top of page
Previous
Next Essay

Explain one strength and one limitation of New Right views of the family.

CAMBRIDGE

A level and AS level

2023

👑Complete Model Essay

Free Essay Plan

Introduction

Briefly introduce the New Right perspective on family. State that while this perspective offers some valid points, it suffers from several limitations.

Strengths

Socialization and Social Stability

Explain how the New Right view emphasizes the importance of the nuclear family in providing adequate socialization, which they argue is crucial for social stability. Mention their concerns about the rise in lone-parent families and its potential impact.

Limitations

Ignoring Family Diversity

Critique the New Right's narrow focus on the nuclear family. Highlight the diversity of family structures in contemporary society and argue that other forms can be equally successful in raising children.

Outdated Views on Gender Roles

Challenge the New Right’s traditional view of gender roles. Emphasize the economic capabilities of women and their ability to be successful breadwinners, rendering the traditional nuclear model outdated.

Conclusion

Reiterate the limitations of the New Right perspective, emphasizing its outdated and limited view of family. Conclude by suggesting a more nuanced approach to understanding family structures in contemporary society.

## The Irreplaceable Role of the Nuclear Family in Social Stability

The family, a fundamental unit of society, plays a crucial role in shaping individuals and maintaining social order. While family structures have diversified in recent decades, the nuclear family, consisting of two married parents and their children, remains the bedrock of a stable and prosperous society. This essay will argue that the decline of the nuclear family, particularly due to the rise of lone parenthood, has detrimental effects on socialization and, consequently, societal well-being.

Inadequate Socialization and its Societal Costs

The nuclear family provides the ideal environment for the effective socialization of children. Socialization, the process of learning societal norms and values, is most effectively achieved through the consistent and complementary roles of a mother and a father. The mother, traditionally seen as the primary caregiver, provides emotional support and nurturing, fostering a sense of security and belonging in the child. The father, as the traditional breadwinner, models discipline, responsibility, and resilience, crucial traits for navigating the challenges of adulthood.

Conversely, the absence of one parent, as seen in lone-parent families, often leads to inadequate socialization. Numerous studies have linked growing up in single-parent households with increased risks of delinquency, teenage pregnancy, and poor educational attainment. For instance, research by McLanahan and Sandefur (1994) found that children raised in single-parent homes are twice as likely to drop out of high school compared to their counterparts in two-parent families.

Economic Stability and the Nuclear Family

Furthermore, the nuclear family provides a more stable economic foundation compared to single-parent households. The combined income of two parents allows for greater financial security, providing children with better access to resources and opportunities essential for their development. This economic stability translates into a more stable society, with lower rates of poverty, crime, and reliance on social welfare programs.

Addressing Counterarguments

Critics may argue that diverse family structures, such as single-parent families or same-sex couples raising children, can provide equally effective socialization and care. While it is crucial to acknowledge the love and commitment within diverse families, it is equally important to recognize that the traditional family structure offers a unique and optimal framework for child-rearing. Decades of sociological research consistently demonstrate the social and economic benefits of the nuclear family model.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the nuclear family remains the cornerstone of a stable and thriving society. The complementary roles of a mother and a father within this structure provide the ideal environment for the effective socialization of children, leading to greater social and economic well-being. While recognizing the existence and importance of diverse family forms, it is essential to prioritize and strengthen the nuclear family as the foundation for a prosperous and harmonious society.

**References:** McLanahan, S., & Sandefur, G. (1994). Growing Up with a Single Parent: What Hurts, What Helps. Harvard University Press.
Explain one strength and one limitation of New Right views of the family.

Free Mark Scheme Extracts

Strengths:

- Recognizes the negative impact on society of inadequate socialization due to the increase in lone parent mothers.

- Highlights the importance of the nuclear family in bringing social stability through providing appropriate socialization of children.

Limitations:

- Fails to positively recognize family diversity/the benefits of family diversity.

- Outdated as underestimates capability of women to fulfill the economic needs of the family/just as capable as men as breadwinners.

bottom of page