3. Evaluate the sociological view that all digital forms of communication have a negative impact on social relationships.
OCR
A Level
2020
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Essay Outline: Evaluating the Negative Impact of Digital Communication on Social Relationships
This essay will evaluate the sociological view that all digital forms of communication have a negative impact on social relationships. It will explore arguments both supporting and challenging this perspective, drawing upon relevant sociological studies and contemporary examples.
AO1: Knowledge and Understanding
Arguments Supporting Negative Impact
• "Alone Together" Phenomenon: Sherry Turkle's work highlights the potential for digital communication to create a paradox of "alone together," where individuals are physically present but emotionally disconnected due to their engagement with digital devices. This can lead to a decline in face-to-face interaction and a superficiality in relationships.
• Weakening of Offline Relationships: Studies, such as those by Kraut, suggest that excessive time spent online can negatively impact offline relationships. Individuals may neglect their real-world connections, prioritizing virtual interactions, which can lead to feelings of isolation and resentment.
• Conflict and Tension: Social media platforms are often associated with the potential for conflict and tension. The public nature of online communication can lead to misunderstandings, the spread of misinformation, and cyberbullying, all of which can damage relationships.
• Disadvantages for Certain Groups: Lack of access to smartphones and the internet can create a digital divide, particularly affecting children from disadvantaged backgrounds. This can lead to feelings of isolation and exclusion from peer groups, potentially impacting their social integration.
• Social Media Footprints and Privacy Concerns: The permanent nature of online information raises concerns about privacy and social control. The potential for past mistakes to resurface and the exploitation of private information can create anxiety and damage trust in relationships.
Arguments Challenging Negative Impact
• Strengthening of Existing Bonds: Digital communication can facilitate easier and more frequent communication for families and friends, overcoming geographical barriers. The ability to stay connected across distances can strengthen relationships and make it easier to maintain contact.
• Pandemic-Era Resilience: During the COVID-19 pandemic, digital communication played a crucial role in maintaining social connections during lockdowns. This demonstrates how it can act as a vital lifeline, especially during challenging times.
• New Opportunities for Social Interaction: Social media platforms can create new opportunities for forming and nurturing relationships. Individuals can connect with like-minded people around the world, expand their social networks, and find support from communities. This can be particularly beneficial for people who face traditional barriers to social interaction.
• Increased Social Capital: Social networking can contribute to higher social capital by connecting individuals with diverse groups and promoting collaborative behavior. This can lead to a sense of community and shared purpose.
• Mental Health Benefits: Digital platforms can also provide access to social support networks and offer resources for mental health well-being. The ability to connect with others online can reduce feelings of loneliness and isolation and provide a sense of belonging.
AO2: Application
The arguments presented in AO1 should be directly applied to the question. For example, Turkle's research on "alone together" can be linked to the potential for digital communication to create a disconnect between partners or family members who are physically present but distracted by their devices.
AO3: Analysis and Evaluation
• Nuance and Complexity: The impact of digital communication on social relationships is not simply positive or negative. It is important to acknowledge the complex interplay of factors, including the individual, the type of communication, the context, and the specific platform or technology used.
• Contemporary Examples: The essay should utilize contemporary examples to illustrate the arguments. For instance, the rise of "Twitter-related conflict" (Clayton) can be used to support the claim that digital communication can have detrimental effects on relationships, particularly in the context of romantic partnerships.
• Limitations and Alternative Perspectives: The essay should acknowledge the limitations of existing research and consider alternative perspectives. For example, while some studies point to the negative effects of social media on well-being, others argue that these effects are often exaggerated or influenced by other factors.
• Conclusion: The essay should conclude with a balanced evaluation of the sociological view, acknowledging the potential both for negative and positive impacts of digital communication on social relationships. It should highlight the need for a nuanced understanding of the complex interplay of factors involved.
Evaluate the sociological view that all digital forms of communication have a negative impact on social relationships.
This essay will evaluate the view that digital communication has an entirely negative impact on social relationships. While there is evidence to suggest that overuse of social media can have detrimental impacts on the quality of our relationships, technological advancements have also provided us with new ways to connect with others in an increasingly globalised world, and arguebly strengthened pre-existing ties.
Negative Impacts of Digital Communication
Concerns have been raised regarding the potential for digital communication to have a negative impact on our relationships, leading to weaker social ties and conflict. Turkle (2015) argues that the presence of devices within family settings can lead to family members becoming ‘alone together’, physically present but emotionally checked out of family interactions. Similarly, Kraut (1998) highlights that online social ties tend to be weaker than relationships formed offline, suggesting that excessive reliance on digital communication may lead to superficial connections and a decline in close relationships.
Furthermore, the very nature of social media can exacerbate tensions. The pursuit of online validation and carefully crafted online personas can lead to feelings of inadequacy and envy, negatively impacting self-esteem and relationships. This is particularly relevant in the case of young people, who may be more susceptible to social comparison and the pressure to present a perfect online image. This pressure is amplified by the permanence of the digital footprint; as argued by Case (2015), mistakes made online are difficult to erase and can have long-lasting impacts on an individual's social standing and relationships.
The accessibility and ease of communication afforded by digital platforms can also have a darker side. Cases of cyberbullying and online harassment highlight the potential for digital communication to facilitate the infliction of emotional harm. The anonymity provided by certain online spaces can embolden individuals to engage in behaviours they might not otherwise engage in face-to-face, leading to the breakdown of relationships and significant emotional distress.
Positive Impact of Digital Communication on Social Relationships
While the potential downsides of digital communication are undeniable, it is important to acknowledge the positive impact digital communication has had on maintaining and strengthening social connections. The ability to connect with friends and family regardless of geographical location is perhaps the most significant advantage of the digital age. This has been particularly important for individuals who have moved away from loved ones for work or personal reasons, allowing them to maintain close bonds despite physical distance.
The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent lockdowns highlighted the essential role of digital communication in maintaining our social lives. Platforms such as Zoom and Skype provided a lifeline for people to connect with loved ones during a period of unprecedented isolation. This was particularly important for vulnerable individuals who were shielding and reliant on digital communication for social interaction and support.
Furthermore, the rise of social media has created opportunities to connect with like-minded individuals and form new relationships based on shared interests, hobbies, and values. Online communities can provide a sense of belonging and support, particularly for individuals who may feel isolated or marginalised in their offline lives.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the impact of digital communication on social relationships is complex and multifaceted. While excessive use of social media and the potential for online conflict cannot be ignored, it is important to recognise that digital communication has also had a positive impact on how we connect with others. Ultimately, a balanced approach to technology use, coupled with an awareness of the potential pitfalls, is crucial for harnessing the benefits of digital communication while mitigating its negative impacts on our relationships.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
AO1: Knowledge and Understanding
NOTE: Contemporary examples should be credited in AO1 in the same way as sociological studies.
Relevant material supporting the view that all digital forms of communications have a negative impact on social relationships may include:
- Families/ friends may be ‘alone together’ – in the same room but using devices to communicate with others or engage in other tasks; Turkle
- Offline relationships may suffer as a result of time spent with online relationships
- Online social ties tend to be weaker than relationships formed and maintained offline; Kraut
- Social media potential to cause tension and conflict between individuals
- Solitary activities – e.g. such as surfing the internet, negative impact on social ties; Zhao
- Lack of privacy or different ideas about privacy may cause conflict
- Children who cannot afford smartphones or access to internet; disadvantaged in peer interaction in all countries including UK; Berry
- Social media footprints - harder for adolescents today to remove mistakes; Case, Ellison.
- Disputes can occur when private information disclosed on line; Case
- Social networking sites can expose the unfaithful: dynamic of the news being ‘public’ can have an negative impact on relationships; Miller
- ‘Twitter-related conflict’ can have negative impact on relationships: emotional and physical cheating, breakup and divorce; Clayton
- Problem if people believe the truth of another lies more in what is posted online than face-to-face communication; Miller
- Other reasonable response.
AO2: Application
The selected knowledge should be directly specific to the question - view that all digital forms of communication have a negative impact on social relationships.
AO3: Analysis and Evaluation
NOTE: Contemporary examples should be credited in AO3 in the same way as sociological studies.
Relevant material challenging the view that all digital forms of communications have a negative impact on social relationships may include:
- Digital forms of communication have helped strengthen relationships between family and friends as time and location no longer presents a barrier to maintaining contact.
- During the coronavirus pandemic and lockdown, digital communication allowed friends and family to maintain their relationships.
- Older generation may use social media to maintain contact with family here and abroad; Berry
- Social media platforms that connect individuals directly to one another such as Zoom, Snapchat, Instagram strengthen relationships; Zhao
- Social networks can lead to stronger social relationships and cooperative behaviour may increase; Christakis.
- New social media can help develop more meaningful/developed relationships; Miller
- Through social media, young people can send messages to others, share photographs, videos across the world at the press of a button; Boyle, Boellstorff.
- Opportunity to increase social capital in relationships with a wide group of people; Bourdieu, Boyle
- Can help decrease loneliness and depression and increase self-esteem through access to social support 24/7; Shaw and Gant
- Social networking provides opportunities to overcome traditional barriers to meeting people such as disability, geographical distance, family disapproval.
- Women may use communication technology to engage with and form relationships with women from across the world; Haraway, Nakumara.
- Young people may broaden and strengthen relationships with other young people; Boyle
- Weak ties are strengthened; Granovetter
- Other reasonable response.