Explain practical factors to consider when conducting observational studies.
CAMBRIDGE
A level and AS level
2023
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Practical Factors in Observational Research
This essay will explore the practical considerations that researchers must address when conducting observational studies. These challenges arise from the nature of observational research, where the researcher aims to understand social phenomena by directly observing and interacting with individuals or groups in their natural settings.
Taking Notes and Recording Events
One key practical challenge is **recording observations**. This can be particularly difficult in participant observation where the researcher is actively involved in the group and may need to balance note-taking with their participation. This can be addressed using techniques such as:
- Taking brief field notes during observations and then expanding on them later.
- Using audio or video recording devices, but with ethical considerations in mind.
- Employing a research assistant to take notes while the researcher observes.
Gaining Acceptance and Fitting In
Observational research, especially participant observation, requires researchers to** gain acceptance from the group**. This can be challenging if the researcher is from a different social group or if their presence is disruptive. Strategies for overcoming this include:
- Building rapport with group members through empathy, active listening, and shared experiences.
- Adopting appropriate dress, language, and behaviour to fit in with the group.
- Clearly explaining the research purpose and gaining informed consent.
Maintaining Cover in Covert Observation
Covert observation poses unique challenges, as the researcher must **maintain their identity as an observer** while participating in the group. This requires meticulous planning and execution, including:
- Developing a believable cover story and maintaining consistency in their persona.
- Controlling their behavior and interactions to avoid suspicion.
- Managing the ethical implications of deception and potential risks.
Gaining Access to the Group
Researchers need to **secure access to the group** they intend to study. This can be challenging due to factors such as:
- Gatekeepers who control access to the group, requiring negotiation and trust-building.
- The group's own internal dynamics and potential reluctance to participate in research.
- The researcher's own social capital and connections within the network.
Time and Cost Considerations
Observational studies can be **time-consuming and costly**, especially those conducted over long periods. This may involve:
- Significant time investment in observing and recording data.
- Travel expenses, accommodation, and other logistical costs.
- Opportunity costs associated with the researcher's time and effort.
Exiting the Group and Maintaining Ethical Considerations
Researchers must consider **how to exit the group** after the study, particularly in participant observation. This requires:
- Communicating the conclusion of the study to the group members and thanking them for their participation.
- Maintaining the anonymity of individuals and protecting their privacy.
- Avoiding potential harm or disruption to the group during the exit process.
Obtaining a Holistic View of the Group
Observational research aims to provide a **holistic understanding** of the group and its activities. This can be challenging as researchers may be limited by:
- Their own biases and perspectives, influencing their interpretations.
- The specific contexts and situations they observe, potentially limiting the scope of their findings.
- The availability of data and information, which may be incomplete or inaccessible.
Conclusion
This essay has outlined crucial practical considerations for conducting observational research. By addressing these challenges effectively, researchers can maximize the validity and reliability of their findings while upholding ethical standards. By demonstrating an awareness of these practicalities, sociologists can produce more insightful and rigorous observational studies that contribute meaningfully to our understanding of social phenomena.
Practical Factors in Observational Studies
Observational studies, particularly participant observation, present researchers with a unique set of practical challenges. Successfully navigating these challenges is crucial for gathering rich, valid data. This essay will explore some of the key practical factors researchers must consider when conducting observational studies.
Gaining Access and Acceptance
A fundamental hurdle in observational research, especially in ethnography, is gaining access to the group being studied. This can be particularly difficult if the researcher is perceived as an outsider. Patrick's (1973) study of a Glasgow gang highlights this challenge. He gained access through a contact but faced initial suspicion and hostility. Building rapport and trust is essential, often requiring prolonged engagement and demonstrating respect for the group's norms and values.
Maintaining Cover and Objectivity
Covert observation poses the ethical dilemma of deception and the practical challenge of maintaining cover. Researchers must convincingly adopt the group's behavior and language, risking "going native" and losing objectivity. Festinger et al.'s (1956) study of a doomsday cult involved researchers posing as believers. While they successfully gathered data, the ethical implications of such deception remain debated.
Note-Taking and Recording
Recording observations accurately and unobtrusively is crucial. In overt settings, researchers may use notebooks or audio recorders openly. However, covert observation often necessitates relying on memory and discreet note-taking later, potentially leading to data loss or distortion. Humphreys' (1970) controversial study of homosexual encounters in public restrooms exemplifies the ethical and practical complexities of covert data collection.
Time, Cost, and Holistic Perspective
Longitudinal observational studies, particularly ethnographic research, demand considerable time and financial resources. Researchers must immerse themselves in the field, sometimes for months or years, incurring living expenses, travel costs, and research materials. Maintaining a holistic perspective can also be challenging, requiring researchers to balance detailed observations with broader contextual understanding.
Exiting the Field
Leaving the field presents its own set of challenges, especially in covert research where revealing one's true identity can have repercussions. Researchers must carefully manage their exit to minimize disruption to the group and ensure their own safety. The emotional impact on both the researcher and the participants should also be considered.
Conclusion
Conducting observational studies, particularly participant observation, necessitates careful consideration of various practical factors. From gaining access and maintaining objectivity to managing data collection and ethical considerations, researchers must navigate a complex web of challenges. By addressing these challenges thoughtfully and rigorously, researchers can harness the power of observation to generate valuable sociological insights.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
Practical Factors to Consider When Conducting Observational Studies:
- Taking notes/recording events (particularly if participating). - Gaining acceptance from/fitting in with the group (particularly if from a different social group). - Maintaining cover (if covert). - Gaining access to the group. - Time involved. - Cost of the study (if conducted over a long period of time). - How to exit the group (particularly if a covert participant). - How to get a holistic view of the study group/activities (particularly if participating). - Any other relevant argument.
In addressing this question, one can demonstrate the use of sociological material by referring to methodological concepts or providing examples related to specific research methods.