‘Cultural differences between people are disappearing as a result of globalisation.’ Evaluate this view
CAMBRIDGE
A level and AS level
2023
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Briefly introduce globalization and its impact on culture. State your stance on whether cultural differences are disappearing due to globalization.
Arguments For Cultural Convergence
Growing Interconnectivity: Discuss how global communication and travel facilitate the rapid spread of ideas and cultural products. Westernization and Homogenization: Explain the concept of cultural homogenization, citing examples like the dominance of Western media and consumer culture. Global Language and Icons: Address the increasing use of English as a global language and the rise of global celebrities.
Arguments Against Cultural Convergence
Cultural Diversity and Hybridity: Emphasize the persistence of cultural differences and the emergence of hybrid cultures through global interactions. Localization and Adaptation: Discuss how global cultural elements are often modified and adapted to fit local contexts. Cultural Revival and Resistance: Highlight the resurgence of local traditions and national identities as a response to globalization.
Conclusion
Summarize the main arguments presented and restate your evaluated stance on the impact of globalization on cultural differences.
Is Cultural Homogeneity an Inevitable Consequence of Globalisation?
Globalisation, the increasing interconnectedness of societies, has sparked debate about its impact on cultural diversity. While some argue that globalisation fosters cultural convergence, leading to a homogenised global culture, others contend that it encourages diversity and hybridity. This essay will critically evaluate the view that cultural differences are disappearing due to globalisation.
The Case for Cultural Convergence
Proponents of cultural convergence highlight several trends supporting their view. Firstly, the rise of global media conglomerates, as highlighted by Martell, has facilitated the widespread dissemination of Western cultural products, particularly music, film, and television. This, coupled with the pervasiveness of Western consumer culture, fuelled by global markets and trading networks, has led to the popularisation of Western values and lifestyles, particularly among younger generations. This phenomenon is often referred to as "Westernisation" or "Americanisation".
Furthermore, the dominance of English as the language of international trade and global communication reinforces cultural convergence. As English becomes increasingly indispensable for economic and social mobility, other languages may decline, leading to a loss of cultural diversity. The prediction that half of the world's languages could disappear by the end of the 21st century underscores this concern.
The global reach of celebrities, primarily from Western entertainment and sports industries, also contributes to the perception of cultural homogenisation. These figures serve as global cultural icons, shaping tastes and aspirations across borders.
Challenging the Convergence Narrative
However, the notion of a monolithic global culture driven by globalisation overlooks the complexities of cultural exchange. While globalisation facilitates the flow of cultural products and ideas, it also fosters cultural hybridity. Global tourism, migration, and trade expose individuals to a wider range of cultures, leading to the fusion and adaptation of cultural elements. Steger refers to this process as "cultural hybridity," where elements from different cultures are blended, creating new and dynamic forms.
Global corporations, often seen as agents of homogenisation, are increasingly embracing cultural diversity to enhance their products' appeal. For instance, the incorporation of Bollywood elements in Hollywood films illustrates this trend. This adaptation and appropriation of local cultural elements demonstrate a recognition of the economic and creative potential of cultural diversity.
Moreover, globalisation can invigorate local cultures. The perceived threat of cultural homogenisation has triggered a resurgence of interest in preserving and revitalising local traditions and values. Fundamentalist movements and nationalist sentiments, while often viewed negatively, demonstrate a resistance to cultural homogenisation and a desire to protect cultural identity.
Conclusion
While globalisation undoubtedly influences cultural exchange, it is simplistic to assert that cultural differences are disappearing. While Western cultural products and values hold significant influence, the reality is far more nuanced. Globalisation fosters cultural hybridity, encourages the adaptation of global trends to local contexts, and can even stimulate a renewed appreciation for local traditions. Therefore, rather than leading to cultural homogeneity, globalisation is creating a complex and dynamic cultural landscape characterised by both convergence and divergence.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
Cultural differences between people are disappearing as a result of globalisation. Evaluate this view.
The question invites discussion of the cultural impact of globalisation. Good answers will demonstrate knowledge of the view that differences in lifestyles and values between people are disappearing as societies become more integrated globally. This process is often referred to as ‘cultural convergence’.
One version of the cultural convergence perspective argues that globalisation has brought about a one-way flow of culture from the West to the less economically developed countries. A process of Westernisation (or Americanisation) has occurred whereby local cultures become less valued by people in poorer countries who come to Explain increasingly with the same values and lifestyles that are found in rich capitalist countries such as the US and Western Europe. However, tranformationalist and postmodernist theories of globalisation argue that the idea of cultural convergence exaggerates the impact of globalisation and fails to acknowledge how Western culture is enriched by inputs from other world cultures and religions. In this view, globalisation is actually producing greater cultural diversity, both by exposing more people to different cultures and through localisation (a process whereby cultural influences from other countries are modified and adapted to local culture and needs).
Good answers will set out the arguments for suggesting that globalisation is leading to cultural convergence and offer an evaluation that is likely to draw contrasts between the cultural convergence and the cultural divergence perspectives.
For:
- There is clearly a growing engagement and communication between societies wherever they are located in the world and regardless of what language they speak. This means that the conditions are in place for the rapid movement of ideas, attitudes, meanings, values and cultural products across national borders. - Martell argues that global processes are sweeping away significant territorial boundaries and bringing about the global homogenisation of cultural tastes. - Powerful media conglomerates have established global networks to transmit their products to all corners of the world. - Global markets and trading networks have spread Western consumer culture to most parts of the world and an interest in products, brands, and materialistic lifestyles is undermining the appeal of local cultures to young people in particular. - Leisure habits in many parts of the world are increasingly shaped by a global popular culture disseminated by global media that specialises in distributing the same music, television, film, computer games, and video to a global audience. - Globalisation has contributed to the dominance of English as the universal language of international trade and global culture. It is predicted that at least 50% of languages spoken in the world in 2018 will have disappeared by the end of the 21st century. - Cultural icons are increasingly global celebrities, including pop stars, sports stars, and movie stars.
Against:
- The extent to which the world is characterised by cultural homogeneity today can be questioned; there are still considerable differences between cultures and countries, and the extent to which different parts of the world are affected by the processes of globalisation varies (some people and countries are more connected to global networks than others). - Global tourism, travel, migration and trade have all contributed to a situation where people are exposed to a wider variety of cultural influences today. Elements of different cultures are increasingly combined together (what Steger refers to as ‘cultural hybridity’). - Global corporations have seized the opportunity to strengthen the appeal of their products and services by incorporating attractive elements from different cultures around the world (aspects of Bollywood incorporated in Hollywood films, for example). - Local people modify and adapt elements of global culture to strengthen and enhance local cultures. - Globalisation may also have led to a revival or reinvigoration of some cultural forms. For example, traditional social values have been reasserted by fundamentalist movements opposed to the influence of globalisation. A resurgence of nationalism and interest in national cultures is another response by those who feel threatened by the globalising forces.