*In what ways are victim surveys a useful measurement of crime?*
OCR
A Level
2021
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Victim Surveys: A Useful Measurement of Crime
This essay will explore the various ways in which victim surveys provide a valuable tool for measuring crime. It will examine the advantages they offer over official police statistics, focusing on their ability to shed light on the "dark figure of crime" and provide insights into the impact of crime on individuals and society.
AO1: Knowledge and Understanding
Alternative Measurement of Crime
Victim surveys offer an alternative method for measuring crime, by directly surveying individuals about their experiences of crime within a specific period. This approach complements official police-recorded statistics, providing a broader and more comprehensive picture of the crime landscape.
Illuminating the "Dark Figure of Crime"
A significant advantage of victim surveys lies in their ability to uncover the "dark figure of crime" – crimes that are not reported to the police. This hidden aspect of crime remains undetected by official statistics, and victim surveys provide a valuable means of uncovering this concealed reality.
The CSEW: A Comprehensive Study
The Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) stands as the largest victim survey conducted in the UK, commissioned by the Home Office. This survey employs face-to-face, structured interviews to gather data from a representative sample of adults and children, enabling generalization of findings. The CSEW has been particularly successful in estimating the extent of domestic violence, an area often underreported to the police.
Beyond Police Statistics: Exploring Attitudes and Experiences
Unlike police statistics, which primarily focus on reported incidents, victim surveys allow for a deeper understanding of crime by incorporating questions about individuals' attitudes towards crime-related topics, such as anti-social behaviour. This provides a more holistic perspective on the impact of crime on society.
Confidentiality and Encouraging Disclosure
The confidentiality guaranteed by victim surveys encourages individuals to disclose their experiences of crime, even those they may have not reported to the police. This anonymity fosters trust and allows for a more accurate assessment of victimization levels.
Qualitative Insights from Local Surveys
Beyond national surveys like the CSEW, localized victim surveys, such as the Islington Crime Surveys, have utilized unstructured interviews to gather in-depth qualitative data about victims' experiences. This rich data has provided valuable insights into the nature of crime and its impact on individuals.
Impact on Sociological Perspectives
The findings from Islington and Merseyside Crime Surveys, especially their focus on the impact of crime on vulnerable groups, have informed Left Realist perspectives on crime. These surveys emphasized the need to address the social and economic factors contributing to crime, highlighting the impact on individuals' lives.
Feminist Perspectives on Crime
Victim surveys have played a crucial role in informing feminist perspectives on crime, particularly regarding gender-based violence. The Islington Survey revealed higher rates of female victimization in sexual and domestic offences compared to police statistics, supporting feminist arguments about the prevalence of patriarchal structures contributing to violence against women.
Raising Awareness about Fear of Crime
Data from victim surveys has been instrumental in raising awareness about the impact of fear of crime on individuals' lives. Both Left Realist and feminist scholars have drawn on this evidence to advocate for policies that address the anxieties and concerns of citizens, particularly those who feel vulnerable to crime.
Enhancing Understanding of Crime Patterns
Insights gained from victim surveys can be used to supplement information collected through police recorded statistics, leading to a richer understanding of crime patterns. By cross-referencing data from both sources, researchers can gain a more comprehensive and nuanced view of the nature and extent of crime within a specific community or region.
AO2: Application
The information presented above demonstrates the diverse ways in which victim surveys provide valuable insights into the crime landscape. They offer a unique perspective by illuminating the "dark figure of crime," gathering qualitative data on victims' experiences, and providing information on attitudes towards crime. This data can be used to inform policy decisions, raise awareness about the impact of crime on individuals and society, and contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of crime patterns.
In what ways are victim surveys a useful measurement of crime?
Victim surveys are questionnaires given to members of the public asking if they have been a victim of crime, often within a specified time frame. They are seen as a useful tool for building a picture of crime alongside official police statistics. Whilst police statistics only give a limited view of crime, victim surveys offer a different perspective on the nature and extent of offending, often revealing a ‘dark figure’ of unreported and unrecorded crime.
A key strength of victim surveys is that they can provide insights into this ‘dark figure’. Hough and Mayhew, in their pioneering work on the British Crime Survey (now the Crime Survey for England and Wales), argued that victim surveys offer a more accurate picture of crime levels, particularly for offences like sexual assault and domestic violence which are often under-reported to the police. The CSEW, commissioned by the Home Office, is the largest victim study in England and Wales. It uses a large, representative sample, using structured interviews. The large sample size and representative nature of the respondents allow for generalisations to be made about the extent of crime across England and Wales. This makes it valuable for identifying trends in crime over time and for informing policy decisions.
Victim surveys are particularly useful for understanding the experiences and needs of particular groups. For example, the CSEW has been successful in developing measures to estimate the extent of domestic violence. By asking specific questions about experiences of abuse, the survey has helped to shine a light on a form of crime that is often hidden and under-reported. This information is vital for developing effective strategies to support victims and tackle the perpetrators of domestic abuse.
Furthermore, unlike police statistics, victim surveys can also explore the impact of crime on victims' lives, including the emotional, social and financial consequences. Kinsey, Jones et al, drawing on the Islington and Merseyside Crime Surveys, highlighted how such surveys provide valuable insights into the lived experiences of crime, particularly for vulnerable groups who may be more likely to be repeatedly victimised. These locally based surveys used unstructured interviews which allowed respondents to talk in detail about their experiences. For example, Young’s work on the Islington Crime Survey found that the survey revealed a far higher rate of female victimisation, especially in relation to sexual and domestic offences, than official police statistics suggested. This finding, echoed in other victim studies, fuelled radical feminist perspectives such as those of Dobash and Dobash, highlighting the pervasive nature of patriarchal control and violence against women.
Moreover, victim surveys can provide valuable information about public attitudes towards crime and the criminal justice system. By including questions about fear of crime, perceptions of anti-social behaviour, and confidence in the police, victim surveys can contribute to a more nuanced understanding of the social context of crime. For example, both Left Realists like Lea and Young and feminists have used insights from victim surveys to highlight the impact of fear of crime on people's lives, particularly women and the elderly.
However, it's important to recognise that victim surveys are not without limitations. For example, some critics argue that they are prone to issues of recall, with respondents potentially forgetting or misremembering incidents. Others highlight the potential for ‘telescoping’, where individuals include events that happened outside the specified time frame. Additionally, while the promise of confidentiality might encourage some victims to come forward, others may still be reluctant to disclose sensitive information, particularly if it involves family members or if they fear the repercussions of reporting.
In conclusion, victim surveys provide a valuable tool for measuring crime, offering insights that complement and enhance official police statistics. By revealing the ‘dark figure’ of crime, exploring the experiences of victims, and providing information about public attitudes, victim surveys contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the nature and impact of crime and inform the development of more effective crime prevention and victim support strategies.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
AO1: Knowledge and Understanding
Candidates may refer to:
- Alternative way of measuring crime – surveying people about which crimes they have been victims of in a given period.
- Insight into ‘dark figure of crime’ - crimes not reported to the police; balances information provided from police recorded crime statistics; Hough and Mayhew
- CSEW largest victim study carried out on behalf of Home Office; face-to-face structured interviews; representative sample of adults and children, therefore can generalise data.
- CSEW successful in developing measures to estimate the extent of domestic violence
- Unlike police statistics, victim surveys include questions on people’s attitudes to crime related topics e.g. anti-social behaviour.
- Confidentiality in the surveys is promised - people can talk without repercussions, therefore some are more likely to admit to being a victim of crime than report the incident to the police.
- Islington Crime Surveys used unstructured interviews to collect qualitative data on victims’ experiences of crime.
- Provided insights used in the development of Left Realist views on causes and possible solutions to crime; Lea and Young
- Islington and Merseyside Crime Surveys focused on the impact of crime on individual’s lives, especially vulnerable groups, gaining more valid insights; Kinsey, Jones et al
- Islington Survey found a higher rate of female victimisation regarding sexual and domestic offences than police statistics; Young,
- Victim research informed radical feminist views on patriarchy; Dobash and Dobash
- Left Realist and Feminists use data from victim surveys which raised awareness of the impact of fear of crime on people’s lives; Young
- The insights gained from victim surveys can be used to enhance understanding of patterns of crime published in police recorded statistics.
AO2: Application
The selected knowledge should be directly specific to the question: the ways victim surveys are a useful measurement of crime.