Describe ways that roles in the family have become more equal.
CAMBRIDGE
A level and AS level
2022
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Briefly introduce the traditional view of gender roles in the family. State that while complete equality is debated, there's evidence suggesting a move towards more balanced roles. Outline the key areas you'll discuss.
Men's Increased Domestic Contribution
Discuss the rise of the "New Man" and increased participation in housework and childcare. Mention studies/statistics that show this trend. However, acknowledge that inequalities may persist and traditional expectations haven't entirely vanished.
Women's Evolving Roles
Highlight how women are no longer solely confined to domesticity. Discuss their rise as breadwinners and its impact on decision-making within families. Mention the growth of dual-income households and its implications for equality.
Shifting Family Dynamics
Discuss the move towards egalitarian parent-child relationships and joint conjugal roles. Mention the decline of patriarchal structures and the rise of symmetrical families. You can use examples of shared decision-making, finances, and household tasks.
Counter Arguments and Persistence of Inequality
Acknowledge that complete equality hasn't been achieved. Discuss persistent inequalities, such as the gender pay gap and the uneven division of unpaid labor. Briefly mention feminist perspectives that critique the concept of complete equality within existing societal structures.
Conclusion
Summarize the key arguments, emphasizing the shift towards more equal roles within families. Reiterate that while complete equality is debatable, significant progress has been made, challenging traditional norms and reshaping family dynamics. Conclude with a thought-provoking statement about the future of gender roles in families.
Ways Roles in the Family Have Become More Equal
The traditional nuclear family, characterised by a male breadwinner and a female homemaker, has undergone significant transformations in recent decades. Societal shifts, economic changes, and evolving gender ideologies have contributed to a greater sense of equality within families. This essay will explore some of the key ways in which roles within the family have become more balanced and equitable.
Shifting Domestic Labour Dynamics
One significant change has been the increased participation of men in housework and childcare. While women still bear a disproportionate burden in many households, research suggests a trend towards a more equitable division of domestic labour. Gershuny (2000) found that men's contribution to housework has gradually increased, particularly in younger generations. This shift can be attributed to factors such as the rise of the 'New Man' ideal, which emphasizes men's participation in domestic life, and the increasing economic necessity for dual-income households.
Women in the Workforce and Financial Decision-Making
The entry of women into the workforce in large numbers has had a profound impact on family dynamics. As more women become breadwinners or co-breadwinners, they gain greater financial independence and decision-making power within the family. This challenges traditional patriarchal structures where men held primary control over finances. Pahl (1993) argues that the control of finances within a relationship is a key indicator of power and equality.
Evolving Parenting Styles and Child-Rearing Practices
Parenting styles have also shifted towards more egalitarian approaches. The concept of 'intensive parenting,' which emphasizes equal involvement from both parents, has gained traction. This is reflected in the growing number of fathers taking on more active roles in childcare, attending school events, and engaging in emotional labour related to parenting (Dermott, 2008).
Challenges to Traditional Gender Roles
The traditional division of labour based on gender roles, with men as instrumental leaders and women as expressive caregivers, is being challenged. Beck (1992) argues that we are living in a 'risk society' where traditional structures are being eroded. This includes a questioning of rigid gender roles, with men and women increasingly sharing both instrumental and expressive responsibilities within the family.
The Role of Legislation and Social Policy
It is important to acknowledge the role of legislation and social policy in promoting gender equality within families. Policies such as parental leave for both parents, affordable childcare options, and flexible working arrangements have all contributed to creating a more equitable environment for families.
Conclusion
While complete equality within families remains an ongoing process, there is evidence of significant progress in recent decades. The increasing participation of men in domestic labour, the rise of dual-income households, and the shift towards more egalitarian parenting styles all point towards a more balanced and equitable distribution of roles within the family. However, challenges remain in terms of addressing persistent gender inequalities in areas such as pay gaps and societal expectations. Continued efforts are needed to promote a society where all family members have equal opportunities and are valued for their contributions.
References
- Beck, U. (1992). Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. Sage Publications.
- Dermott, E. (2008). Intimate Fatherhood: A Sociological Analysis. Routledge.
- Gershuny, J. (2000). Changing Times: Work and Leisure in Postindustrial Society. Oxford University Press.
- Pahl, J. (1993). Money and Marriage. Macmillan.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
Ways Roles in the Family Have Become More Equal
- Men taking on a greater share of housework: The rise of the 'New Man' has resulted in women no longer being burdened with doing most or all of the housework.
- Increased involvement of men in childcare: The growth of 'new dads' indicates a shift in responsibility for childcare, reducing the likelihood of it falling solely on the woman or mother.
- Females participating in decision-making: Women are now taking on a more active role in decision-making within the family, thereby reducing the influence of traditional patriarchy.
- Women becoming breadwinners alongside men: More women are entering the workforce as breadwinners, leading to greater decision-making power in relationships.
- Egalitarian parent-child relationships: Children are no longer seen as powerless, and they are playing a more significant role in decision-making processes within the family.
- Joint conjugal roles and symmetrical families: There is an increase in men and women sharing traditional instrumental and expressive roles more equally.
- Growth of dual-income families: Both men and women are contributing as breadwinners for the family, fostering equality in financial responsibilities and decision-making.
- Other appropriate ways not specified above.