Problems of navigation (ii) Conditions at sea Explain your answer with reference to both (i) and (ii).
Which of the following caused the greater difficulty for early explorers? (i) Problems of navigation (ii) Conditions at sea
Early explorers faced numerous challenges in their voyages of discovery, with navigation and the harsh conditions at sea presenting significant obstacles. While both presented difficulties, conditions at sea arguably posed a greater challenge for early explorers due to their direct and often immediate impact on survival, ship safety, and the morale of the crew. This essay will explore the difficulties of both navigation and conditions at sea, ultimately arguing that the latter was a more significant obstacle for early explorers.
Problems of Navigation
Navigation in the pre-modern era was a complex and challenging endeavor. The limitations of cartography, with inaccurate maps and incomplete knowledge of the world, made it difficult to chart a course and stay on track. Finding latitude was possible using the stars, but fixing longitude remained a major problem until the invention of the chronometer in the 18th century. Early explorers relied on dead reckoning, using compass bearings and estimated distances, which could lead to significant errors and potential disaster.
Despite these shortcomings, early explorers did utilize some navigational advancements. The knowledge and techniques of Arab and Chinese mathematicians and navigators, notably the use of Arabic mathematical tables and the compass, were adopted by the Spanish and Portuguese, contributing to their success in navigating the oceans. However, navigating in uncharted waters, especially on the open sea or off coasts, remained a formidable challenge, filled with uncertainties and potential dangers.
Conditions at Sea
Conditions at sea could be incredibly harsh, posing constant threats to the well-being of explorers and their ships. Prevailing winds, while sometimes helpful, could also be fierce and unpredictable, pushing ships off course and making it difficult to maintain a steady journey. The vast stretches of open water made communication between ships on the same expedition difficult, hindering coordination and potentially isolating ships in distress.
The high seas and strong currents of certain routes, like the Cape Horn in South America, presented significant dangers, risking shipwrecks and loss of life. Long journeys, especially those venturing far from known shores, presented immense difficulties in maintaining fresh water and food supplies. The lack of refrigeration meant spoilage, leading to disease and starvation among the crew. Furthermore, the constant threat of scurvy, caused by vitamin C deficiency, was a major problem requiring knowledge of preventive measures and careful food preservation.
Maintaining crew morale on long journeys, often in cramped and arduous conditions, was a constant concern for captains. Disease, injury, exhaustion, and fear of the unknown could lead to mutiny, desertion, or loss of hope.
Finally, explorers faced the difficult task of harboring in uncharted waters. Identifying safe anchorages, obtaining fresh supplies, and navigating unfamiliar coastlines were daunting tasks that could easily turn perilous if the wrong decision was made.
Conclusion
While both navigation and conditions at sea presented significant challenges to early explorers, conditions at sea arguably had a greater impact on their success. The immediate dangers posed by storms, currents, disease, and lack of supplies had a direct and often immediate impact on survival, ship safety, and the morale of the crew. In contrast, while navigational errors could lead to disaster, they were typically less immediate and could be mitigated by careful planning and the use of available knowledge and tools. While navigation was crucial for charting a course, it was ultimately the harsh conditions at sea that posed the greatest threat to explorers' well-being and the success of their voyages.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Early explorers faced immense challenges in their pursuit of new lands and sea routes. This essay will argue that while problems of navigation presented significant obstacles, conditions at sea posed the greater difficulty for early explorers. Navigation difficulties, while real, were often surmountable with existing knowledge and technology, whereas the unpredictable and often harsh conditions at sea presented constant and life-threatening dangers.
Problems of Navigation
Early explorers certainly faced challenges in navigation. Cartography was in its infancy, with maps often inaccurate or incomplete. Determining latitude using celestial navigation was possible but required precise instruments and calculations. Finding longitude proved far more challenging, with no reliable method available until the invention of the marine chronometer centuries later. However, explorers were not without navigational tools. They relied on Arabic mathematical tables and adopted technologies like the astrolabe and compass, demonstrating a willingness to learn from other cultures. Moreover, explorers often hugged coastlines, using landmarks for guidance whenever possible.
Conditions at Sea
The conditions at sea presented far more formidable and relentless challenges. Prevailing winds could either speed up or severely hinder a journey, and unpredictable storms could appear suddenly, tossing ships about like toys. Communication between ships on the same expedition was rudimentary, increasing the risks if separated. Life onboard was grueling. Fresh water and food would spoil on long voyages, leading to scurvy and other diseases. Maintaining crew morale amidst storms, disease, and hunger was a constant struggle. Furthermore, the need to find safe harbor in unfamiliar waters added another layer of difficulty and danger.
Conclusion
While navigational challenges undoubtedly existed, the unforgiving nature of the open sea posed the greater threat to early explorers. The capricious weather, disease, hunger, and psychological toll of seafaring presented constant and often insurmountable obstacles. While explorers showed ingenuity and adaptability in overcoming navigational hurdles, it was the brutal conditions at sea that truly tested the limits of human endurance and ultimately determined the fate of many expeditions.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
In dealing with problems of navigation
Answers might discuss the limitations of cartography. Answers might explain the difficulty of finding latitude. Answers might explain the difficulty of fixing longitude. Answers might discuss the value of Arabic mathematical tables. Answers might explain the extent to which the knowledge and techniques of Arabs and Chinese were adopted by the Spanish and Portuguese. Answers might discuss the difficulty of navigating in uncharted waters on the open sea or off coasts.
In dealing with conditions at sea
Answers might explain how prevailing winds were difficult. Answers might explain the difficulty of communication between ships on the same expedition. Answers might discuss the difficulty of high seas and currents especially on particular routes. Answers might discuss the problems of fresh water and food supplies on long journeys especially. Answers might discuss the difficulty of maintaining the morale of the crew. Answers might explain the difficulty of harbouring in uncharted waters.