How the centenary of the First World War affected the debate: the importance of contingency over motive
12.2 Key Approaches (WWI)
Analyzing the World Wars
A Level/AS Level/O Level
History Notes
Your Burning Questions Answered!
Assess the extent to which the centenary of the First World War challenged the traditional focus on motive in understanding the causes of the war, and emphasized the role of contingency.
Discuss how the centenary prompted historians to reconsider the significance of decision-making and leadership in the outbreak of the First World War, and shifted their attention towards systemic factors and the interplay of events.
Evaluate the impact of the centenary on the historiography of the First World War, and explain how it led to a more contextualized and nuanced understanding of the conflict.
Analyze the ways in which the centenary of the First World War influenced the study of military history, and led to a greater emphasis on the role of technology, logistics, and the impact of war on civilians.
Discuss the historiographical debates surrounding the centenary of the First World War, and explore how these debates have shaped our current understanding of the causes and consequences of the conflict.
History Study Pack Required!
How the centenary of the First World War affected the debate: the importance of contingency over motive
Chapter 12: Analyzing the World Wars
#12.2 Key Approaches (WWI)
1. The Impact of the Centenary of WWI
The centenary of the First World War (2014) sparked a renewed interest in the conflict and its lasting consequences. This anniversary provided a platform for historians to reflect on existing scholarship and explore new perspectives. One significant influence was the growing emphasis on contingency over motive in understanding the causes of the war.
2. Contingency vs. Motive
- Motive: This approach focuses on the intentions of key players and their desire to achieve certain objectives. For example, historians might analyze Germany's ambition for power and expansionism as a leading motive for the war.
- Contingency: This approach emphasizes the role of chance events and the unforeseen consequences of decisions. It acknowledges that the outbreak of war was not a predetermined outcome but rather a product of a series of complex and unpredictable circumstances.
3. The Shift Towards Contingency
The centenary of WWI saw a shift in historical analysis. Historians began to recognize the significance of minor decisions, miscalculations, and chance events that played a crucial role in escalating the crisis.
Examples of Contingency:
- The Assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand
- The death of the heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne was not initially seen as a major catalyst for war. However, the assassination triggered a chain reaction of events, including Austria-Hungary's ultimatum to Serbia and the subsequent mobilization of the European powers.
- The Schlieffen Plan
- Germany's war plan aimed to quickly defeat France and then focus on Russia. However, the plan failed due to logistical challenges, miscommunication, and the resilience of the French army. This failure led to a protracted war on the Western Front, with devastating consequences.
4. The Importance of Contingency
Understanding the impact of contingency emphasizes that war was not an inevitable outcome. The actions and decisions of individuals, along with unforeseen events, played a crucial role in shaping the course of events. This approach helps us:
- Avoid Determinism: It prevents us from assuming that history was predetermined and that certain events were inevitable.
- Appreciate Complexity: It recognizes the intricate web of causes and effects that led to war.
- Learn from the Past: By acknowledging the role of chance, we can better understand how seemingly minor events can have significant consequences and avoid similar mistakes in the future.
5. Conclusion
The centenary of the First World War brought a renewed focus on contingency in understanding the conflict. By emphasizing the role of chance events and unforeseen consequences, historians have gained a deeper understanding of the complexities of the conflict and its lasting impact on the world. This approach encourages a more nuanced and critical analysis of history, allowing us to learn from past mistakes and explore the myriad possibilities that existed in the past.
Crack History Exams With Confidence!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive History Study Pack.
Get instant access to a wealth of resources designed to help you thrive and achieve top grades!
What’s Inside?
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
Take Action Now!
Don’t let exam stress hold you back. Equip yourself with the tools you need to succeed.