Discuss how far sociologists would agree that gender inequalities continue to exist within the family in Britain today.
AQA
GCSE
2021
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Start with a hook to grab the reader's attention. Briefly introduce the topic of gender inequalities within the family.
State your line of argument: While societal changes suggest a move towards greater equality, sociologists would largely agree that gender inequalities persist within the British family, albeit in evolving forms.
Feminist Perspectives
Explain the core argument: Feminists argue that the family is a patriarchal institution that perpetuates gender inequalities.
- Patriarchy and the Domestic Sphere: Discuss how feminists view the home as a site of female oppression, with women bearing the brunt of domestic labour and childcare.
- Unequal Division of Labour: Provide evidence of this unequal division, even in dual-earner households (refer to Oakley's study, for example).
- Triple Shift and Emotional Labour: Explore the concepts of the "triple shift" (paid work, housework, and emotional labour) and how they disproportionately impact women.
Functionalist and Marxist Perspectives - Contrasting Views
Functionalism:
- Symmetrical Family: Explain Willmott and Young's theory of the symmetrical family and its suggestion of shared conjugal roles.
- Critique of Symmetry: Critically evaluate this theory – has it come to fruition? Point to evidence that challenges the idea of a truly equal division of labour.
Marxism:
- Family as a Unit of Consumption: Explain how Marxists view the family's role in supporting capitalism - women's unpaid labour maintains the workforce.
- Ideological Control: Discuss how the family perpetuates traditional gender roles that serve capitalist interests.
- Critique of Marxism: Acknowledge the limitations of this perspective – does it fully account for agency and variations in family life?
Changing Family Structures and Gender Roles
Acknowledge the Shifts:
- Dual-Earner Families: Discuss the rise in dual-earner families and its implications for gender roles.
- The “New Man”: Explore the concept of the "New Man" who actively shares domestic work and childcare. To what extent does this reflect reality?
- Divorce and Changing Family Forms: Analyze the impact of divorce and changing family structures on gender roles and inequalities.
Changing Position of Women in Society
Progress and Limitations:
- Legal Changes: Highlight key legal changes that have advanced women's rights (e.g., equal pay legislation, maternity/paternity leave).
- Employment Opportunities: Discuss the increase in women's employment opportunities. However, acknowledge persistent inequalities (e.g., the gender pay gap, occupational segregation).
- The Feminist Movement: Explain how feminism has challenged traditional gender roles and raised awareness of inequalities.
Analysis and Evaluation
Synthesize the Arguments:
- Persistence of Inequality: Present evidence that supports the continued existence of gender inequalities within the family (e.g., statistics on the division of labour, the gender pay gap).
- Evolving Nature of Inequality: However, acknowledge that these inequalities may be manifesting in new ways (e.g., the mental load of housework, expectations around emotional labour).
- Intersectionality: Stress the importance of considering how gender intersects with other social factors (class, race, sexuality) to produce diverse experiences of family life.
Conclusion
Restate your Argument: Sociologists largely agree that gender inequalities persist within the British family. While progress has been made, traditional gender norms and patriarchal structures remain influential.
Offer a Final Thought: Conclude with a thought-provoking statement about the future of gender relations within the family, considering the impact of ongoing social changes.
Gender Inequality in the British Family: A Sociological Perspective
This essay will examine the ongoing debate among sociologists regarding the persistence of gender inequalities within the contemporary British family. While societal shifts have undoubtedly occurred, perspectives diverge on the extent to which these changes have eradicated traditional gender imbalances.
Feminist Perspectives: Patriarchy and the Family
Feminist sociologists argue that the family unit remains a site of significant gender inequality. They point to the enduring nature of patriarchy – a system that privileges men and masculinity – which manifests in unequal divisions of labor within the household.
Research consistently shows that women continue to shoulder a disproportionate burden of unpaid domestic work, including childcare and housework. This "double shift" – paid work followed by unpaid domestic labor – leaves women with less leisure time and contributes to their economic disadvantage.
Functionalist Perspectives: The Symmetrical Family
In contrast, functionalist sociologists like Willmott and Young argue that the family has undergone a process of "symmetrization." They suggest that traditional, segregated roles are being replaced by more shared and egalitarian partnerships, particularly in the middle classes.
This perspective emphasizes the increasing participation of women in the workforce and the growing willingness of men to share domestic responsibilities. However, critics argue that functionalists underestimate the persistence of unequal power dynamics within the family and overlook the fact that significant gendered divisions of labor remain.
Marxist Perspectives: Capitalism and the Family
From a Marxist perspective, gender inequalities within the family are seen as integral to the functioning of capitalist societies. They posit that women's unpaid domestic labor is essential for maintaining a healthy and productive workforce, ultimately benefiting capitalist interests.
This perspective also highlights the role of the family in reproducing social inequalities. The transmission of wealth, cultural capital, and social networks across generations often reinforces existing gender disparities.
Changing Family Structures and the "New Man"
The rise of dual-career families, single-parent households, and same-sex partnerships has led some to argue for a decline in the significance of traditional gender roles. The concept of the "New Man" – a figure who embraces shared parenting and domestic responsibilities – has gained traction.
However, evidence suggests that the "New Man" remains somewhat elusive. While men's contributions to domestic work have increased, they still lag behind women's. Furthermore, societal expectations and traditional gender norms continue to influence family dynamics.
Women's Changing Position in Society
Undoubtedly, women's position in society has undergone significant transformation. Legal reforms, such as the Equal Pay Act and the Sex Discrimination Act, have sought to address gender inequality in the workplace.
Increased educational and employment opportunities have empowered women and challenged traditional gender norms. However, despite these advancements, a gender pay gap persists, and women remain underrepresented in positions of power.
Conclusion
Sociologists are unlikely to reach a definitive consensus on the extent to which gender inequalities continue to exist within the family. While feminist perspectives highlight the enduring nature of patriarchy and the unequal division of labor, functionalists point to the emergence of more symmetrical family structures. Marxists, meanwhile, emphasize the role of capitalism in perpetuating gender inequalities.
Evidence suggests that while progress has been made in challenging traditional gender roles, significant inequalities persist. The persistence of the gender pay gap, the unequal division of domestic labor, and the underrepresentation of women in positions of power all point to the ongoing need for social change to achieve true gender equality within the family and wider society.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
Family Structures and Gender Roles
This topic explores the interplay between family structures, gender roles, and societal changes, drawing on key sociological perspectives.
Key Concepts
- Feminism
- Functionalism
- Marxism
- Changing family structures
- Changing position of women in society
Theoretical Perspectives
Feminist Perspectives
Feminist perspectives emphasize the patriarchal nature of the family, highlighting the exploitation of women within the home. This includes the unequal gender division of labor, where women often bear the brunt of domestic responsibilities.
Functionalist Perspectives
Functionalists focus on the significance of the symmetrical family, as researched by Willmott and Young. They suggest a trend towards shared conjugal roles, with both partners contributing equally to household duties and childcare.
Marxist Perspectives
Marxist perspectives argue that women and men have unequal roles within the family because this structure supports capitalism. Women who stay at home, performing unpaid housework and emotional work, are seen as contributing to capitalist society by providing healthy, happy workers.
Contemporary Trends
The movement towards dual-career families and the concept of the "New Man," who actively participates in domestic responsibilities, reflect evolving family structures and gender roles.
Changes in women's legal status and employment opportunities have also contributed to a shift in gender relations, providing women with greater rights and career prospects.
Analysis and Evaluation
- Feminist Perspective: Analysis of the extent to which gender inequalities exist within the family.
- Functionalist Perspective: Evaluating the extent to which there has been a rise in the symmetrical family.
- Marxist Perspective: Examination of the extent to which the family supports capitalism.
- Changes in Family Structures and Gender Roles: Analysing the prevalence of the "New Man" and the impact of these changes.
- Changes in Women's Position in Society: Evaluating the extent of gender equality in society, focusing on legal rights and employment opportunities.
Evidence-Based Judgments and Conclusions
Evidence-based judgements and conclusions should address the following:
- How far do sociologists agree on the extent of gender inequalities within the family?
- To what extent does the evidence support the premise that gender inequalities still exist in the family in Britain today?
This analysis requires a critical examination of existing research findings, societal trends, and the perspectives of different sociological theories.