top of page
Previous
Next Essay

Discuss how far sociologists would agree that families are the main agent of socialisation.

AQA

GCSE

2019

👑Complete Model Essay

Free Essay Plan

Discuss how far sociologists would agree that families are the main agent of socialisation.

Introduction

Define socialisation. Briefly introduce the family as a primary agent of socialisation and other agencies such as peers and education. Outline the debate - sociologists disagree on the extent to which the family is the main agent.

Functionalism

Functionalists like Parsons see the family as the primary agent. Explain Parsons' idea of primary socialisation and the stabilisation of adult personalities.

Analysis and Evaluation of Functionalist Theories

Evaluate Parsons - Are families always harmonious? Do they always transmit shared values? Consider the impact of social change - are families as traditionally functional as Parsons suggests?

Feminism

Feminists like Oakley challenge the functionalist view. Explain how families contribute to gender socialisation and the patriarchal nature of society through canalisation, manipulation, etc.

Analysis and Evaluation of Feminist Theories

How significant are Oakley's findings today? Consider changes in family structures and the position of women in society. Have feminist ideas led to changes in socialisation patterns within families?

Marxism

Explain how Marxists like Zaretsky view the family as serving the needs of capitalism. Explain the family as a unit of consumption and how this benefits capitalism.

Analysis and Evaluation of Marxist Theories

Consider if Zaretsky's arguments are outdated. Does the family primarily serve the interests of capitalism today? Consider the role of the media and advertising.

Alternative Agencies of Socialisation

Discuss the role of education - the formal and hidden curriculum. Discuss the role of peer groups - peer pressure and conformity. Discuss the impact of the mass media and social media on socialisation.

Analysis and Evaluation of the Significance of Other Agents of Socialisation

Evaluate the relative importance of these alternative agents compared to the family. How significant is the influence of the media, especially in an age of digital technology? Consider whether these alternative agents can ever fully replace the family.

Changes in the Significance of the Family

Discuss changes in family structures, e.g., single-parent families, reconstituted families, and same-sex families. How might these impact socialisation? Consider the impact of geographical mobility and increased individualism.

Conclusion

Summarise the different sociological perspectives on the family as an agent of socialisation. To what extent is the family still the main agent? Acknowledge the complexity of the issue and the variety of factors influencing socialisation today. Offer a balanced conclusion highlighting the interplay between families and other agents in shaping individuals.

## How Far Do Sociologists Agree That Families Are The Main Agent Of Socialisation? ## Introduction Socialisation is the lifelong process through which individuals learn the norms, values, beliefs, and behaviours of their society. It shapes individuals into functioning members of their social groups. The family, as a primary agent of socialisation, plays a crucial role in this process, particularly during childhood. However, other agents like peer groups, education, and the media also significantly influence socialisation. While sociologists agree on the family's importance, they debate the extent to which it remains the *main* agent in contemporary society. ## Functionalism Functionalists, like Parsons, argue that the family is the primary and most influential agent of socialisation. Parsons saw the family as a vital subsystem within society, responsible for primary socialisation. This is where children learn fundamental values and norms, like language, basic skills, and moral codes, which are essential for social stability. He argued that families provide a stable and emotionally secure environment for this learning to occur and that successful primary socialisation is crucial for the stabilisation of adult personalities and the smooth functioning of society. ## Analysis and Evaluation of Functionalist Theories While Parsons highlights the family's importance, his view can be criticized as idealized and outdated. He assumes families are always harmonious and transmit shared values, neglecting the existence of conflict, abuse, and diverse family forms. Parsons also downplays the impact of social change, such as increased family diversity and the changing roles of women, on the family's function as a socialising agent. In contemporary society, the family's role may be less clear-cut than Parsons suggests. ## Feminism Feminists, such as Ann Oakley, challenge the functionalist view of the family as a harmonious unit. They argue that families are often characterized by patriarchal structures that contribute to gender inequality. Through processes like canalisation (directing children towards gender-specific toys and activities) and manipulation (encouraging behaviour deemed appropriate for their gender), families play a key role in instilling gender roles and perpetuating the patriarchal nature of society. ## Analysis and Evaluation of Feminist Theories Oakley's work remains highly relevant today, as gender socialization within families is still a significant area of study. However, it's important to acknowledge the impact of changing family structures and the position of women in society. With increasing female workforce participation and changing family dynamics, gender socialization processes might be evolving. It's debatable whether feminist ideas have significantly altered these patterns within families, though they have certainly raised awareness and encouraged more egalitarian approaches to child-rearing. ## Marxism Marxists, like Zaretsky, view the family as serving the needs of capitalism. They argue that families act as units of consumption, buying goods and services that support capitalist industries. This benefits capitalism by creating a constant demand for products. Furthermore, Zaretsky argues that the family provides a haven from the exploitative world of work, allowing individuals to emotionally recharge and return to the workforce more readily. ## Analysis and Evaluation of Marxist Theories While Zaretsky’s emphasis on consumption remains relevant, it can be argued that his view is somewhat outdated. The family's role in consumption has become more complex with the rise of the media and advertising, which exert significant influence on consumer choices, sometimes even superseding family influence. Therefore, while families remain important consumers, their role in serving the interests of capitalism might be less straightforward than Zaretsky suggests. ## Alternative Agencies of Socialisation Beyond the family, numerous other agents contribute to socialisation. Education, with its formal curriculum and hidden curriculum of norms and values, plays a significant role in shaping individuals. Peer groups exert pressure to conform, influencing attitudes, behaviours, and risk-taking. The mass media, particularly social media, plays a powerful role in shaping perceptions, values, and identities, contributing to the development of social norms and trends. ## Analysis and Evaluation of the Significance of Other Agents of Socialisation The relative influence of these agents compared to the family is a complex issue. While the family lays the foundation, other agents become increasingly significant as individuals navigate adolescence and adulthood. The media, especially in the digital age, plays a particularly powerful role, often competing with or reinforcing familial values. However, arguing that these agents can entirely replace the family’s importance, particularly in early childhood, is debatable. ## Changes in the Significance of the Family Modern society has witnessed significant changes in family structures, including the rise of single-parent families, blended families, and same-sex families. These changes raise questions about how socialisation processes might be affected. Moreover, geographical mobility and increased individualism can weaken traditional family ties and potentially diminish the family's influence compared to other agents. ## Conclusion While sociologists acknowledge the family's significant role in socialisation, the extent to which it remains the *main* agent is open to debate. Functionalists emphasize its crucial role in transmitting essential norms and values, while feminists highlight its role in perpetuating gender inequality and Marxists in supporting capitalist structures. However, the increasing influence of alternate agents like education, peer groups, and especially the media, coupled with evolving family structures, suggests a more complex picture. While the family continues to be a powerful force, it operates within a network of influential agents, highlighting the multifaceted nature of socialisation in contemporary society.
Discuss how far sociologists would agree that families are the main agent of socialisation.

Free Mark Scheme Extracts

Families as an Agency of Socialisation

This topic explores the role of families in shaping individuals and examines how different sociological perspectives understand this process. We will delve into key theories and their critiques, considering the influence of alternative agencies of socialisation and the evolving significance of the family in modern society.

Key Sociological Perspectives

We will examine the following perspectives:

  • Functionalism
  • Feminism
  • Marxism

Functionalist Perspectives on Families

Functionalists view families as essential for social stability and the smooth functioning of society. They argue that families play a crucial role in the process of primary socialisation, teaching children the basic norms, values, and skills they need to become functioning members of society.

Parsons' functionalist account highlights the family's role in providing warmth, affection, and emotional support, as well as the essential skills for effective functioning in society.

Feminist Perspectives on Families

Feminist perspectives argue that families often contribute to the perpetuation of patriarchy, a system that maintains male dominance and female subordination. Feminist theorists highlight the ways in which traditional gender roles are socialised within families, often reinforcing inequalities between men and women.

Oakley's work provides evidence for how gender roles are instilled through socialisation processes within families, contributing to gender inequalities.

Marxist Perspectives on Families

Marxist perspectives see families as units of consumption that support the capitalist system. They argue that families are socialised to desire and consume goods and services, thereby fuelling economic growth and profit for the capitalist class.

Zaretsky's argument suggests that families act as a buffer against the alienating and exploitative nature of capitalist work, providing a space for emotional support and personal fulfilment.

Alternative Agencies of Socialisation

In addition to families, other institutions play a crucial role in socialisation, including:

  • The education system
  • The mass media
  • Social media

The Changing Significance of the Family

We will explore the evidence for and against the idea that the family's role as an agent of socialisation is diminishing in contemporary society. This includes examining the impact of:

  • Increased female employment
  • The rise of single-parent families
  • The growing influence of alternative socialisation agents

Analysis and Evaluation

We will critically analyse and evaluate the different theoretical perspectives, considering the strengths and weaknesses of each approach. This includes:

  • The extent to which Parsons' functionalist view remains relevant today
  • The significance of Oakley's feminist critique
  • The enduring relevance of Zaretsky's Marxist analysis
  • The role of the mass media and social media in shaping contemporary socialisation processes
bottom of page