Urbanisation in developing countries often involves the growth of shanty towns with poor living conditions. Urbanisation also brings about cultural change by exposing city dwellers to Western values and practices.
Urbanisation may affect the process of development.Applying material from Item K, analyse two ways that urbanisation may affect the process of development.
AQA
A Level
2024
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Essay Outline: Urbanisation and Development
This essay will analyse two ways in which urbanisation may affect the process of development, drawing upon the provided material (Item K). The essay will first explore how the growth of shanty towns, a common phenomenon in developing urban areas, can both hinder and contribute to development. Secondly, it will examine the impact of cultural change brought about by exposure to Western values and practices on the development process.
1. Shanty Towns and Development
a. Hindered Development:Shanty towns are often characterized by poor living conditions, including inadequate sanitation, lack of access to clean water, and overcrowding. These conditions can contribute to the spread of disease and hinder development by: *
Reducing productivity: Poor health can lead to lower productivity in the workforce, ultimately slowing economic growth.
*Increasing healthcare costs: The prevalence of disease in shanty towns puts a strain on limited healthcare resources, diverting funds from other development initiatives.
*Maintaining a cycle of poverty: Lack of access to education and employment opportunities within shanty towns perpetuates poverty and hinders upward mobility.
b. Contributing to Development:Shanty towns are not solely detrimental to development. They can also serve as incubators for self-help and innovation, contributing to the development process in the following ways:
*Promoting community spirit: Shanty town residents often develop strong community ties and engage in collective efforts to improve their living conditions.
*Facilitating entrepreneurship: The informal economy thriving within shanty towns provides opportunities for residents to generate income and contribute to local economic growth.
*Developing resilience: Shanty town communities often display remarkable resilience in overcoming challenges, adapting to their environment, and contributing to the development of urban infrastructure.
2. Cultural Change and Development
a. Western Values and Modernisation:Urbanisation often exposes city dwellers to Western values and practices, leading to cultural change. Modernisation theorists argue that adopting Western values, such as individualism, achievement orientation, and rationalism, is crucial for economic growth and development. This can be achieved through: *
Promoting entrepreneurialism: Embracing Western values can encourage a more entrepreneurial spirit, fostering economic innovation and growth.
*Improving education and skills development: Adoption of Western education systems can enhance human capital and boost productivity.
*Encouraging political and social reform: Western values can foster democratic ideals and social change, leading to greater political stability and economic development.
b. Cultural Hybridity and Resistance:However, the impact of Western values on development is not always positive. There is a growing recognition of the importance of cultural hybridity and the need to avoid cultural imperialism. Adopting Western values can sometimes: *
Undermine traditional values: Uncritically adopting Western values can undermine local traditions and cultural practices, leading to societal instability.
*Reinforce existing inequalities: Western values can be seen as promoting individualism and competition, exacerbating existing social and economic inequalities.
*Lead to cultural clashes and resistance: The imposition of Western values can evoke resistance from local communities, hindering development efforts.
Conclusion
Urbanisation presents both opportunities and challenges for development. Shanty towns, while posing significant challenges, also demonstrate potential for self-help and innovation. Cultural change brought about by Western values can drive economic growth but must be carefully managed to avoid cultural imperialism and social unrest. Ultimately, achieving sustainable development in urban environments requires a nuanced approach that balances economic progress with social inclusion and cultural preservation.
Urbanisation and Development: A Two-Sided Coin
Urbanisation, the increasing concentration of population in urban areas, is a global phenomenon with profound implications for development, particularly in developing countries. While often depicted as a catalyst for progress, the reality is more nuanced. This essay will analyse two ways in which urbanisation impacts development, drawing upon the insights provided in Item K.
The Shadow of Shanty Towns
Item K highlights a stark reality of urbanisation in the developing world: the proliferation of shanty towns characterized by substandard living conditions. These informal settlements, often lacking basic amenities like proper sanitation and secure housing, trap residents in a cycle of poverty and hinder development. Overcrowding breeds health risks, while lack of secure tenure discourages investment in housing and entrepreneurship. Limited access to education and healthcare further perpetuates inequality, creating a pool of unskilled labor with restricted opportunities for upward mobility.
However, it's crucial to avoid a purely negative portrayal of shanty towns. They often exhibit a remarkable degree of self-organization and community spirit. Residents establish informal economies, providing goods and services often overlooked by formal systems. This dynamism can foster innovation and contribute to development, albeit often hampered by lack of support and recognition from authorities. Furthermore, addressing the challenges within shanty towns, such as improving infrastructure and providing land tenure security, can unlock their economic potential and improve the lives of millions.
The Allure and Disillusionment of Westernization
Item K also touches upon the cultural transformations accompanying urbanisation, particularly the exposure to Western values and practices. Modernization theorists argue that embracing these values – individualism, achievement orientation, and a market-driven economy – is essential for economic growth. Urban centers become hubs of diffusion for these ideas, fostering a shift away from traditional norms and practices perceived as impediments to progress.
However, this perspective overlooks the potential downsides of rapid cultural change. The erosion of traditional values can lead to social fragmentation and anomie. The adoption of Western consumption patterns, often fuelled by materialistic aspirations, can exacerbate inequality and environmental degradation. Moreover, assuming a singular path to development centered around Western models ignores the diverse cultural contexts and indigenous knowledge systems that can contribute to more sustainable and equitable forms of progress.
Navigating the Urban Transition
In conclusion, urbanisation presents both opportunities and challenges for development. Examining the plight of shanty towns reveals the stark inequalities amplified by rapid urban growth, but also highlights the resilience and resourcefulness within these communities. Similarly, while exposure to Western values might drive economic transformation, a nuanced approach recognizes the importance of preserving cultural diversity and fostering inclusive development. Ultimately, successful navigation of the urban transition requires acknowledging the complexities of this process and adopting policies that address the multifaceted needs of urban populations, fostering sustainable and equitable development for all.
Urbanisation in developing countries often involves the growth of shanty towns with poor living conditions. Urbanisation also brings about cultural change by exposing city dwellers to Western values and practices.
Urbanisation may affect the process of development.Applying material from Item K, analyse two ways that urbanisation may affect the process of development.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
Answers in this band will show good knowledge and understanding of relevant material on two ways that urbanisation may affect the process of development.
There will be two developed applications of material from the item, eg conditions in shanty towns keep people in poverty and hold back development; adopting Western values and practices are seen as essential to economic growth by modernisation theorists.
There will be appropriate analysis/evaluation of two ways eg of the extent to which shanty towns foster self-help and innovation, contributing to development.