To what extent does the media help individuals to learn social expectations?
Cambridge
O level and GCSE
2023
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
To What Extent Does the Media Help Individuals Learn Social Expectations?
I. Arguments for
A. Ubiquitous exposure to media in today's society
B. Media's ability to shape self-perception and perception of others
C. Postmodernist view of media's cultural influence
D. Social control through social media
E. Promotion of social conformity
F. Role models in traditional and new media
G. Media's perpetuation of stereotypes and demonization of social groups
H. Labeling theory and the creation of moral panics
II. Arguments against
A. Family's primary role in teaching social expectations
B. Individuals' ability to critically evaluate media messages
C. Influence of peer groups
D. School peer groups and age-based classes
E. Education as a powerful agent of secondary socialization
F. Influence of religion and religious texts
G. Significance of the workplace in shaping values and norms
To What Extent Does the Media Help Individuals to Learn Social Expectations?
In contemporary society, the media's pervasive influence on our lives is undeniable. From the moment we wake up to the time we go to sleep, we are bombarded with messages from various media platforms, including television, films, social media, and the internet. This essay will explore the extent to which the media helps individuals to learn social expectations, considering both the arguments for and against its influence.
Arguments for the Media's Influence
Proponents of the media's significant role in shaping social expectations argue that its omnipresence makes it a powerful force. We live in a media-saturated society where children and adults alike are constantly exposed to media messages. This constant exposure, from a young age, suggests that the media plays a crucial role in shaping our understanding of the world and our place in it.
Furthermore, the media often presents stereotypical representations of different social groups. For instance, women are frequently portrayed in traditional roles, while men are often depicted as dominant and assertive. These representations can influence how individuals perceive themselves and others, shaping their expectations of appropriate behavior for different genders. As sociologist Erving Goffman argued in his book "Gender Advertisements" (1979), the media often presents a "hyperritualized" version of gender roles, exaggerating differences and reinforcing traditional expectations.
Postmodernists like Jean Baudrillard argue that the media has become so powerful that it has created a "hyperreality," where the lines between reality and simulation are blurred. In this hyperreality, the media shapes our desires and aspirations, encouraging us to consume products and lifestyles based on media images and celebrity endorsements. This consumer culture, fueled by the media, profoundly impacts social expectations and interactions.
Moreover, social media has emerged as a new form of social control. Young people, in particular, are influenced by the number of likes, followers, and friends they have on social media platforms. This constant feedback loop can impact their self-esteem and shape their understanding of social acceptance and rejection.
Arguments Against the Media's Influence
However, critics argue that while the media undeniably plays a role, other agents of socialization are far more influential in shaping social expectations. The family, for instance, is the primary agent of socialization. Through primary socialization, children learn fundamental social norms and values from their parents and immediate family members. Parents use sanctions, both positive and negative, to reinforce acceptable behavior and discourage deviance.
Moreover, individuals do not passively absorb media messages. Research suggests that people exercise discrimination and choice in what they consume and are influenced by their peers when interpreting media messages. This active audience theory, as proposed by Stuart Hall, suggests that individuals are not simply passive recipients of media messages but actively interpret and negotiate meaning based on their social background and experiences.
Peer pressure is a powerful force, particularly during adolescence. Young people are often more influenced by their peers' opinions and behaviors than by media portrayals. This is evident in traditional societies, where age groups are united by rites of passage and shared experiences, shaping their social expectations and behaviors.
Education also plays a crucial role in secondary socialization. Schools not only impart knowledge and skills but also instill social norms and values. Through interactions with teachers and peers, students learn about teamwork, discipline, and other essential social skills required for the workplace and broader society.
Furthermore, other social institutions, such as religion and the workplace, significantly shape social expectations. Religion often provides a moral framework that guides individuals' interactions and behaviors. Similarly, the workplace has its own set of norms and expectations that individuals must learn to navigate to succeed.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the media undoubtedly plays a role in shaping social expectations, it is essential to recognize that its influence is not all-encompassing. Other agents of socialization, such as the family, peers, education, religion, and the workplace, also exert significant influence. Individuals are not passive recipients of media messages but actively interpret and negotiate meaning based on their social experiences and interactions. Therefore, while the media can contribute to our understanding of social expectations, its influence should be considered within the broader context of other socializing agents.
**Sources:** * Goffman, Erving. *Gender Advertisements*. Macmillan, 1979. * Hall, Stuart. *Encoding/Decoding*. 1980.Free Mark Scheme Extracts
To what extent does the media help individuals to learn social expectations?
Arguments for:
- We live in a media-saturated society, where children and adults interact with multiple media every day, including films, TV, and social media. The media's influence extends throughout life, making it the most effective in terms of exposure.
- The media shapes how we perceive ourselves and others by manipulating representations of different groups. For example, women are often portrayed in stereotypical ways, affecting social interactions significantly.
- Postmodernists argue that the media is highly influential in shaping culture, creating a consumer culture that encourages purchasing based on celebrity endorsements or lifestyle associations.
- Social media serves as a new form of social control, impacting young people's self-identity and social interactions through likes and de-friending.
- The media promotes social conformity by showcasing the effects and consequences of deviance, such as in news stories about lawbreakers and their sentences.
- Celebrity role models in traditional and new media influence the younger generation's lifestyle, appearance, and behavior.
- The media often perpetuates stereotypes and demonizes certain social groups.
- According to labeling theory, the media can incite moral panics by creating folk devils, shaping audience perceptions of specific social groups.
Arguments against:
- The family plays a more crucial role in teaching social expectations through primary socialization and the use of sanctions by parents.
- Research indicates that individuals do not passively accept negative media messages but exercise discrimination and choice in what they absorb, often influenced by peers.
- Peer pressure holds more sway in influencing behavior, as seen in traditional societies where age groups are united by rites of passage into peer groups.
- School peer groups, formed in age-based classes, foster strong emotional bonds that can outweigh the influence of media messages.
- Education is arguably the most potent agent of secondary socialization, equipping youth with essential skills for the workplace due to the lifelong learning approach.
- In some cultures, religion wields a more powerful influence than the media, providing a moral framework for all interactions.
- Religious leaders and holy texts can have a more significant impact than media propaganda.
- The workplace plays a critical role in individuals' welfare, as they adapt to new norms and values and strive to avoid sanctions while seeking rewards like promotions and higher status.
- Any other reasonable response.